Dwarf Manatee — The Amazon’s Disputed “Fourth Manatee”
The “dwarf manatee” is a disputed taxon, not an accepted species. It was proposed as a fourth species of manatee, said to live in a single tributary of the Rio Aripuanã in the central Brazilian Amazon. Its mitochondrial DNA cannot be told apart from that of the Amazonian manatee, the IUCN does not recognise it, and the leading sirenian specialist who examined the evidence concluded that the animals were young Amazonian manatees.
That is the short answer. The longer story is worth telling because it shows how new species are proposed, tested and, sometimes, rejected. It also shows why body size and local reports are not enough to establish a new mammal, and why even DNA has to be read with care. This page sets out what was claimed, what the evidence shows, what would be needed to change the verdict, and what we know about the real animal behind the claim: the Amazonian manatee.
What exactly was claimed?
The proposal came from Marc van Roosmalen, a Dutch-born primatologist who spent decades working in the Brazilian Amazon. He was known for fieldwork in the region between the Madeira and Aripuanã rivers. In 2000, with colleagues, he described two new species of marmoset from this region, Callithrix manicorensis and Callithrix acariensis, in the journal Neotropical Primates. His record of finding genuinely new monkeys is one reason his later claims about larger mammals were at first taken seriously.
According to van Roosmalen, local people recognised a small, dark kind of manatee that lived in one tributary of the Aripuanã. He described it as typically about 130 cm long and about 60 kg in weight. That would make it the smallest living sirenian by a wide margin. He said it was very dark, almost black, with a white patch on the belly. It was said to live in shallow, fast-running water rather than the deep, slow backwaters favoured by Amazonian manatees, and to eat different water plants. During the rainy season, when the river floods up to its headwaters and shallow ponds, it was said to move upriver.
He gave it the name Trichechus pygmaeus. The name Trichechus bernhardi is also sometimes attached to it, but Wikipedia describes that use as a mistake. A manuscript describing the animal was submitted to Nature and rejected. The description was eventually published in the Biodiversity Journal in 2015. On the basis of its tiny reported range, supporters suggested it would be critically endangered if it really were a separate species.

How small was the dwarf manatee supposed to be?
About 130 cm long and 60 kg. That is well within the size of a growing Amazonian manatee.
The Amazonian manatee is already the smallest of the three accepted manatee species. Calves are born at about 85 to 105 cm long and 10 to 15 kg. Free-ranging adults measured in the wild were about 162 to 230 cm long and 120 to 270 kg. Captive animals have ranged from about 71 cm and 8 kg to 266 cm and 379 kg, covering the full span from newborn to large adult. Calves gain about 1 kg a week and grow by roughly 1.6 to 2.0 mm a day. A 130 cm, 60 kg animal therefore sits right in the range of a calf or juvenile that is still growing. That overlap is at the heart of the dispute.
| Measure | Claimed dwarf manatee | Amazonian manatee calf | Wild Amazonian adult |
|---|---|---|---|
| Length | ~130 cm | 85–105 cm at birth | ~162–230 cm |
| Weight | ~60 kg | 10–15 kg at birth, ~1 kg/week gain | ~120–270 kg |
| Colour | Very dark, white belly patch | Grey, often a white or pink chest patch | Grey, often a white or pink chest patch |
| Habitat | Shallow, fast tributary | Fresh water | Backwater lakes, flooded forest |
What does the DNA say?
The mitochondrial DNA of the specimens could not be distinguished from that of the Amazonian manatee.
Genetic testing was the critical check. Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA), the small genome inherited through the mother, is the standard first test of whether a population is genetically distinct. No difference was found between the supposed dwarf manatees and the Amazonian manatee, Trichechus inunguis. Wikipedia notes that, based on known manatee mutation rates, a dwarf manatee lineage, if real, would have split from the Amazonian manatee less than about 485,000 years ago. That would be very recent for a mammal species with such a striking difference in adult size.
Daryl Domning, a Smithsonian research associate and one of the world’s leading experts on sirenian evolution, concluded that the DNA evidence showed the animals were simply immature Amazonian manatees. In a widely quoted remark, he said he had no doubt that the “new species” was nothing but immature individuals. Van Roosmalen is reported to have compared skulls of a dwarf manatee and an immature Amazonian manatee of similar size and to have found differences in proportions. However, that comparison has not been independently repeated with a proper sample of skulls of known age.
Why are size and colour weak evidence?
Manatees grow for years, and young animals of one species can easily be mistaken for adults of a smaller one. To show that a small animal is a fully grown adult, a biologist would normally look for signs of maturity. These include fused growth plates in the bones, adult tooth wear, or evidence of breeding, such as a pregnant or lactating female of small size or a sexually mature male. Without that kind of evidence, a small specimen is most simply explained as a young one.
The calves of Amazonian manatees stay with their mothers for a year or more. Amazonian manatees are mostly solitary, but they sometimes gather in groups of up to about eight. Local reports of small manatees gathering in one creek fit a group of juveniles or young adults as easily as they fit a separate species. Fishers and hunters who know the river well may notice a real local pattern, such as where young animals gather, without that pattern meaning a new species.
Colour is also unreliable. Amazonian manatees are usually grey, but individuals vary, and most have a distinct white or bright pink patch on the chest. A dark animal with a pale belly patch is not obviously different from many Amazonian manatees. Skin colour can also change with age, with algae and other growth on the skin, and with the colour of the water in which the animal is seen. Judging the colour of a dark animal in murky river water, often from a boat or from local descriptions, is harder still.
Behaviour and habitat are harder to dismiss, but they are still not proof of a separate species. Amazonian manatees make seasonal movements tied to the flood cycle. They move into flooded forests and meadows when the water is high and food is abundant, then retreat to deep lakes and channels as it falls. Young animals, or a local population making use of a particular creek, could produce the pattern that local people described without being genetically distinct.
Can mitochondrial DNA settle the question on its own?
Not entirely, and it is worth being fair to both sides. Mitochondrial DNA is excellent at revealing deep, old splits between lineages, and it is the obvious first test. But it is only one small part of the genome, inherited only through the female line. Manatee genetics shows how it can blur boundaries. In a 2005 study of the Amazonian manatee, Cantanhede and colleagues found that Amazonian manatee mtDNA sequences were nested inside those of the West Indian manatee, which would make the West Indian species look paraphyletic, even though the two are clearly different animals. In 2006, Vianna and colleagues sequenced the mtDNA control region of 330 manatees. They found that Amazonian manatees formed a single, expanding population with many closely related haplotypes. They also found hybrids between West Indian and Amazonian manatees around the mouth of the Amazon.
These studies show that mtDNA can understate differences between related species and that manatee species can interbreed where they meet. A supporter of the dwarf manatee could argue that a very young species might not yet show mtDNA differences. That argument works only if other evidence, such as nuclear DNA, adult skeletal features or a breeding population of small adults, shows a clear difference. So far no such evidence has been presented and accepted by other specialists. The burden of proof lies with the claim.

What would it take to prove a dwarf manatee exists?
The test is straightforward in principle. Researchers would need several specimens that are clearly adult, such as skeletons with fused growth plates or small females that are pregnant or nursing, and that are consistently smaller than Amazonian manatee adults. Nuclear DNA from multiple individuals would need to show that the population is genetically separate, not just a set of young animals from the wider Amazonian population. Field surveys would also have to show where the animals live and breed. Published, peer-reviewed comparisons using enough skulls of known age would help as well.
None of that has happened in a way that has convinced the wider community of mammal specialists. The Amazon is still poorly surveyed, and its tributaries do hold undescribed animals, so it is not impossible that a locally distinct manatee population exists. But “not impossible” is not the same as demonstrated. On current evidence, the dwarf manatee is best treated as a disputed name for small Amazonian manatees.
What is the real animal behind the claim?
The animals seen and sampled on the Aripuanã appear to be Amazonian manatees, and that species is interesting in its own right. It is the only sirenian that lives only in fresh water, and it never leaves the water. It is found across much of the Amazon basin in Brazil, Peru, Colombia and Ecuador, from the river’s headwaters to the Marajó area near its mouth. Within that area it concentrates in nutrient-rich flooded forests, backwater lakes and lagoons with plenty of floating and emergent plants. Its scientific name, inunguis, means “nailless”: unlike other manatees, it has no nails on its flippers.
Amazonian manatees feed on aquatic plants such as water lettuce, water hyacinth, grasses and water lilies, and eat about 8 per cent of their body weight a day. During the dry season, when water levels fall, some become trapped in deep lakes for months. They are thought to survive on fat reserves and a very low metabolic rate, reported at only about 36 per cent of the usual rate for a placental mammal of their size. They can go up to about seven months with little or no food. Pregnancy lasts 12 to 14 months. Most calves are born between December and July, with about 63 per cent born between February and May as rivers rise, and calves stay with their mothers for 12 to 18 months. Wild animals are thought to live about 30 years. See our pages on baby manatees and manatee lifespan for more detail.
The Amazonian manatee is listed as Vulnerable by the IUCN. Heavy hunting in the twentieth century, with more than 140,000 animals estimated to have been killed between 1935 and 1954, greatly reduced its numbers. Illegal hunting, mostly for local use, remains its main threat today, along with accidental capture in fishing nets and changes to its river habitat. Recent surveys in the Ecuadorian Amazon, published in 2021, estimated densities of about one manatee per square kilometre at two sites. Because the species is hard to see in muddy and dark waters, there is no reliable estimate of its total population.
Studying these animals is difficult, which is part of why claims like the dwarf manatee are hard to settle quickly. Amazonian manatees surface briefly, often showing only their nostrils, and they usually come up to breathe every few minutes, although one captive animal stayed under for 14 minutes. The Ecuador team covered 573 km of rivers and lagoons and used side-scan sonar from a fish finder to detect animals they could not see. They found that manatees were more likely to be present farther from people. Surveys of this kind, extended to the Aripuanã and its tributaries, together with genetic sampling and the study of skeletons from animals that have died, are what would finally show whether anything unusual lives there.
Why did the claim get so much attention?
New species of large mammals are very rare, and the Amazon is one of the few places where one might plausibly have escaped notice. The dwarf manatee came from a researcher with a track record of discoveries, in a remote river basin that few scientists had visited. That combination made it an appealing story. It also spread through species lists and websites that do not always distinguish proposed taxa from accepted ones.
The episode also follows a familiar pattern. Several “new” large animals proposed on the basis of a few specimens, a size difference and local knowledge have later turned out to be young or unusual individuals of known species. Genetic testing now makes it much easier to check such claims quickly. In this case the first genetic test pointed firmly toward the known species, and no later evidence has reversed that. That is not a judgement on the value of local knowledge, which often leads scientists to real discoveries, but a reminder that it has to be tested.
How many manatee species are there?
Three accepted living species. Add the dugong and there are four living sirenians.
The accepted manatees are the West Indian manatee of the Caribbean, Gulf of Mexico and Atlantic coasts of the Americas, the African manatee of West African coasts and rivers, and the Amazonian manatee. Together with the dugong of the Indo-Pacific, these make up the living members of the order Sirenia. A fifth sirenian, Steller’s sea cow, was a genuinely distinct giant of the North Pacific, but it was hunted to extinction in the eighteenth century. If you see a “dwarf manatee” in a list of species, treat it as a disputed name for small Amazonian manatees, not a fourth living manatee.

Is the dwarf manatee a real species?
Most scientists say no. Its mitochondrial DNA matches the Amazonian manatee, and the specimens appear to be juveniles of that species. The IUCN does not recognise it.
Where was the dwarf manatee found?
In a tributary of the Rio Aripuanã in the central Brazilian Amazon, according to its describer, Marc van Roosmalen.
How big is the dwarf manatee?
It was described as about 130 cm long and 60 kg, which overlaps with young Amazonian manatees.
What is the scientific name of the dwarf manatee?
Trichechus pygmaeus, a disputed name. Trichechus bernhardi is sometimes attached to it by mistake.
When was the dwarf manatee described?
The description was rejected by Nature and later published in the Biodiversity Journal in 2015.
How many manatee species are there?
Three accepted living species: the West Indian, African and Amazonian manatees.
What is the smallest manatee?
The Amazonian manatee. Wild adults are usually about 1.6–2.3 m long and 120–270 kg.
- Van Roosmalen, M. (2015). Description of Trichechus pygmaeus. Biodiversity Journal.
- Van Roosmalen, M.G.M., Van Roosmalen, T. & Mittermeier, R.A. (2000). Two new species of marmoset, genus Callithrix, from the Tapajós/Madeira interfluvium. Neotropical Primates 8.
- Wikipedia: Dwarf manatee; Amazonian manatee (size ranges, growth, diet, reproduction, hunting history).
- Cantanhede, A.M. et al. (2005). Phylogeography and population genetics of the endangered Amazonian manatee, Trichechus inunguis. Molecular Ecology.
- Vianna, J.A. et al. (2006). Phylogeography, phylogeny and hybridization in trichechid sirenians: implications for manatee conservation. Molecular Ecology.
- Narváez Ruano, V. et al. (2021). Occupancy and population density estimates of the Amazonian manatee in eastern Ecuador. Endangered Species Research.
- Domning, D. (Smithsonian Institution), public comments on the dwarf manatee, as quoted in Wikipedia and on Mammalwatching.com (2018).
- IUCN Red List: Trichechus inunguis (Vulnerable).
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.
About Blane Perun →