Silvery Reef Fish — Jacks, Barracudas and Spadefish: the Mirror-Sided Hunters and Schoolers of the Reef Edge
A field grouping of fish that live in the water column over and around reefs rather than in the coral itself. Their silver sides come from stacked guanine crystals in the skin that act as vertical mirrors. Main groups: jacks and trevallies (Carangidae, ~150 species), barracudas (Sphyraenidae, ~29 species), spadefish and batfish (Ephippidae), sweepers (Pempheridae), fusiliers (Caesionidae) and baitfish such as silversides, herrings and scad.
Why are open-water fish silver?
Mirrors make them disappear.
In open water there is nowhere to hide. Light underwater is roughly the same in every horizontal direction, so a vertical mirror reflects exactly what is behind the viewer, making the fish blend into the background. Silvery fish achieve this with layers of guanine crystals in their skin and scales. Many also have darker backs (to blend with the deep below when seen from above) and white bellies (to blend with the bright surface when seen from below), a pattern called countershading. When a school turns in unison, the flashing confuses predators.

What are jacks and trevallies?
The reef’s cruise missiles.
Jacks (Carangidae) are muscular, fork-tailed predators built for speed, with a row of hard scutes along the tail. They patrol reef edges and channels, often in groups, ambushing fish that stray from cover. The giant trevally (Caranx ignobilis) is the largest, reaching about 1.7 m and 80 kg; at Farquhar Atoll in the Seychelles it has been filmed leaping out of the water to catch seabirds. The black jack (Caranx lugubris) prowls steep drop-offs. Bigeye trevally form slowly spiralling schools of thousands that divers love to swim into. Jacks also hunt by shadowing other predators, such as moray eels, goatfish and even sharks, picking off flushed prey.
What are barracudas?
Toothy, curious and mostly harmless to people.
Barracudas (Sphyraena) are long, torpedo-shaped ambush predators with a jutting lower jaw full of fang-like teeth. The great barracuda (S. barracuda) reaches roughly 1.65–2 m and often hovers motionless near divers, which can be unnerving. Smaller species such as the chevron and blackfin barracuda form huge spiralling schools in the Indo-Pacific and Red Sea. Barracudas rarely bite people; most incidents involve shiny objects in murky water or spearfished fish.
What are spadefish, batfish and sweepers?
Disc-shaped and sociable.
Spadefish and batfish (Ephippidae) are tall, compressed fish that cruise in schools. The Atlantic spadefish (Chaetodipterus faber) is common around wrecks and oil platforms in the Gulf of Mexico and Caribbean. Indo-Pacific batfish (Platax) are famously curious and often accompany divers; their juveniles mimic dead leaves or toxic flatworms. Sweepers (Pempheridae) are small, coppery-silver fish that pack into caves by day and leave to feed on plankton at night. Fusiliers (Caesionidae) are streamlined plankton feeders that stream past reef walls in blue-and-yellow rivers.
| Group | Size | Diet | Where to see them |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jacks & trevallies | 30 cm–1.7 m | Fish, squid | Channels, drop-offs, open water |
| Barracudas | 50 cm–2 m | Fish | Reef edges, seagrass, schools in currents |
| Spadefish & batfish | 30–70 cm | Invertebrates, plankton, algae | Wrecks, reef tops, around divers |
| Sweepers | 10–20 cm | Plankton | Caves and overhangs |
| Fusiliers | 15–40 cm | Plankton | Upper reef walls in current |
| Silversides, scad | 5–25 cm | Plankton | Dense baitballs in summer |
What about baitfish schools?
The food that feeds everything else.
Silversides, herrings, anchovies and scad gather in shimmering clouds around reefs, especially in caves and over wrecks in summer. Divers in places like Cozumel, Bonaire and the Cayman Islands see caverns so packed with silversides that they part like a curtain. These schools draw in jacks, tarpon, barracudas and seabirds. Tarpon, the “silver king”, are giant silvery fish up to 2.5 m that hang in Caribbean swim-throughs and wrecks.
How does silver camouflage actually work?
A silver fish is not simply shiny. Its skin and scales hold stacks of flat guanine crystals separated by thin layers of cytoplasm, and the spacing of those layers decides which wavelengths are reflected. The British physiologist Eric Denton worked out in the 1960s and 1970s that the crystals in fish such as herring and bleak are tilted to stay close to vertical as the body curves, so the whole flank behaves like a flat mirror hung in the water. Because daylight underwater is close to symmetrical around the vertical axis, a vertical mirror shows a predator the same blue it would see if the fish were not there.
Later work added two refinements. Ordinary multilayer mirrors become less reflective, and polarise light, at certain angles. In 2012 a Bristol team led by Tom Jordan showed that herring, sardines and sprats avoid that weakness by mixing two kinds of guanine crystal with different optical properties, giving a broadband mirror that does not lose brightness when light hits it obliquely. In 2015 a Texas group reported that the lookdown, a flat silver jack, manipulates polarised light so well that it appears to match the background better than a perfect mirror would. Other optics researchers questioned the statistics and the habitat assumptions behind that claim, and the debate is a reminder that how predators actually see these fish is still being worked out.
The mirror trick has a limit. From directly below, a fish blocks the bright surface and shows as a dark silhouette, which is why many open-water hunters attack from beneath. Some deep-water fish solve that with belly lights, but reef-edge silver fish rely on schooling, speed and the confusion of a thousand flashing flanks.
Which jacks will you meet on a reef?
Jacks are one of the most varied fish families on the reef edge, and a few species account for most sightings. In the Caribbean the bar jack, with its electric-blue stripe from back to tail, often rides close above foraging stingrays and goatfish, grabbing small animals they disturb from the sand. Horse-eye jacks school in the hundreds around walls and wrecks. Permit, deep-bodied silver jacks prized by fly anglers, cruise sand flats and reef edges in search of crabs. In the Indo-Pacific the bluefin trevally hunts in small, fast packs over the reef top, often alongside octopus or goatfish, and bigeye trevally hang in dense, slow spirals on current-swept points.
Other members of the family look nothing like the classic jack. Rainbow runners are slim, torpedo-shaped and striped blue and yellow. Amberjacks are large, powerful predators of deeper reefs and wrecks. Pilot fish ride the pressure wave in front of sharks, turtles and even boats. Juvenile jacks of several species shelter among the tentacles of jellyfish or under drifting weed, and some juveniles swim in front of divers for the same reason.
The giant trevally is the heavyweight of the group. At Farquhar Atoll in the Seychelles, filmed for the BBC’s Blue Planet II, trevally learned to track fledgling sooty terns in flight and leap clear of the water to catch them as they landed on the sea. Giant trevally also tolerate fresh and brackish water unusually well for a reef fish, and recent genetic work has found that the Hawaiian population, known there as ulua, is genetically distinct from fish elsewhere in the Pacific.
What is a barracuda’s life like?
The great barracuda begins life in sheltered water. Young fish live in mangrove creeks and seagrass meadows, where their thin bodies and dark bars let them hover among roots and blades like a floating twig. As they grow they move out to the reef and open water, where adults may roam widely between favoured sites. In the Florida Keys, where barracuda are a popular sport fish, researchers have aged them from ear bones and tracked their spawning seasons to help manage the fishery.
Barracudas are ambush predators rather than chasers. They hang almost motionless, often with dark blotches showing on the lower flank, then accelerate in a short burst to seize prey sideways in the jaws. Large fangs grip and slice; prey too big to swallow whole may be cut in two. The fish’s apparent fearlessness around divers is partly a product of this strategy: an ambush hunter saves energy by watching and waiting, and a diver is just one more object to watch.

Can a batfish save a coral reef?
Batfish are better known for their charm than their ecology, but one experiment made them famous among reef scientists. In 2006 David Bellwood and colleagues fenced off plots on the inshore Great Barrier Reef, let them become overgrown with large seaweeds, then filmed which fish removed the algae once the cages came off. They expected parrotfish and rabbitfish. Instead, a single species, the dusky batfish Platax pinnatus, did almost all of the work, a fish rarely counted as an important grazer at all.
The authors called it a “sleeping functional group”: a species that normally plays a minor role but becomes critical when a reef tips toward seaweed. Batfish are heavily fished in parts of the Indo-Pacific, and the study became a warning that the loss of an apparently unimportant species may weaken a reef’s ability to recover.
Why do some sweepers glow?
Sweepers and their relatives fill caves and overhangs during the day and rise into open water to feed at night. In the golden sweeper Parapriacanthus, which forms glowing schools in the western Pacific, the light comes from organs near the gut and throat. In 2020 a Japanese team showed that the fish does not make its own light-producing enzyme. It gets both the enzyme and its fuel from the luminous ostracods, tiny crustaceans, that it eats, and stores them in its light organs. The researchers called the trick kleptoprotein bioluminescence, the first known case of an animal stealing a functional enzyme from its food.
How are fusiliers related to snappers?
Fusiliers look like a different kind of fish from snappers, slim, fork-tailed and blue and yellow rather than heavy-bodied and red, but genetic studies place them inside the snapper family, Lutjanidae. They are snappers that switched from hunting on the bottom to picking plankton out of the current, and their small protrusible mouths and streamlined bodies evolved for that job. Rivers of fusiliers along a wall are a good sign of strong currents and a healthy supply of plankton, and they in turn feed jacks, mackerel and reef sharks.
What makes tarpon different?
Tarpon look like oversized herrings but belong to an older lineage, the Elopomorpha, which they share with eels and bonefish. Like eels, they begin life as transparent, ribbon-shaped leptocephalus larvae that drift offshore before transforming into tiny fish and moving into mangroves, ponds and tidal creeks. Juveniles survive in stagnant, low-oxygen water because tarpon can gulp air at the surface and absorb oxygen through a modified swim bladder, a trait adults keep. Divers often see them rise to “roll” at the surface between dives.
Adult tarpon can live for several decades and are among the most prized catch-and-release game fish in Florida and the Caribbean. The IUCN lists the Atlantic tarpon as Vulnerable, mainly because of overfishing in parts of its range and the loss of the mangrove nurseries the young depend on.
Why does cooking not remove ciguatera?
Ciguatoxins are fat-soluble, heat-stable compounds, so cooking, freezing, smoking or marinating a fish has no effect on them, and an affected fish looks, smells and tastes normal. The microalgae that make the precursors, mainly species of Gambierdiscus, grow on seaweeds and dead coral surfaces, and outbreaks have been linked to disturbance such as storms, dredging and bleaching that open up new surfaces for them. Herbivorous fish ingest the toxins, predators eat the herbivores, and the toxins concentrate in older, larger fish and in their liver, guts and roe.
Ciguatera is thought to be the most common non-bacterial seafood illness in the world. Estimates run into the tens of thousands of cases a year, but most are never reported, and in small Pacific island communities it shapes which fish are eaten. Local knowledge is the best guide: fishers usually know which reefs and which species are risky.
Where can you see the biggest silver schools?
Some of the most famous fish spectacles in diving are silver ones. Barracuda Point at Sipadan, off Borneo, is known for vortexes of chevron barracuda, and bigeye trevally form similar spirals at sites across the Indo-Pacific and the Red Sea. At Cabo Pulmo in the Gulf of California, a no-take reserve created in 1995, fish biomass rose by more than 400% over the following decade, and the resulting schools of bigeye jacks, a cousin of the bigeye trevally, are now one of the best-known recovery stories in marine conservation. In the Caribbean, summer brings silverside clouds to caves in Cozumel and the Cayman Islands, with tarpon and jacks hunting through them.
Are silvery reef fish safe to eat?
Usually, but watch out for ciguatera.
Large reef predators accumulate ciguatoxins, produced by a dinoflagellate (Gambierdiscus) that grows on algae and works its way up the food chain. Great barracuda, large jacks, amberjacks and some groupers and snappers are the most common culprits. Symptoms include nausea, tingling and a reversal of hot and cold sensation that can last weeks. Many Caribbean islands advise against eating large barracuda altogether. Smaller jacks, spadefish and baitfish are widely and safely eaten.
How do schools of fish move together?
Simple rules, spectacular results.
A school of thousands of silversides or trevally has no leader. Each fish follows a few simple rules: stay close to your neighbours, match their speed and direction, and avoid collisions. Fish sense neighbours with their eyes and with the lateral line, a row of pressure-sensitive pores along each flank that detects water movements. When a predator strikes, the reaction ripples through the school faster than any individual could see the threat, producing the “flash expansion” and “fountain effect” that divers see when a jack charges a baitball.
Schooling also saves energy, as fish ride the vortices of those ahead, and improves the odds of finding food and mates. Predators respond with tactics of their own: jacks and tuna hunt in packs to herd baitfish against the surface or the reef, and barracudas take turns to slash through the school. These feeding frenzies, most common at dawn and dusk and in summer, are among the most dramatic events on any reef.

Why are some fish silver?
Guanine crystals in their skin act as mirrors, reflecting the surrounding water so they blend in.
What silver fish live around coral reefs?
Jacks, trevallies, barracudas, spadefish, batfish, sweepers, fusiliers, tarpon and baitfish.
Are barracudas dangerous?
Rarely. Bites are very uncommon and usually involve shiny objects or speared fish.
What is the largest jack?
The giant trevally, up to about 1.7 m and 80 kg.
Why do barracudas follow divers?
They are curious and opportunistic, and divers sometimes flush prey.
Can you eat barracuda?
Small ones are eaten, but large barracuda frequently carry ciguatera toxin.
What is a spadefish?
A tall, disc-shaped schooling fish common around wrecks in the western Atlantic.
Why do fish school?
Safety in numbers, confusing predators, easier feeding and finding mates.
- Denton, E. J. (1970). On the organization of reflecting surfaces in some marine animals. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B 258: 285–313.
- BBC Blue Planet II (2017). Giant trevally feeding on fledgling sooty terns, Farquhar Atoll, Seychelles.
- Froese, R. & Pauly, D. (eds.). FishBase. www.fishbase.org.
- Humann, P. & DeLoach, N. (2014). Reef Fish Identification: Florida, Caribbean, Bahamas, 4th ed. New World Publications.
- Jordan, T. M., Partridge, J. C. & Roberts, N. W. (2012). Non-polarizing broadband multilayer reflectors in fish. Nature Photonics 6: 759–763.
- Brady, P. C. et al. (2015). Open-ocean fish reveal an omnidirectional solution to camouflage in polarized environments. Science 350: 965–969; and comment by Cronin, T. W. et al. (2016), Science.
- Bellwood, D. R., Hughes, T. P. & Hoey, A. S. (2006). Sleeping functional group drives coral-reef recovery. Current Biology, doi:10.1016/j.cub.2006.10.030.
- Bessho-Uehara, M. et al. (2020). Kleptoprotein bioluminescence: Parapriacanthus fish obtain luciferase from ostracod prey. Science Advances 6: eaax4942.
- Pickett, B. D. et al. (2021). Genome of a giant (trevally): Caranx ignobilis. bioRxiv, doi:10.1101/2021.09.11.459923.
- Kadison, E., D’Alessandro, E. K., Davis, G. O. & Hood, P. B. (2010). Age, growth, and reproductive patterns of the great barracuda from the Florida Keys. Bulletin of Marine Science, doi:10.5343/bms.2009.1070.
- Aburto-Oropeza, O. et al. (2011). Large recovery of fish biomass in a no-take marine reserve. PLoS ONE 6: e23601.
- Soliño, L. & Costa, P. R. (2020). Global impact of ciguatoxins and ciguatera fish poisoning on fish, fisheries and consumers. Environmental Research 182: 109111.
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.