The Japanese Pufferfish’s Underwater Circles — A 12 cm Fish That Sculpts 2 m Sand Art
The mysterious “crop circles” on the seafloor off Amami Oshima, southern Japan, are made by a male white-spotted pufferfish, Torquigener albomaculosus. The fish is only about 10–12 cm long, yet over 7–9 days it ploughs the sand with its fins into a symmetrical nest about 2 m across, with radiating ridges and a fine-sand centre. Females choose mates by the quality of the circle, spawn in the middle, and the male guards the eggs until they hatch about six days later.
Who makes the underwater circles off Japan?
A long-running diving mystery with a very small culprit: a male pufferfish about the length of your hand.
From 1995, divers around Amami Oshima, an island in the subtropical Ryukyu chain of southern Japan, began reporting perfect geometric circles in the sand. Each was about two metres across, with ridges and valleys radiating from a flat centre like the spokes of a wheel or the petals of a flower. They appeared, lasted a few days and vanished. Nobody knew what made them, and the patterns became known as “mystery circles”, the seafloor’s answer to crop circles.
The answer came in 2011, when the underwater photographer Yoji Okata and a television crew filmed a small male pufferfish building one. The fish turned out to be a species new to science. Hiroshi Kawase of the Natural History Museum and Institute, Chiba, worked with Okata and Kazuo Ito to document the behaviour over two breeding seasons, and their study appeared in Scientific Reports in 2013. The ichthyologist Keiichi Matsuura formally described the species as Torquigener albomaculosus, the white-spotted pufferfish, with the description dated 2014.
When Kawase’s team did their fieldwork, the fish had only been found in coastal waters off southern Amami Oshima. Despite extensive scuba searches at less than 30 metres around the island, it turned up in small numbers in a few very restricted areas, off Seisui and Katetsu, where the team set up observation plots on the sand at 23–28 metres and 18–23 metres deep.

How does the pufferfish build its circle?
Working alone for seven to nine days, the male digs radial valleys from the outside in, then sorts and sculpts fine sand in the centre.
The 2013 study followed ten male reproductive cycles in the two observation areas. Each male built his own circular structure, and it took seven to nine days to complete. The radius of the finished structures measured 79–105 cm, with a central zone 31–50 cm in radius, and each had 24 to 32 pairs of radial peaks and valleys.
Construction followed three stages. In the early stage, the male laid out the basic circle. Swimming in straight lines along the bottom, he dug valleys in the sand by flapping his pectoral, anal and tail fins, always moving from the outside of the circle toward the inside and at varying angles, so that radially aligned peaks and valleys formed around the edge. By briefly pausing his fin-flapping as he moved inward, he left small bumps and dips along the valleys. In the centre, he swam in random directions, stirring the sand into a flat area.
In the middle stage he refined the structure, repeating his inward passes until the peaks and valleys were sharp and clearly defined, and swimming in circles in the centre to flatten and widen it. When he swam outward through the inner part of the ring, fine sand particles were stirred up and flowed toward the middle. In the final stage, on the day before and the day of spawning, he drew an irregular pattern of fine sand in the central zone by flapping his anal fin against the bottom, and he decorated the peaks with fragments of shell and coral picked up from the centre and valleys.
A 2018 study by Ryosuke Mizuuchi, Kawase and colleagues analysed the outer ring in more detail, recording the entry position, length and direction of each ditch. A computer simulation that followed the same simple rules, digging from the outside in, starting low and moving in straight lines, reproduced the circle pattern. The complex geometry, in other words, emerges from the repetition of a few simple actions, much as termite mounds emerge from simple behaviours of individual termites.
| Stage | What the male does | Timing |
|---|---|---|
| Early | Swims in straight lines from outside to inside, digging radial valleys with his fins; stirs the centre flat | First one to two days |
| Middle | Repeats the radial passes to sharpen peaks and valleys; widens the central zone; swims outward to push fine sand to the centre | Most of the week |
| Final | Draws an irregular pattern of fine sand in the centre with his anal fin; decorates the peaks with shell and coral fragments | Day before and day of spawning |
| Courtship | Females visit; the male stirs up sand in the centre and rushes toward the female | Final stage only |
| Spawning | The pair spawn and eggs are released in the central zone | Spring to summer |
| Egg care | Male stays with the eggs and stops maintaining the ridges, which collapse | About 6 days, until hatching |
Why does the pufferfish make circles?
The circle is both a courtship display and a nest. Females judge it, spawn in its centre, and the male guards the eggs there.
Females visited a male’s nest only during the final stage of construction. When a female approached, the male stirred up the sand in the centre; when she entered, he retreated and then rushed toward her several times. Females stayed in the nest for about a minute, left, and often came back to the same nest. Spawning happened in pairs, and the eggs were released into the central zone.
The researchers concluded that females evaluate features of the nest when choosing a mate, but exactly which features matter is still unknown. The candidates include the size and symmetry of the circle, the height and number of the peaks, the size, colour, number and arrangement of the shell decorations, and the amount, quality and design of the fine sand in the centre. The team noted that three features had never been reported in any fish before: radially aligned peaks and valleys outside the nest, decorations of shell fragments on those peaks, and an irregular pattern of fine sand gathered in the centre. All three were completed before females visited and collapsed afterwards.
The ridges also do practical work. As the male digs, smaller sand particles settle on the valley surfaces, and his later outward swims push them toward the centre. In a flow-tank experiment using a half-scale model, water flowing over the structure turned toward the centre in the valleys on the upstream side, whatever direction the current came from, and current speed in the central zone was 24.2% lower than outside the circle. A 2022 study that reconstructed a circle in three dimensions confirmed that water passing through the upstream valleys always gathers in the centre, and that the structure extracts fine sand from the valleys and directs it inward. The circle is therefore a machine for gathering fine sand and calming the water over the eggs, as well as a signal to females.
Why does the male build a new circle every time?
Probably because one breeding cycle uses up the fine sand, so an old nest is no longer worth reusing.
After spawning, males stayed in the circle for about six days caring for the eggs. During that time they did no digging or maintenance, so currents gradually collapsed and smoothed the structure until it was almost flat, and the fine sand in the centre was dispersed and replaced by coarser sand. Once the eggs hatched, the males left and soon began a new circle at a separate site. They never returned to an old one.
That is unusual. In many nest-building fish, nest sites are valuable resources that males defend and reuse cycle after cycle. The yellow-margin triggerfish, for example, digs crater-like nests 1.5–2.5 metres across and returns to the same site for each breeding cycle. Given that a pufferfish circle takes a week to build, why not reuse it? Kawase and colleagues suggested that a single cycle consumes a large share of the fine sand particles available in the valleys, so males must move to fresh sand where enough fine particles remain. Fine sand also flows away unless it is continually replenished, which is another reason an abandoned circle cannot simply be revived.
Are there pufferfish circles outside Japan?
Yes. In 2018, similar circles were found more than 100 metres deep off Western Australia.
For years the mystery circles were known only from Japan, in water less than 30 metres deep. Then, during a 2018 survey of oil and gas infrastructure on the North West Shelf of Western Australia, a remotely operated vehicle and a hybrid autonomous underwater vehicle recorded 21 circular formations with features very similar to the Japanese circles, at depths of 129 to 137 metres. High-resolution photographs captured a Torquigener pufferfish next to the circles, and another circle and pufferfish were recorded nearby at 129 metres by baited underwater cameras.
The study, published in the Journal of Fish Biology in 2020 by Todd Bond and colleagues, could not identify the Australian species from the images. Its discovery suggests that circle-building may be more widespread among Torquigener pufferfishes than anyone realised, and that it can happen in the dim mesophotic zone, far below where divers usually look. Other undiscovered circles may be waiting on sandy seafloors elsewhere.

What kind of fish is the white-spotted pufferfish?
A small member of the pufferfish family, Tetraodontidae, in a genus of sand-dwelling Indo-Pacific puffers.
The genus Torquigener contains small pufferfishes that live over sand in the Indo-Pacific, many of them in Australian waters. The white-spotted pufferfish is about 10–12 cm long and was distinguished from its relatives by the arrangement of small spinules on its body and its colour pattern, which did not match any known species. Its name, albomaculosus, means “white-spotted”.
Before the circles were explained, very little was known about the breeding behaviour of pufferfishes from direct underwater observation. Shallow-reef puffers of the genus Canthigaster mate in pairs and lay eggs on algae, and neither parent tends them. Some close relatives of pufferfish, the leatherjackets and triggerfishes, lay eggs on sandy bottoms, and some triggerfish guard them. The white-spotted pufferfish’s combination of an elaborate decorated structure, female choice and male egg care is unique among known fish. Comparisons with bowerbirds, which build and decorate structures to attract mates, are tempting, although the pufferfish circle also serves directly as the nest.
What do the circles tell us about animal builders?
That complex, precise structures do not need a complex plan, and that sexual selection can drive remarkable engineering.
At first sight, a two-metre circle with dozens of evenly spaced ridges looks as if it must require a blueprint, or at least a sense of the whole design. The 2018 simulation study suggests otherwise. A fish that repeatedly swims inward in straight lines from the edge, starting low and digging as it goes, ends up with a radially symmetrical pattern without ever needing to “see” the finished product. The precision comes from the consistency of the behaviour, not from foresight. The same principle explains many structures built by animals with small brains, from termite mounds to the combs of honeybees.
The circles are also a striking example of sexual selection acting on something outside the body. In many animals, females choose males by their colours, songs or displays. Here the display is a structure, and its quality may depend on how much effort and skill the male invests. Because the circle also gathers the fine sand in which eggs are laid and slows the current over them, a well-built circle may signal a male who will provide a good nest. Untangling which of the circle’s many features females actually respond to, and whether those features honestly signal male quality, remains one of the open questions about this small fish.
Is the white-spotted pufferfish poisonous?
Possibly, like many puffers, but its toxicity has not been studied.
Many pufferfishes contain tetrodotoxin, a powerful nerve toxin, and Torquigener species may too. But this small fish is not a food fish and its toxicity has not been a focus of research. It should not be confused with the fugu species, mainly of the genus Takifugu, served in specialist restaurants in Japan. For the wider family, how puffers inflate and why they are toxic, see pufferfish (Tetraodontidae).
Can divers see the pufferfish circles?
Yes, on Amami Oshima during the breeding season, but only with excellent buoyancy and a strict hands-off approach.
Kawase’s team found circles and fish during regular observations from April to September, and local dive operators run trips to see the nests in the warmer months. The circles are fragile: a fin-kick, a diver kneeling on the sand or a cloud of silt can wreck a week of work in seconds, and a male whose nest is disturbed close to spawning may lose his chance to breed. Look, photograph from above, and keep well clear of the sand. Our scuba diving guide covers the basics; good buoyancy matters more here than almost anywhere.
The circles have also caught the attention of engineers and mathematicians. The 2022 three-dimensional model was published as an open dataset so that researchers could run fluid-dynamics simulations on it, with an eye to applications in architecture and engineering, and a 2023 image analysis even looked for geometric ratios in the circles’ proportions. Few animals so small have inspired so much study from so many fields.

What fish makes circles in the sand?
The male white-spotted pufferfish, Torquigener albomaculosus, off Amami Oshima in southern Japan.
How big are pufferfish sand circles?
About 2 m (6.5 ft) across, with 24–32 radial ridge-and-valley pairs, built by a fish about 10–12 cm long.
How long does it take a pufferfish to build its circle?
About 7–9 days of continuous work.
Why do pufferfish make circles?
To attract a female, who spawns in the centre. The ridges also funnel fine sand to the centre and slow the current there.
When were the underwater circles discovered?
Divers first saw them in 1995; the builder was filmed in 2011 and described as a new species dated 2014.
Where can you see pufferfish circles?
Around Amami Oshima in Japan’s Ryukyu Islands, at less than 30 m, mainly from spring to late summer. Similar circles occur 129–137 m deep off Western Australia.
Do pufferfish reuse their circles?
No. A male builds a fresh circle at a new site for each breeding attempt.
How long does the male guard the eggs?
About six days, until the eggs hatch. The circle collapses during that time.
- Kawase, H., Okata, Y. & Ito, K. (2013). Role of huge geometric circular structures in the reproduction of a marine pufferfish. Scientific Reports 3: 2106.
- Matsuura, K. (2014/2015). Description of Torquigener albomaculosus. Ichthyological Research.
- Mizuuchi, R. et al. (2018). Simple rules for construction of a geometric nest structure by pufferfish. Scientific Reports 8.
- Kawase, H., Kitajima, Y. & Iwai, D. (2022). 3D model of the geometric nest structure, the “mystery circle,” constructed by pufferfish. Scientific Data 9.
- Bond, T. et al. (2020). Mystery pufferfish create elaborate circular nests at mesophotic depths in Australia. Journal of Fish Biology.
- Çatalbaş (2023). Modelling and analysis of pufferfish circular nests. Marine Science and Technology Bulletin.
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.
About Blane Perun →