Exploring Earth's Oceans Since 1999 · Founded by Blane Perun
3,072 Articles·80+ Countries·25 Years of Ocean Science·Site Map
◆ Trending
25 years exploring Earth's oceans,
coral reefs, and the creatures within.
3,072Articles
80+Countries
1999Founded

Advantages and Disadvantages of Aquaculture: A Balanced Scorecard

Advantages and Disadvantages of Aquaculture — The Scorecard in One Page

Coral Aquaculture
November 7, 2026
13 min read
The short answer

Aquaculture’s main advantages are a reliable, growing food supply (more than half of the world’s aquatic animals in 2024), jobs, efficient protein and relief for wild stocks. Its main disadvantages are pollution, disease and parasites, escapes, dependence on wild fish for some feeds and, historically, loss of habitats such as mangroves. Which side wins depends on the species, the system and the farmer.

Context
Farmed share of aquatic animals, 2024
53%
Farmed aquatic animals, 2024
About 103 million t
Wild capture trend
Flat at 86–94 million t since late 1980s
Feed efficiency (2015)
About 4.55 kg farmed fish per kg wild fish used in feed (IFFO)
Mangrove loss 2000–2016
About 3,400 km², 62% from direct human causes incl. aquaculture

Aquaculture is neither a miracle nor a menace. It is a set of very different farming systems, from oyster lines in a clean estuary to crowded shrimp ponds dug out of mangroves, and each comes with its own balance of benefits and costs. This page weighs both sides, with the evidence behind each.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of aquaculture?

Salmon farm pens in a sea loch | TheSea.Org by Blane Perun
AdvantagesDisadvantages
Supplies 53% of aquatic animal food and growingNutrient and waste pollution from fed farms
Takes pressure off wild stocks when feeds are low in fishmealSome species still rely on wild fish for feed
Efficient protein; shellfish and seaweed need no feedDisease and parasites, sometimes spreading to wild fish
Jobs and income, often in rural areasEscaped fish can compete or interbreed with wild stocks
Year-round, predictable supply and traceabilityAntibiotic and chemical use on poorly run farms
Restocking and conservation hatcheries; coral and clam farmingHabitat conversion, especially mangroves for shrimp ponds
Seaweed and shellfish can clean waterConflicts with other coastal users; labour abuses in some supply chains
Advantages and disadvantages of aquaculture: circular fish-farm net pens floating in a calm coastal bay
Advantages and disadvantages of aquaculture: circular fish-farm net pens floating in a calm coastal bay

Advantage: a growing, reliable food supply

The biggest advantage is simple. According to the FAO’s State of World Fisheries and Aquaculture 2026, farms produced about 103 million tonnes of aquatic animals in 2024, 53 percent of the world total, while wild capture has stayed between roughly 86 and 94 million tonnes a year since the late 1980s. Farming has supplied essentially all the growth in seafood consumption for a generation, lifting world availability to an estimated 21.3 kilograms per person.

Farming also makes supply more predictable. Wild catches rise and fall with weather, ocean cycles such as El Niño and the state of fish stocks, and boats may be stuck in port for weeks. A farm can harvest to a schedule, grade its fish for size and trace each batch back to a pond or pen, which matters to retailers and to food-safety regulators. The broader case for why this matters is in why is aquaculture important?

Advantage: efficient protein with a smaller footprint

Fish are cold-blooded and supported by water, so they waste less energy than land animals keeping warm or holding themselves up. When researchers led by Jillian Fry compared farmed animals in 2018 by the protein and calories that end up in edible parts, farmed fish and shrimp came out broadly similar to chicken and pork and well ahead of beef. The Blue Food Assessment, published in Nature in 2021, found that farmed seaweeds and bivalves such as mussels and oysters had the lowest environmental impacts of any animal-source foods it studied, across greenhouse gases, nutrient pollution, land and water use.

The reason is that these “extractive” species need no feed at all. Mussels and oysters filter plankton from the water, and seaweeds take up dissolved nutrients and carbon dioxide. Farming them can actually remove some nutrient pollution from coastal waters. Herbivorous and omnivorous fish, such as carp and tilapia, can be raised mainly on plant-based feeds. These groups make up the bulk of world aquaculture by weight, which is one reason its average footprint is lower than critics sometimes assume.

Advantage: relief for wild stocks and support for conservation

Every tonne of farmed shellfish, seaweed or plant-fed fish eaten is a tonne that does not need to be taken from the wild, at a time when the FAO estimates that only about 62 percent of marine fish stocks are fished at biologically sustainable levels. Hatchery techniques developed for aquaculture are also used to rebuild depleted populations. In Alaska, for example, hatcheries released about 1.7 billion young salmon in 2021, and hatchery fish made up nearly a third of the state’s commercial salmon catch. Coral nurseries, giant clam hatcheries and captive breeding of aquarium fish reduce collection from reefs; see coral aquaculture.

Advantage: jobs and livelihoods

About 22 million people worked directly in aquaculture in 2022, according to the FAO, most of them in Asia, and many more work in feed production, processing and trade. A large share of farms are small family operations in rural areas with few other sources of income. Seaweed farming in Indonesia, the Philippines and East Africa, for instance, provides cash income for coastal households, often with women doing much of the work. For many developing countries, farmed shrimp and fish are also valuable exports.

Disadvantage: pollution and waste

Fed aquaculture produces waste. In open net pens, uneaten feed and fish faeces drop to the sea floor or dissolve into the water. Beneath crowded salmon farms in sheltered fjords and bays, the sediment can become enriched with organic matter, oxygen levels fall and the normal community of bottom animals is replaced by a few pollution-tolerant species. Dissolved nitrogen and phosphorus can feed algal blooms where many farms are concentrated in poorly flushed waters. Inland, shrimp and fish ponds can discharge nutrient-rich water into rivers and estuaries when they are drained between crops.

The scale of the problem depends heavily on siting and management. Farms in deep, well-flushed water with strong currents spread their waste widely, and fallowing a site between production cycles lets the sea floor recover. Regulators in countries such as Norway and Scotland require monitoring of the sea bed beneath farms. Closed containment and recirculating systems on land capture waste so it can be treated or used as fertiliser, although they use more energy.

Disadvantage: disease and parasites

Crowding animals together makes disease easier to spread, and outbreaks can be devastating. In 2007 an outbreak of infectious salmon anaemia, a viral disease, swept through Chile’s salmon farms and caused production of Atlantic salmon to collapse over the following years, costing thousands of jobs. In shrimp farming, white spot syndrome virus has caused huge losses in Asia and Latin America since the 1990s, and a bacterial disease known as early mortality syndrome, or acute hepatopancreatic necrosis disease, spread through China, Viet Nam, Thailand and beyond from about 2009.

The bigger worry for conservationists is spillover to wild animals. Sea lice are parasitic copepods that feed on salmon skin. In farms they can multiply to high numbers, and juvenile wild salmon migrating past the pens can pick them up. A 2007 study in Science by Martin Krkošek and colleagues linked sea lice from farms to declines of wild pink salmon in the Broughton Archipelago of British Columbia, although later work disputed how strong the effect was. The debate helped drive tighter lice limits on farms and, in British Columbia, a federal decision to phase out open net-pen salmon farming in coastal waters.

Disadvantage: escapes

Farmed fish regularly escape through torn nets, storm damage and handling accidents. The escapees can compete with wild fish for food and spawning sites, spread disease, and, where they are the same species as local wild populations, interbreed with them. Farmed Atlantic salmon have been bred for fast growth in a sheltered environment, and genetic studies in Norway have found farmed genes in many wild salmon populations, which may make their offspring less fit for life in the wild.

One escape changed policy in the United States. In August 2017 a net-pen complex run by Cooke Aquaculture Pacific off Cypress Island in Washington’s Puget Sound collapsed. State investigators estimated that 243,000 to 263,000 non-native Atlantic salmon escaped, and only about 57,000 were recaptured, many by Lummi Nation fishers. Investigators found that the nets were carrying more than six times their own weight in marine growth, and that poor maintenance, not unusual currents, was the main cause. In March 2018 Washington passed a law ending state leases and permits for Atlantic salmon and other non-native finfish farming as existing leases expired, which phased those farms out by 2022. In November 2022 the state Lands Commissioner ended the last remaining net-pen leases, the final farms were removed in 2023, and in January 2025 the Board of Natural Resources adopted a rule prohibiting all commercial finfish net-pen aquaculture on state-owned aquatic lands.

Advantages and disadvantages of aquaculture: a heap of small forage fish on a dock, the kind used for fish feed
Advantages and disadvantages of aquaculture: a heap of small forage fish on a dock, the kind used for fish feed

Disadvantage: feeding fish to fish

Carnivorous species such as salmon, trout, sea bass and many shrimps have traditionally been fed fishmeal and fish oil made from small wild fish such as Peruvian anchoveta, sardines and herring. Critics argue that this simply moves fishing pressure from one stock to another, and that the small fish would be better eaten directly by people or left in the sea as food for seabirds, marine mammals and larger fish.

The industry has become much more efficient. A 2021 review in Nature by Rosamond Naylor and colleagues found that inclusion of fishmeal and fish oil in feeds had fallen sharply over two decades, replaced by plant proteins and oils and by trimmings from fish processing. The fishmeal trade body IFFO estimated that in 2015 each kilogram of wild fish used in feed supported about 4.55 kilograms of farmed fish. New ingredients such as insect meal, algal oils and single-cell proteins are being developed to cut dependence further. But replacing fish oil with plant oils can lower the omega-3 content of farmed fish, which is part of their nutritional appeal.

Disadvantage: habitat loss, especially mangroves

The most damaging chapter in aquaculture’s history was the clearance of mangrove forests for shrimp ponds, especially in Southeast Asia and Latin America from the 1980s onward. Mangroves protect coasts from storms, store large amounts of carbon and serve as nurseries for wild fish and crabs, so their loss had costs far beyond the ponds themselves. Many ponds were abandoned after a few years because of disease or soil acidification, leaving degraded land behind.

The picture has improved, though not everywhere. A satellite study published in Global Change Biology in 2020 by Liza Goldberg and colleagues found that 3,363 square kilometres of mangroves, about 2.1 percent of the global total, were lost between 2000 and 2016. Human activity caused 62 percent of the loss, and conversion to commodities, including shrimp ponds, rice and oil palm, caused 47 percent. Six Southeast Asian countries, Indonesia, Myanmar, Malaysia, the Philippines, Thailand and Viet Nam, accounted for 92 percent of the commodity-driven losses. Encouragingly, the rate of direct human-driven loss declined significantly over the study period.

Disadvantage: energy use and climate impacts

Aquaculture is not automatically climate-friendly. For fed species, the Blue Food Assessment found that most greenhouse gas emissions come from producing the feed, so a farm’s footprint depends heavily on what goes into its pellets and how efficiently the fish convert them. Energy is the next big factor. Aerating ponds, pumping water and running recirculating systems on land all use electricity, and where that power comes from fossil fuels the emissions add up. Land-based recirculating farms solve many local pollution and escape problems, but they can have a larger energy footprint than open net pens.

Habitat conversion carries a hidden climate cost too. Mangroves and other coastal wetlands store large amounts of carbon in their soils, much of which is released when they are cleared and dug into ponds. Studies of shrimp farmed on former mangrove land have found that this lost carbon can make the shrimp’s climate footprint far higher than that of most farmed animals. By contrast, farming seaweed and shellfish has a very small carbon footprint, and seaweed farms are being studied as a possible way to take up carbon, although how much they can store long term is uncertain.

Disadvantage: antibiotics and chemicals

To control disease, some farms use antibiotics, pesticides against parasites and disinfectants. Overuse can leave residues in seafood, harm non-target animals near farms and encourage antibiotic-resistant bacteria, a concern for human health as well as for the farms themselves. Some chemicals once common in fish farming, such as the dye malachite green, are now banned in many countries because of health risks.

Norway shows that this disadvantage can be reduced. After vaccines against major bacterial diseases were introduced for farmed salmon in the late 1980s and early 1990s, antibiotic use in Norwegian salmon farming fell by well over 90 percent from its peak, even as production grew many times over. Practices in other countries vary widely, and the use of antibiotics in some shrimp and fish farms remains poorly documented.

Disadvantage: conflicts and social costs

Coastal farms compete for space with fishing, tourism, shipping and conservation, and coastal communities often object to the noise, smell, lights and visual impact of large installations. In some regions, land and water rights have been taken over by large shrimp or fish farms at the expense of small farmers and fishers. Investigations in the 2010s also linked forced labour on fishing boats that supplied fish for feed to shrimp supply chains in Thailand, showing that the ethical footprint of aquaculture can extend far beyond the farm.

Are the disadvantages getting better?

In many places, yes. Feed efficiency has improved, vaccines have cut antibiotic use in leading salmon-producing countries, satellite studies show slower human-driven mangrove loss, and some governments have tightened rules on farm siting, sea lice and escapes. Certification schemes, such as the Aquaculture Stewardship Council, founded in 2010, and Best Aquaculture Practices, set standards for feed, waste, disease control and labour, and give buyers a way to reward better farms. Recirculating systems, offshore farms in deeper, more exposed water and integrated multi-trophic aquaculture (IMTA) all aim to reduce local impacts further. The fuller lists are in pros of aquaculture and cons of aquaculture.

How to judge a farm
Ask four questions: What species? What does it eat? Where is it sited? How is waste handled? An oyster farm in a clean estuary and a crowded shrimp pond carved out of mangroves are both “aquaculture”, but their scorecards are opposites.

Which types of aquaculture have the best balance?

Bivalves and seaweed score best, because they need no feed and remove nutrients from the water. Herbivorous and omnivorous fish such as carp and tilapia come next, particularly in well-managed ponds and integrated systems. Carnivorous finfish and shrimp have the heaviest footprints, though well-run farms with efficient feeds, good siting and strong disease control can narrow the gap considerably. Coral farming for restoration and the aquarium trade has minimal impact and a clear conservation benefit. For consumers, choosing farmed mussels, oysters, clams and seaweed, or certified fish and shrimp, is the simplest way to support the better side of the ledger.

Advantages and disadvantages of aquaculture: rectangular fish cages in a lagoon beside mangrove forest
Advantages and disadvantages of aquaculture: rectangular fish cages in a lagoon beside mangrove forest
Frequently asked questions

What are the main advantages of aquaculture?

A growing, reliable food supply, efficient protein, relief for wild stocks, conservation hatcheries and jobs, especially in rural areas.

What are the main disadvantages of aquaculture?

Pollution, disease and parasites, escapes, reliance on wild fish for some feeds, antibiotic use and habitat loss such as mangrove clearance.

Is aquaculture better than wild fishing?

It depends on the species and farm. Shellfish and seaweed farming usually have lower impacts than many wild fisheries; some fed farms have higher.

Does fish farming harm wild fish?

It can, through sea lice and disease spillover, escapes that interbreed with wild fish, and feed made from wild-caught fish.

Why did Washington ban salmon net pens?

After the 2017 Cypress Island collapse released roughly 250,000 Atlantic salmon, the state passed a 2018 law phasing out non-native finfish net pens by 2022; a January 2025 rule then banned all commercial net-pen fish farming on state-owned aquatic lands.

Does aquaculture destroy mangroves?

Shrimp ponds caused major mangrove losses, especially in Southeast Asia; human-driven loss has slowed since 2000 but continues.

What is the most sustainable type of aquaculture?

Farming bivalves such as mussels and oysters, and seaweed, which need no feed and can improve water quality.

How can I choose sustainable farmed seafood?

Prefer shellfish and seaweed, and look for certification such as the Aquaculture Stewardship Council or Best Aquaculture Practices.

Sources & further reading
  1. FAO (2026). The State of World Fisheries and Aquaculture 2026; FAO (2024), SOFIA 2024 employment chapter.
  2. Naylor, R.L. et al. (2021). A 20-year retrospective review of global aquaculture. Nature 591: 551–563.
  3. Gephart, J.A. et al. (2021). Environmental performance of blue foods. Nature 597: 360–365.
  4. Goldberg, L. et al. (2020). Global declines in human-driven mangrove loss. Global Change Biology 26: 5844–5855.
  5. Krkošek, M. et al. (2007). Declining wild salmon populations in relation to parasites from farm salmon. Science 318: 1772–1775.
  6. Washington State Department of Natural Resources (2018). Cypress Island net pen failure investigation; Wikipedia: Cypress Island Atlantic salmon pen break.
  7. Washington State DNR (2025). Board of Natural Resources ends open sea net pen salmon farms in Washington waters (news release, January 2025).
  8. Fry, J.P. et al. (2018). Feed conversion efficiency in aquaculture: do we measure it correctly? Environmental Research Letters 13: 024017.
BP
Last updated November 7, 2026
Written by
Blane Perun

Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.

About Blane Perun →
Coral Aquaculture · The Pioneer Story
Blane Perun, A coral aquaculture pioneer

Built one of the first home reef tanks designed as a multi-zone replica of natural reef conditions. Author of long-form profiles cited by Wikipedia, Quality Marine, and SeaScope. Independent — no advertisers, no sponsored placements, no editorial board outside the dive log.

Widely credited as the pioneer of named-coral culture in the reef-keeping hobby. The original — “Perun's Purple People Eater”, a Protopalythoa morph from his coral farm — became the first hobbyist coral to carry an aquaculturist's name in trade, sparking the now-standard practice of naming individual coral strains across the industry.

Founded1999 Articles3,072 Countries80+ Cited inWikipedia · Quality Marine · SeaScope
Read Blane's full bio →
The Dispatch · Monthly

Field notes from eighty countries worth of ocean.

One monthly email. New long-form reporting, species profiles, and dive reports — no filler, no tracking pixels, no sponsored placements. Ever.

Sign up and get my one-click underwater color-correction actions for Photoshop — the set I run on my own dive shots. Free.

Get the action now + monthly field notes
No spam · Unsubscribe anytime
Underwater reef photo before and after Blane Perun's Photoshop color-correction action — washed-out blue-green on the left, full natural color restored on the right
Same shot · one click