Rachel Wall — Pirate Legend and the Last Woman Hanged in Massachusetts
Rachel Wall (c. 1760–1789) was a Pennsylvania-born woman hanged on Boston Common on October 8, 1789, for highway robbery, the last woman executed in Massachusetts. She is often called America’s first female pirate, said to have lured ships off the Isles of Shoals with her husband George in 1781–82, but her own printed confession admits only thefts in Boston, and the pirate story is unproven.
Rachel Wall is often called America’s first female pirate. What can be proved is narrower but still remarkable: she was a Pennsylvania-born woman with a long record of thefts in Boston, she was convicted of highway robbery, and on October 8, 1789, she became the last woman executed in Massachusetts. The pirate story came later, and its key details cannot be confirmed.
Who was Rachel Wall?
She was a servant and repeat thief in post-Revolutionary Boston who was hanged on Boston Common for robbing a teenage girl of her bonnet. Legends say that a few years earlier she had helped her husband lure ships to their doom off the Isles of Shoals.
Two kinds of story exist about her, and they need to be kept apart. The first comes from court records, newspapers of the 1780s and the printed confession she dictated the night before she died. It describes a poor, often desperate woman who was repeatedly caught stealing, punished with whipping and public humiliation, sold into servitude when she could not pay damages, and finally sentenced to death. The second, much more colourful story describes a pirate crew, a stolen schooner, a woman screaming for help on deck after storms, a dozen ships taken and two dozen sailors murdered. That second story is what made her famous, but no document from her lifetime is known to support it.
This page sets out what each version says, where it comes from and how much weight it can bear. The distinction matters, because many popular accounts, including earlier versions of this page, repeated the pirate legend as fact and even stated that she was hanged for murder. She was not. She was hanged for highway robbery, a crime she denied to the end.

Where did Rachel Wall come from?
According to her own account, Rachel Wall was born in about 1760 near Carlisle, Pennsylvania, in the Cumberland Valley west of the Susquehanna River. Later writers give her maiden name as Schmidt. One modern account gives an exact birth date of October 1, 1760, though most sources simply say about 1760, and her confession states that she died in the twenty-ninth year of her age, which fits a birth around 1760.
She described her parents as honest and reputable people. Her father was a farmer, said to be prosperous and of a serious and devout turn of mind, and the family belonged to the Presbyterian church, the dominant denomination among the Scots-Irish settlers of that part of Pennsylvania. She had several brothers and sisters. In her confession she presents her younger self as restless and disobedient, someone who ran away from home, came back, and then left again for good.
Her final departure came when she married George Wall without her parents’ knowledge or consent. Accounts differ about how they met. Later retellings say he was a fisherman and that he rescued her from a fight on a waterfront, but those details do not come from her confession. What she did say is that she never saw her family again after leaving with him.
How did she end up in Boston?
The couple moved first to Philadelphia, then spent a few months in New York City before arriving in Boston. There George left her, and she later described herself as an entire stranger in the city. To support herself she went into service as a domestic servant, reportedly in the Beacon Hill area, and by her own account she was content in that work for a time.
That stability did not last. In the most quoted line of her confession, she said that as soon as George came back, he enticed her to leave her service and take to bad company, from which she dated her ruin. The “bad company” is never described in detail. Supporters of the pirate story read the phrase as a coded reference to a pirate crew. It could just as easily refer to the thieves and drinkers of Boston’s waterfront, which is the world her documented crimes actually belong to.
George himself had trouble with the law. In 1785, when he was being held in a Boston jail, Rachel baked him a loaf or cake with a saw, a file and other tools hidden inside in an attempt to help him escape. The jailer passed it on, but the plot was discovered before he could get out. Afterwards George left her again, and she said that she did not know where he was. She forgave him in her final statement.
What does the pirate legend say?
The popular version of Rachel Wall’s life runs roughly as follows. In 1781 George Wall returned to Boston with a group of sailors and persuaded Rachel to join them. After spending their money, the group took a schooner, often named as the Essex, and sailed north to the Isles of Shoals, a cluster of rocky islands off the border of New Hampshire and Maine.
After storms, the story goes, they would make the schooner look damaged and Rachel would stand on deck calling for help. When another vessel came alongside to rescue them, the crew boarded it, killed the people aboard, looted the cargo and sank the ship. Over about two seasons, in 1781 and 1782, they are said to have taken 12 vessels and killed 24 sailors. Some versions say they stole about $6,000 in cash plus other valuables; others put the haul at more than $12,000. The adventure supposedly ended in 1782, when a storm wrecked the schooner and drowned George and the crew, while Rachel was rescued and returned to Boston.
It is a vivid tale, and it has been retold many times in books, magazines and websites about women pirates and New England crime. It is the reason Rachel Wall appears in lists of famous female pirates alongside Anne Bonny, Mary Read and Grace O’Malley, and the reason she is often described as the first American-born woman to commit piracy.
Is there evidence that she was a pirate?
Very little. Historians who have examined the surviving documents point out that her printed confession, the fullest first-hand account of her life, does not describe any piracy at all. It lists a string of thefts, many of them from ships in Boston harbour, but nothing about luring vessels at sea, killing sailors or raiding off the Isles of Shoals. The Massachusetts Historical Society, which holds a copy of the broadside, describes the Isles of Shoals attacks as supposed and notes that there is no actual evidence for them.
Several details of the legend sit awkwardly with her own words. The legend says George drowned in 1782, yet in 1785 he was in a Boston jail and she was smuggling tools to him, and in 1789 she said only that he had left her and that she did not know where he was. The figures for the ships taken, the men killed and the money stolen also vary from one retelling to the next, which is typical of stories that grow with each telling rather than being copied from a record.
Some modern accounts, including a National Park Service profile and a New England Historical Society article, say that she admitted to piracy at her trial or asked to be tried as a pirate rather than a thief, while denying that she had ever killed anyone. Other writers who have worked from the confession and the newspaper record find no such admission. Without the trial papers being published in full, the safest conclusion is that the piracy story is unproven. One plausible explanation, suggested by researchers of early American crime, is that her real habit of slipping aboard moored ships at night to rob sleeping officers was later inflated into a career of piracy on the open sea.
What were the Isles of Shoals like at the time?
The setting of the legend is real enough. The Isles of Shoals lie about 10 km off the coast, straddling the Maine–New Hampshire border near Portsmouth. They had been an important cod-fishing station since the early 1600s, and by the 18th century the New Hampshire side supported a fishing village called Gosport on Star Island.
During the Revolutionary War, however, the islands were exposed to British warships, and around 1778 most of the islanders were evacuated to the mainland at Rye, New Hampshire. A small population stayed, but the islands were largely deserted for decades. That would have made the area a lonely stretch of water in the early 1780s, which some writers use to explain why a pirate schooner could have operated there unnoticed. It also means that there were few local witnesses, and no contemporary record of a wave of disappearances in that area has been produced to support the story.

What crimes did Rachel Wall actually commit?
Her documented record is one of repeated theft, harsh punishment and deepening poverty. In 1785 she pleaded guilty to stealing goods from the Boston lawyer Perez Morton, a Revolutionary patriot who later became Speaker of the Massachusetts House. She was ordered to pay triple damages of eighteen pounds, to be whipped fifteen lashes and to pay court costs. Unable to pay, she was sold into servitude for three years, a common punishment at the time for convicted thieves who had no money.
While in servitude she kept stealing. In her confession she described nighttime excursions aboard ships moored at Boston’s wharves. In the spring of 1787, she said, she slipped aboard a vessel at Long Wharf and took a black silk handkerchief containing about thirty pounds in gold and small change from under the head of the sleeping captain, whom she thought was a Frenchman. Around 1788 she boarded a sloop at Doane’s Wharf and took a silver watch, silver shoe buckles and some coins while the crew slept.
In 1788, about three years after she had first been sold, she was caught with two accomplices trying to rob the house of a man named Lemuel Ludden. She pleaded guilty to housebreaking and theft. This time her sentence included paying Ludden twenty-four pounds, sitting on the gallows for an hour with a rope around her neck, a ritual of public shaming, and a whipping. Once again she could not pay, and once again she was sold as a servant.
Her confession also cleared another woman. She admitted that a theft on Essex Street for which Dorothy Horn, a disabled woman from the Boston almshouse, had been imprisoned, set on the gallows for an hour and whipped had in fact been committed by Rachel herself. By her own account she had committed “a great many” such crimes and almost every other sin, except murder.
What crime was she hanged for?
Rachel Wall was hanged for highway robbery. In March 1789 a 17-year-old girl named Margaret Bender was attacked on a Boston street. The attacker tried to take her bonnet, struck her in the face and forced a handkerchief into her mouth. Reports say the girl also lost her shoes and buckles in the struggle. A passer-by named Thomas Dawes went to help Bender, and another man, Charles Berry, chased and caught the woman he said was the attacker. It was Rachel Wall.
For the only time in her criminal career, Wall pleaded not guilty. She said she had been working all of the previous day, that she had only been walking past when she heard a commotion, and that she had been seized by mistake. At her trial before the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts in late summer 1789, nine witnesses described her capture and Bender’s injuries, but only Berry positively identified her as the attacker.
Her court-appointed lawyers, reportedly including the future Massachusetts governor Christopher Gore, argued that because she had never actually held the bonnet, the crime was at most attempted robbery, which did not carry the death penalty. The jury rejected that argument and found her guilty of highway robbery. Attorney General Robert Treat Paine, a signer of the Declaration of Independence, asked for a death sentence. According to one account, the sentence was pronounced by Justice William Cushing in one of his last judgments before he joined the new United States Supreme Court. Governor John Hancock signed the order for her execution.
The Massachusetts Historical Society notes that this was her third robbery conviction, which made her a repeat offender in the eyes of the court. It has also raised the possibility that rumours about her past may have influenced the severity of the outcome, while stressing that this is speculation. What is clear is that the charge was robbery, not murder and not piracy.
What did her dying confession say?
On the night of October 7, 1789, the day before her execution, Wall dictated her statement to the deputy jailer, Joseph Otis, and his assistant, William Crombie. It was printed and sold as a broadside under the title Life, Last Words and Dying Confession, of Rachel Wall, illustrated with a crude woodcut of three hanged figures, the middle one a woman. Copies survive at the Massachusetts Historical Society and the American Antiquarian Society.
Such “last words” were a popular genre in early New England. Printers sold them to the crowds at executions, and ministers and officials used them to present the condemned as a warning to others. They followed a familiar pattern: a short life story, an account of the first steps into sin, a list of crimes, a plea to young people to avoid the same path, and a statement of repentance. Historians such as Daniel E. Williams, who collected many of these texts in Pillars of Salt (1993), treat them as valuable but shaped documents, partly the voice of the condemned and partly the voice of the people who wrote them down and printed them.
Wall’s confession follows the pattern closely. She blamed her disobedience to her parents and her husband’s influence for her downfall, confessed to her many petty thefts and cleared Dorothy Horn, but firmly denied the robbery of Margaret Bender, saying that the witnesses were “certainly mistaken”. She forgave them and ended by committing her soul into the hands of Almighty God, relying on his mercy, and describing herself as an unworthy member of the Presbyterian church, in the twenty-ninth year of her age.
How was Rachel Wall executed?
She was hanged on Boston Common on Thursday, October 8, 1789, together with two men, William Smith and William Dunogan, who had also been convicted of highway robbery. Public hangings at the time drew large crowds, and the National Park Service describes the audience as numbering in the thousands. Executions were meant to be public lessons, with sermons, prayers and the reading or sale of confessions.
The three were the last people executed in Massachusetts for highway robbery. Massachusetts soon narrowed the list of crimes punishable by death, so their hanging marked the end of an era. Rachel Wall is also recorded as the last woman executed by the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. Earlier women had been hanged there, including Bathsheba Spooner in 1778 for arranging her husband’s murder, but none has been executed since 1789.
Why is Rachel Wall remembered?
Rachel Wall stands at the meeting point of two histories. In the history of crime and punishment she is a significant figure: a poor woman hanged for a property crime at a time when Massachusetts was about to stop executing people for such offences, and the last woman put to death by the state. Her case shows how the courts of the 1780s handled repeat offenders, how debtors and thieves could be sold into servitude, and how public punishments such as whipping and sitting on the gallows were used to shame the convicted.
In the history of piracy she is far more doubtful. The so-called golden age of Atlantic piracy had ended a generation before she was born, and the most famous women pirates, Anne Bonny and Mary Read, were tried in Jamaica in 1720. If the Isles of Shoals story were true, Rachel Wall would be a late and unusual example of a woman directly involved in piracy in American waters. Because it cannot be confirmed, the most accurate description is that she is a reputed pirate and a documented thief.
Her story also shows how legends grow. A handful of genuine facts, including a husband who went to sea, thefts from ships in the harbour and a dramatic public execution, were combined over time into a full-blown pirate career with precise numbers of ships and victims. Readers who come across those numbers should treat them with caution. The real Rachel Wall, as revealed by court records and her own last words, is less glamorous but more human: a young woman far from home, bound into servitude, caught again and again for petty theft, and executed for a robbery she insisted she did not commit.
Related reading: Anne Bonny, Mary Read and Grace O’Malley.

Related on TheSea
Was Rachel Wall really America’s first female pirate?
That is how she is often described, but it is not proven. Her printed confession does not mention piracy, and no record from her lifetime confirms the Isles of Shoals story. She is best described as a reputed pirate and a documented thief.
What was Rachel Wall hanged for?
Highway robbery. She was convicted of attacking 17-year-old Margaret Bender on a Boston street in 1789 and trying to take her bonnet. She denied the crime.
Was Rachel Wall charged with murder?
No. She was tried and hanged for highway robbery. In her confession she admitted many thefts and said she had committed almost every sin except murder.
When and where was she executed?
On October 8, 1789, on Boston Common, together with William Smith and William Dunogan, who were also convicted of highway robbery.
Was she the last woman executed in Massachusetts?
Yes. She is recorded as the last woman executed by the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, and she and the two men hanged with her were the last people executed there for highway robbery.
What happened to George Wall?
Legend says he drowned in a storm in 1782, but he was in a Boston jail in 1785, and in 1789 Rachel said he had left her and she did not know where he was.
Where can her confession be seen?
Copies of the 1789 broadside Life, Last Words and Dying Confession, of Rachel Wall are held by the Massachusetts Historical Society and the American Antiquarian Society.
- Wall, Rachel (1789). Life, Last Words and Dying Confession, of Rachel Wall. Broadside, Boston. Massachusetts Historical Society; American Antiquarian Society.
- Massachusetts Historical Society (2018). “Rachel Wall’s Confession, the words of a Pirate?” The Beehive blog.
- National Park Service. Rachel Wall, Boston National Historical Park people profile.
- Early American Crime. Rachel Wall: court records and newspaper reports, 1785–1789.
- Past is Present / American Antiquarian Society (2025). “In Her Own Words: The Life and Death of Rachel Wall.”
- Landrigan, L. (2016). “Rachel Wall, New England’s Only Lady Pirate.” New England Historical Society.
- Williams, D.E. (ed.) (1993). Pillars of Salt: An Anthology of Early American Criminal Narratives. Madison House.
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.
About Blane Perun →More on Pirates →