Exploring Earth's Oceans Since 1999 · Founded by Blane Perun
3,072 Articles·80+ Countries·25 Years of Ocean Science·Site Map
◆ Trending
25 years exploring Earth's oceans,
coral reefs, and the creatures within.
3,072Articles
80+Countries
1999Founded

What made Charles Vane different from other pirates of his time

What Made Charles Vane Different From Other Pirates of His Time

Pirates
15 min read
The short answer

Charles Vane was the most prominent pirate in Nassau to reject the King’s pardon outright and to fight his way past the new governor, Woodes Rogers, in July 1718. He was not the only holdout, but he led the faction that opposed surrender, sent a fireship against the governor’s squadron, fired on a warship as he escaped and kept threatening to retake the island. He was also unusually cruel to captives, and his own crew voted him out of command for refusing to fight a French warship. He was captured after a shipwreck in 1719 and hanged in Jamaica in March 1721.

Charles Vane at a glance
Born
c. 1680, probably England
Active
1716–1719
Pardon
Led the Nassau faction that rejected it
Deposed
November 1718, crew vote for Jack Rackham
Captured
1719, after a shipwreck in the Bay of Honduras
Executed
29 March 1721, Gallows Point, Port Royal

The Golden Age of Piracy produced dozens of notorious captains, and most of their careers followed a familiar arc: a few seasons of raiding, a pardon or a quiet retirement when the authorities offered one, or capture and the gallows. Charles Vane’s career was short, about three years at sea as a pirate, but at nearly every turning point he chose confrontation where his contemporaries chose compromise. That is what makes him stand out, and it also explains why his career ended the way it did. Some popular accounts exaggerate the story, claiming he was the only pirate to refuse the pardon or that he raided for years after the Bahamas were retaken. The documented record is more interesting than the myth.

Who was Charles Vane?

Very little is known about Vane’s early life. He was probably born in England around 1680 and lived in Port Royal, Jamaica, before he turned pirate. He first appears in the record as one of the men who followed Henry Jennings in his 1716 raid on the Spanish salvage camp on the Florida coast, where survivors of the 1715 Treasure Fleet were recovering silver from the wrecks. Jennings’ men seized a large haul and carried it to Nassau on New Providence in the Bahamas, an island that had been left without effective English government since French and Spanish attacks in the early 1700s.

Nassau became the base of the loose pirate community that the historian Colin Woodard calls the Republic of Pirates. It had no formal government. Crews elected their captains, shared plunder under written articles and treated other pirate crews with rough civility. By the summer of 1717 Vane was commanding his own vessel, and by that winter he was one of the leading captains on the island, alongside older figures such as Benjamin Hornigold and Jennings himself.

Pirate brigantine sailing past a Royal Navy squadron with a fireship burning at sunset - Charles Vane
Charles Vane

What did the King’s pardon actually offer?

On 5 September 1717, George I issued the Proclamation for Suppressing of Pirates, usually called the Act of Grace. It promised a pardon for piracies committed before 5 January 1718 to any pirate who surrendered to a secretary of state or a colonial governor on or before 5 September 1718. The deadline was later extended to 1 July 1719, and the cut-off date for covered crimes was moved forward, to 23 July 1718 in general and to 18 August 1718 in the commissions given to Rogers and to Virginia’s governor, Alexander Spotswood.

News of the offer reached Nassau in December 1717, carried by the son of Bermuda’s lieutenant governor, Benjamin Bennett. It split the pirates into two camps. One group, including Hornigold and Jennings, was ready to accept. The other, which included men with Jacobite sympathies who regarded the Hanoverian king as illegitimate, wanted to fortify the island and hold it. Vane led that second faction. A general council of the pirates was called but agreed on nothing.

On 23 February 1718, Captain Vincent Pearse arrived from New York in the frigate HMS Phoenix to receive surrenders. Pirates who intended to take the pardon told Pearse’s men where to find Vane, and his sloop, the Lark, was seized with its crew. Hornigold and several other captains then persuaded Pearse to release Vane as a gesture of good faith, and Vane declared that he too would accept the pardon. Pearse compiled a list of 209 pirates who said they intended to surrender, fewer than half the pirates on the island. Within weeks Vane had broken his word. On 21 March he and his men, among them Edward England and John “Calico Jack” Rackham, captured a Jamaican sloop, harassed the Phoenix’s crew, and recovered the Lark, which they later renamed the Ranger. Vane left Nassau on 4 April; Pearse sailed four days later, leaving the pirates in control again.

How did Vane escape Woodes Rogers?

Rogers, a former privateer famous for rescuing the castaway Alexander Selkirk, had been appointed governor of the Bahamas in January 1718. He sailed from the Thames in April with settlers, soldiers and an escort of Royal Navy warships, and arrived off Nassau in late July. Most modern accounts give 24 July 1718 for his arrival; other accounts give dates between 22 and 26 July. Vane was in the harbour with a large captured French ship and his sloop.

Vane’s response combined bargaining and force. He and his company sent the governor a letter saying they would accept the pardon if they could keep and dispose of their plunder as they pleased; if not, they would defend themselves. When that went unanswered, the pirates set the French prize on fire and let it drift toward the warships at the harbour mouth. The fireship did little damage, but it forced the naval vessels to cut their cables and pull away. During the night and next morning Vane’s men took on supplies and a local pilot, then slipped out through the narrow eastern channel, which was too shallow for the warships, in a small sloop. According to Captain Charles Johnson’s General History of the Pyrates, they sailed out “with their piratical colours flying” and fired on one of the men-of-war as they went.

The escape was a genuine tactical success, but it did not save the republic. Rogers landed, took control of Nassau and the island’s old fort, and pardoned the pirates who had stayed. Vane kept the governor nervous for months afterwards. He wrote that he would join forces with Blackbeard and come back to take the island, and Rogers also had to worry about a Spanish attack. Rogers set the island’s population to rebuilding the fortifications and later declared martial law.

Was he really the only pirate to refuse the pardon?

No, and this is the most common error in popular accounts of Vane. Plenty of pirates refused, or accepted and then went back to sea. Rogers estimated that about 150 men left New Providence between the end of July and late October 1718, some of them hoping to join Vane. That September, the crew of the Buck, a sloop Rogers had brought with him, mutinied and turned pirate; its new crew included Howell Davis and Thomas Anstis, both of whom became notorious captains. In October, pardoned pirates led by John Auger seized three trading sloops. Elsewhere, Blackbeard had accepted a pardon from Governor Charles Eden of North Carolina in mid-1718, but he too continued to operate on the margins of the law.

What distinguished Vane was not refusal as such but the way he refused. He was the recognised leader of the resisting faction, he dealt with Rogers directly and on his own terms, he used force against the governor’s squadron, and he then spent months openly threatening to return. Other pirates drifted away quietly; Vane made a political point of it. Woodard and other historians link this stance to the Jacobite sympathies common among the pirates who rejected the pardon, although there is no direct evidence of Vane’s own political opinions.

How did Vane treat his captives?

Violence toward prisoners was common among pirates, who often beat or threatened captured sailors to make them reveal hidden money. Even by those standards, Vane had a reputation for cruelty. In April 1718 his crew captured the Bermuda sloop Diamond, and one of its crew, Nathaniel Catling, later testified that he had been hanged by the neck until he was thought to be dead and then slashed with a cutlass. Other captives described being beaten, and one account describes a sailor tortured with burning matches to make him reveal where valuables were hidden. Complaints from Bermuda reached the island’s governor, and the stories travelled through the colonial ports.

This sets Vane apart from several of his best-known contemporaries. Hornigold was known for his reluctance to attack English ships. Samuel Bellamy’s crew sometimes gave captured ships back to their owners when they had no use for them. Blackbeard cultivated a fearsome appearance, but historians have found little evidence that he killed anyone before his final battle. Vane’s reputation was built on what his crews actually did to prisoners, and it made merchant crews more likely to surrender without a fight. It also made him an obvious target for colonial governments and gave his own men little reason to be loyal to him personally.

What happened at Charles Town?

After escaping Nassau, Vane worked for a time with Charles Yeats, the original captain of the sloop in which he had escaped, and took several vessels off the Bahamas. One captured brigantine became his new flagship. In late August 1718 he moved north to the approaches of Charles Town (now Charleston), South Carolina, where he took eight ships in a few days. Among them, according to Johnson, was Captain Thompson’s brigantine from Guinea with “ninety odd” enslaved Africans on board, whom Vane transferred to Yeats’ sloop.

Yeats had tired of Vane’s domineering command. One evening he slipped his cable and ran for shore with the sloop and its human cargo. He sent word to the governor of South Carolina and surrendered in exchange for a pardon. The Charles Town merchants then fitted out two armed sloops under Colonel William Rhett to hunt Vane. Rhett never found him, but in late September his ships found Stede Bonnet careening in the Cape Fear River, captured him after a battle, and brought him back to Charles Town, where he was hanged in December 1718. Vane’s raid therefore led indirectly to the capture of another well-known pirate.

Why did Vane meet Blackbeard at Ocracoke?

In October 1718 Vane sailed to Ocracoke Inlet on the Outer Banks of North Carolina, where Edward Teach, better known as Blackbeard, was anchored. The two crews spent several days drinking and celebrating together, in what has been called the largest gathering of pirates in North American waters. Some accounts say Vane tried to persuade Blackbeard to join him in retaking Nassau; if so, Blackbeard declined, and the two crews went their separate ways. Within weeks, on 22 November 1718, Blackbeard was killed at Ocracoke by a naval force under Lieutenant Robert Maynard, sent by Virginia’s governor, Alexander Spotswood. The meeting marked the end of the period in which the major Bahamas pirates still operated as a loose network.

Why did his own crew depose him?

Pirate crews operated under articles that limited the captain’s power. Johnson’s General History explains that a pirate captain had absolute authority only “in fighting, chasing, or being chased”; in all other matters he was governed by a majority of the crew, and the quartermaster, elected by the men, controlled the division of plunder and discipline. A captain who lost the crew’s confidence could simply be voted out.

In late November 1718, Vane’s brigantine and a consort sloop were cruising the Windward Passage between Cuba and Hispaniola, “between Cape Meise and Cape Nicholas” in Johnson’s words. They gave chase to a large ship that turned out to be a French man-of-war, which answered their black flag with a French ensign and opened fire. Vane judged that his ships were outgunned and ordered a retreat. Rackham, his quartermaster, argued that they should board her, since a prize that size would give them a far stronger ship. Vane overruled him, as he was entitled to do during a chase, and they escaped.

The next day the crew took its revenge. They passed a resolution branding Vane a coward and voted him out, electing Rackham captain in his place, on or about 24 November 1718. Only his mate, Robert Deal, and about fifteen others stood with him. They were given a small sloop with some arms and supplies and sent away. The episode shows the limits of authority built on fear. Vane had acted within the rules, and his decision was probably sensible, but he had no reserve of goodwill when the crew turned against him. Rackham himself took a pardon from Rogers in 1719, returned to piracy with Anne Bonny and Mary Read, and was hanged at Port Royal in November 1720.

How was Charles Vane finally captured?

Vane and Deal sailed toward the Bay Islands off Honduras, taking small vessels as they went, and Deal took command of one of them. In February 1719 a storm separated the two, and Vane’s sloop was wrecked on a small uninhabited island near the Bay of Honduras. He survived with very few companions and lived for a time on what passing turtle fishermen brought him.

Eventually a ship from Jamaica called at the island. Its captain, a former buccaneer named Holford, knew Vane and refused to take him aboard: “Charles, I shan’t trust you aboard my ship, unless I carry you a prisoner.” Vane then talked his way aboard another ship under a false name. When that ship met Holford’s, Holford recognised him, had him put in irons and took him to Jamaica, where he was handed to the authorities. He spent a long period in prison while Deal was tried, convicted and hanged before him.

When and where was Vane tried and executed?

Vane was tried before a Vice-Admiralty court at Spanish Town, Jamaica, on 22 March 1721. He called no witnesses and asked no questions, and he was found guilty of piracy and sentenced to death. On 29 March 1721 he was hanged at Gallows Point, Port Royal, the same place where many pirates of the period were executed, and his body was hung in chains on Gun Cay, a small island at the entrance to Kingston Harbour, as a warning to passing sailors.

Some sources give the trial year as 1720. This is not a real disagreement but a calendar issue. Until 1752, England began the legal year on 25 March, so a date in early March was written as 1720 in the Old Style calendar, even though it falls in 1721 by modern reckoning. Writers of the time often wrote it as 1720/21. Modern historians, including Woodard, use 1721.

So what really made Vane different?

Taken together, the record points to four things. First, he was the leader of the irreconcilables. Many pirates rejected the pardon, but Vane organised the resistance, negotiated with the governor as an equal, fought his way out of Nassau and threatened to return. Second, he was harder on prisoners than most of his peers, and his cruelty was described in sworn testimony, not just in later legend. Third, he was a capable tactician who escaped a naval blockade, raided a major colonial port and evaded several hunting expeditions. Fourth, his authority depended on fear, and that made him vulnerable. When his judgement was questioned in a single encounter, the crew removed him almost at once.

Some claims about Vane should be dropped. He did not raid for three more years after Nassau fell; his active career ended with the shipwreck in early 1719, and he spent most of the time before his execution in prison. He was not uniquely defiant, since dozens of other pirates refused or ignored the pardon. And he did not die fighting; he was arrested after being recognised by an old acquaintance, which is a fitting end for a man whose career was built on reputation.

How do we know about Vane?

The best-known source is A General History of the Robberies and Murders of the Most Notorious Pyrates, published in London in 1724 under the name Captain Charles Johnson. The book’s author has never been identified with certainty. The scholar John Robert Moore attributed it to Daniel Defoe in 1932, but that attribution was challenged in 1988 by P. N. Furbank and W. R. Owens and is no longer widely accepted. Johnson drew on trial records, newspapers and interviews, but he also embroidered, so historians treat it carefully. Modern historians, notably Colin Woodard in The Republic of Pirates (2007), have tested it against colonial correspondence, naval logs and court records in the British archives, which confirm most of the main events of Vane’s career.

Vane has had a second career on screen. He is a major character in the Starz television series Black Sails (2014–2017), played by Zach McGowan as a more sympathetic and principled figure than the historical record suggests. He appears in the 2013 video game Assassin’s Creed IV: Black Flag, voiced by Ralph Ineson, and in the 2021 Netflix docudrama series The Lost Pirate Kingdom, which follows the rise and fall of the Nassau pirates. Most of these portrayals focus on his defiance of Rogers, which is the part of his story that is best documented.

1718
Year he broke through Rogers’ blockade at Nassau
~16
Men who stayed with him when he was deposed
1721
Year he was hanged at Port Royal
“Vane wasn’t the only pirate who said no to the pardon, but he was the one who said it to the governor’s face, with a fireship.”
— Blane Perun, TheSea.Org
Frequently asked questions

Was Charles Vane the only pirate to refuse the pardon?

No. He led the Nassau faction that rejected it, and many others refused or later returned to piracy, but he was the most prominent and the only one to fight his way past Woodes Rogers.

Why was Charles Vane deposed?

In November 1718 he refused to fight a French warship in the Windward Passage. His crew branded him a coward and elected Jack Rackham captain.

What was Charles Vane’s ship called?

His best-known vessel was the Ranger, the renamed sloop Lark; later a captured brigantine also served as his flagship.

Did Charles Vane meet Blackbeard?

Yes. Their crews spent several days together at Ocracoke Inlet, North Carolina, in October 1718.

How did Charles Vane die?

He was hanged for piracy at Gallows Point, Port Royal, Jamaica, on 29 March 1721, and his body was gibbeted on Gun Cay.

Was Charles Vane a real person?

Yes. His career is documented in colonial records and trial testimony as well as Johnson’s 1724 General History; the Black Sails character is a fictionalised version.

Sources & further reading
  1. Johnson, Captain Charles. A General History of the Robberies and Murders of the Most Notorious Pyrates (1724), chapter on Charles Vane (Standard Ebooks edition).
  2. Woodard, Colin. The Republic of Pirates. Harcourt, 2007.
  3. George I. A Proclamation for Suppressing of Pirates, 5 September 1717, and later extensions.
  4. World History Encyclopedia, “Charles Vane” (testimony of the Diamond crew; capture and execution).
  5. Golden Age of Piracy, “Charles Vane” (letter to Rogers; trial at Spanish Town).
  6. Lee, Robert E. Blackbeard the Pirate: A Reappraisal of His Life and Times. John F. Blair, 1974.
BP
Last updated May 18, 2026
Written by
Blane Perun

Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.

About Blane Perun →
Coral Aquaculture · The Pioneer Story
Blane Perun, A coral aquaculture pioneer

Built one of the first home reef tanks designed as a multi-zone replica of natural reef conditions. Author of long-form profiles cited by Wikipedia, Quality Marine, and SeaScope. Independent — no advertisers, no sponsored placements, no editorial board outside the dive log.

Widely credited as the pioneer of named-coral culture in the reef-keeping hobby. The original — “Perun's Purple People Eater”, a Protopalythoa morph from his coral farm — became the first hobbyist coral to carry an aquaculturist's name in trade, sparking the now-standard practice of naming individual coral strains across the industry.

Founded1999 Articles3,072 Countries80+ Cited inWikipedia · Quality Marine · SeaScope
Read Blane's full bio →
The Dispatch · Monthly

Field notes from eighty countries worth of ocean.

One monthly email. New long-form reporting, species profiles, and dive reports — no filler, no tracking pixels, no sponsored placements. Ever.

Sign up and get my one-click underwater color-correction actions for Photoshop — the set I run on my own dive shots. Free.

Get the action now + monthly field notes
No spam · Unsubscribe anytime
Underwater reef photo before and after Blane Perun's Photoshop color-correction action — washed-out blue-green on the left, full natural color restored on the right
Same shot · one click