Coral Farm Sand Substrate — Deep Sand Beds in Every Grow-Out Tank
Every one of my coral farm tanks needed a bottom, and for most of them I chose the same answer I had used before: a deep sand bed. A deep sand bed is more than decoration. It is a living filter, a home for the tiny worms, crustaceans and microbes that break down waste, and, in a farm with few fish, a source of food for the animals that live above it. It also comes with trade-offs, chief among them the limit it places on how hard you can push water around the tank. This page covers how I built the beds in my farm, how I seeded them, why I do not rinse sand, and what deep sand beds do and do not do.
Why deep sand beds?
On my first coral farm, a series of grow-out systems running off a main tank, I used deep sand beds, often shortened to DSBs, and I think they are a terrific way to control nutrients while feeding the fish and coral population at the same time. So when it came to the new farm, I planned deep sand beds in each system from the start. That decision also explains why the drain plugs in the stock tanks were of little use: a bed of sand several inches deep buries a low drain completely.
Which sand did I use?
Starting this project in 2002 gave me the privilege, and the luck, of being able to use Southdown play sand for the deep sand beds. It cost two to three dollars a bag, compared with the sixteen dollars I would have paid for twenty pounds of reef sand in the late 1990s. This was one step that saved me a lot of money. Southdown tropical play sand was, at the time, a fine aragonite sand that reef keepers had discovered was well suited to sand beds, and it became widely used in the hobby.
By the time of this stage I had four of my six tanks set up, and three of those had deep sand beds. The three tanks with beds were each 110 gallons. Each tank took about 300 pounds of sand to reach a depth of about five and a half inches.
What should you look for in reef sand?
The best sand for a reef tank is aragonite, a form of calcium carbonate, the same mineral that makes up much of the sand on tropical reefs. Aragonite sand helps buffer the water and provides a natural surface for bacteria and small animals. Silica sand, the common quartz sand used in construction and many play sands, is chemically inert in seawater and does not provide the same buffering; some reef keepers also worry that it may contribute silicate, which can feed diatoms.
Grain size matters for a deep sand bed. Fine sand, with grains roughly the size of sugar or smaller, slows the movement of water through the bed, which is what allows oxygen-free zones to form deeper down, and it suits the burrowing worms and crustaceans that keep the bed healthy. Coarse sand and crushed coral let water flow through more freely and trap detritus. Play sands vary widely in composition and the products on shelves have changed over the years, so anyone using a non-aquarium sand today should confirm that it is aragonite and free of additives before putting it in a tank.
How did I seed the beds?
In addition to the bags of Southdown from the local Home Depot, I already had plenty of sand on hand. Part of it was live, in use in a 120-gallon tank and a 120-gallon sump. I also had more in my garage, stored in garbage cans from the grow systems I had torn down. In each tank I built the bed in layers: new sand on the bottom, a thin layer of live sand from the running tank, a thin layer of older, dead sand from the garage, and another layer of live sand from the tank on top.
Live sand carries the bacteria, microorganisms, worms and tiny crustaceans that make a sand bed work. Seeding new sand with live sand from an established system introduces them, and they spread through the new sand over the following weeks and months. Layering live sand through the bed, rather than only on top, gives the organisms a head start throughout.
Should you rinse sand before adding it?
Over the years many people have asked me how I add sand to my tanks. My main concern was the milky water that comes with fresh sand. I have two suggestions. The first is not to rinse the sand with water. I do not believe this step is of any value. You end up washing much of the product down the drain, most of which would have settled out in the tank anyway. And since this sand is sterilised by baking, rinsing it in tap water simply has it absorb tap water and whatever is in it.
Fine sand will cloud the water when it is first added, but the cloud settles in hours to a day or two, faster with filtration running. Adding sand to a tank partly filled with water, rather than pouring water onto dry sand, and placing it gently, for example by lowering it in a container and tipping it out at the bottom, reduces the cloud. Adding sand before corals go in avoids smothering or irritating them with suspended fines.
How does a deep sand bed work?
A deep sand bed works as layers of different chemistry. The top few millimetres to a centimetre or so are well oxygenated by the water above, and here aerobic bacteria convert ammonia, the main waste product of animals, into nitrite and then nitrate. Deeper in the bed, where oxygen is used up faster than it can diffuse in, conditions become low in oxygen, and different bacteria use nitrate in place of oxygen for respiration, converting it to nitrogen gas, which escapes. This process, denitrification, removes nitrogen from the system.
For the deeper, low-oxygen zone to form, the bed must be deep enough and fine enough. Recommendations in the hobby have usually been for beds of at least about four inches, often six or more. My beds of about five and a half inches fell within that range. The bed also needs a healthy population of burrowing animals, such as small worms, amphipods and snails, which slowly turn the sand, break down detritus and keep the bed from clogging.
Why do sand beds help feed corals and fish?
The small animals that live in a mature sand bed, including copepods, amphipods and the larvae of worms, reproduce continuously. Some of them, and their offspring, rise into the water at night or are swept up by currents, where they become food for corals, filter feeders and small fish. In a farm, where corals greatly outnumber fish, this steady supply of natural plankton is a real benefit. That is what I mean when I say a sand bed controls nutrients and feeds the animals at the same time.
A sand bed is also habitat. Many reef animals, from gobies and jawfish to sand-sifting starfish and conchs, need sand to burrow, forage or shelter. Even in a farm focused on corals, a sand bed makes the system more like a natural reef, with more of the organisms that keep it in balance.
What are the drawbacks of deep sand beds?
Deep sand beds have critics as well as fans. Over years, a sand bed can accumulate detritus and phosphate, particularly if it is overloaded or poorly populated with burrowing animals. Some reef keepers believe old beds can release that stored phosphate back into the water, fuelling algae. Disturbing a mature bed suddenly, for example by stirring it hard or tearing it down, can release hydrogen sulphide and nutrients from the deeper layers. Many aquarists who run deep sand beds replace part of the sand periodically or plan for an eventual change.
The biggest practical drawback in a coral farm is water movement. Strong flow at the bottom of a tank blows fine sand around, creating sand storms that bury frags, scour areas bare and cloud the water. That limits how hard you can drive water across a deep sand bed.
How did the sand affect water flow?
One concern while laying these beds was how much current I could get in tanks only about 20 inches high with a six-inch sand bed. The answer, from my experience, was not much, if I wanted to keep the sand bed intact. Water movement was one area I wanted to improve dramatically in these systems, so that was a real tension. I knew that down the road I might remove the sand from one or more of the systems. But not knowing what hardware I would need in the future, this was the best way to proceed.
The general lesson is that substrate and flow have to be planned together. A deep, fine bed suits gentle, broad flow and corals that do not need extreme water movement. Fast-growing small-polyp stony corals often do best with strong, turbulent flow, which is easier to provide over a bare bottom or a shallow layer of coarse sand. Some farmers solve this by running different tank styles for different corals.
Are bare-bottom tanks better for coral farming?
Many commercial coral farms run bare-bottom tanks, with no sand at all. Bare bottoms are easy to clean, allow very strong flow without sand storms, let detritus be siphoned out or carried to the filtration, and remove any worry about a sand bed storing nutrients. Their drawbacks are the loss of the biological filtration and natural food production of a sand bed, and of the habitat for sand-dwelling animals, so they usually rely more on protein skimming, water changes and other forms of nutrient control.
A shallow sand bed, an inch or so deep, is a middle course: it provides a natural look and some surface area for bacteria without the low-oxygen zone of a deep bed. My choice of deep beds reflected my experience with them in the earlier farm and my priority, at that stage, of stable nutrient control and natural food. The decision to keep or remove the sand could be revisited once I knew more about the flow each system would need.
How do you maintain a deep sand bed?
The main maintenance for a deep sand bed is keeping its population healthy. A good mix of burrowing organisms, such as small worms, amphipods and the snails often called Nassarius snails, keeps the bed turning over. Animals that eat the bed’s small invertebrates in large numbers, such as some sand-sifting gobies and starfish in a small tank, can strip it of its fauna and should be chosen with care.
Avoid vacuuming deep into the bed, which disrupts the layers, but do remove detritus that collects on the surface. Add new live sand or organisms from time to time to keep the population diverse. Keep feeding and stocking within the capacity of the system, because no sand bed can process unlimited waste. And watch for signs of trouble, such as dark patches or a smell of rotten eggs, which indicate the bed is overloaded.
How much sand does a deep sand bed need?
A simple estimate is to multiply the area of the tank bottom by the depth of sand you want and allow for the weight of sand. Sand is dense, so a bed several inches deep over a stock tank floor quickly runs into hundreds of pounds; my 110-gallon tanks, which taper toward the bottom, each took about 300. Buying in bulk, as I did with the play sand, makes a large difference to the cost of a farm with several tanks. That sand also adds weight, which should be included when planning floor loads.
How long does a new sand bed take to mature?
A sand bed is not fully functional the day it goes in. Bacteria colonise the surface within weeks, especially when seeded with live sand, but the populations of worms, amphipods and other burrowers, and the stable chemical layers deep in the bed, take months to develop. During that time, the bed may not remove as much nitrate as it eventually will, and patience with stocking pays off. Seeding with live sand from an established system, as I did, shortens the wait considerably.
What came next?
With the sand beds in, the tanks were ready to be filled with saltwater and brought to life. The next pages in the series cover filling the tanks and the long search for the right way to move water through them without wrecking the beds I had just built.
Why use deep sand beds in a coral farm?
They help control nutrients through denitrification and produce small animals that feed corals and fish.
How much sand per tank?
About 300 pounds per 110-gallon tank, for a bed about 5.5 inches deep.
Which sand did I use?
Southdown play sand, an aragonite sand widely used by reef keepers in the early 2000s.
Should you rinse aquarium sand?
I don’t. Rinsing washes away fine sand that would settle and soaks it in tap water.
How do you seed a new sand bed?
Layer live sand from an established tank through the new sand.
Do deep sand beds limit water flow?
Yes. Strong flow near the bottom blows fine sand around, so flow and substrate must be planned together.
- Blane Perun, My Coral Farm series, TheSea.Org
- Shimek, R. L., articles on sand beds and their fauna in Reefkeeping magazine
- Calfo, A. (2001), Book of Coral Propagation, Reading Trees
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.
About Blane Perun →