Exploring Earth's Oceans Since 1999 · Founded by Blane Perun
3,072 Articles·80+ Countries·25 Years of Ocean Science·Site Map
◆ Trending
25 years exploring Earth's oceans,
coral reefs, and the creatures within.
3,072Articles
80+Countries
1999Founded

Whydah Gally Remains: The Wreck Site, the Pirates’ Bones and the Search for Black Sam Bellamy

Whydah Gally Remains — What Is Left of the Ship and the Pirates Who Sailed Her

Shipwrecks Whydah
November 7, 2026
13 min read
Whydah wreck at a glance
Wrecked
Around midnight, April 26, 1717, in a nor’easter
Location
Off Wellfleet, outer Cape Cod, Massachusetts
Aboard / lost
146 aboard; 144–145 lost
Survivors
2 from the Whydah: Thomas Davis and John Julian
Found
1984, by Barry Clifford
Depth
~14–30 ft (4–9 m), under sand
Artifacts
200,000+ pieces recovered
Human remains
Child’s fibula; femur (DNA-tested 2018); six skeletons (2021)

What remains of the Whydah Gally?

No intact hull. The Whydah Gally broke up in the surf off Wellfleet, Cape Cod, on the night of April 26, 1717, and what remains is a debris field of cannons, concretions, coins, timbers and human bone spread under shifting sand in roughly 14 to 30 feet of water.

The Whydah Gally is the only fully authenticated Golden Age pirate shipwreck, confirmed when divers raised its bell, inscribed “THE WHYDAH GALLY 1716,” in the fall of 1985, and supported by a brass placard bearing the ship’s name found in 2013. Since explorer Barry Clifford located the site in 1984, his teams have recovered more than 200,000 individual pieces. This page is about a smaller and more personal part of that collection: the people. It covers what happened to the bodies in 1717, the bones recovered since, and the forensic and DNA work that is trying to put names to them, including the long search for Captain Samuel “Black Sam” Bellamy himself.

whydah gally remains: Whydah Gally Remains: The Wreck Site, the Pirates’ Bones and the Search for Black Sam Bellamy
whydah gally remains

How did the Whydah break apart?

She ran aground on a sandbar in a violent nor’easter around midnight, capsized, and was torn apart by the surf. Her heavy guns and treasure pinned debris to the bottom as the hull disintegrated, and the wreckage was eventually spread along roughly four miles of coast. Accounts of the site’s depth vary because the sand moves so much: descriptions range from about 14 feet of water over 5 feet of sand to 16 to 30 feet of water over sand 10 to 50 feet deep, depending on season, storms and exactly where along the debris field you measure.

The ship had been in pirate hands for only about two months. Built in London as a slave ship, launched in 1716 and rated at 300 tons burthen, she was chased for three days by Bellamy’s company and surrendered by Captain Lawrence Prince near the Bahamas in late February 1717, after the pursuit through the Windward Passage. Bellamy added cannon to her original 18 and put about 150 men aboard. Divers have since found more than 30 cannon in the wreck. Bellamy’s company sailed north along the American coast with a small fleet of captured vessels until the storm caught them off the outer Cape.

146
People aboard
2
Survivors from the Whydah
101–102
Bodies buried ashore (Southack)
200,000+
Artifacts recovered

What happened to the pirates’ bodies in 1717?

Most of the crew drowned in the surf. Of the 146 people aboard, only two survived; the rest, 144 or 145 depending on the count, died.

Massachusetts governor Samuel Shute sent the salvager Captain Cyprian Southack to the wreck. He arrived on May 3, 1717, when parts of the ship were still visible above the water, and he recorded burying 102 bodies that had washed ashore (some modern summaries round this to about 101). He drew a map of the site and recovered little of the treasure. That left somewhere around 40 to 43 men unaccounted for, never washed ashore or never identified. Captain Bellamy was among them, which is why every new discovery of human bone at the wreck raises the same question: could this be him?

The two survivors from the Whydah itself were Thomas Davis, a Welsh carpenter who had been forced into piracy, and John Julian, a young Miskito Indian pilot from the coast of Central America. Seven more men came ashore from the captured sloop Mary Anne, which had been sailing with Bellamy and also wrecked. The survivors were taken to Boston. On October 18, 1717, six were tried for piracy, and the convictions were recorded on October 22: John Brown, Thomas Baker, Hendrick Quintor, Peter Cornelius Hoof, John Shuan and Simon Van Vorst. They were hanged in Boston on November 15, 1717, after the minister Cotton Mather had visited them in jail and walked with them to the gallows; his diary records that “Six Pirates were this Day executed.” Thomas Davis and Thomas South were acquitted because they had been forced to serve. John Julian was sold into slavery.

What are concretions, and why do they hold the bones?

Very little of the Whydah lies on the seabed as loose objects. Over three centuries, iron from cannon, shot, tools and fittings corroded in seawater and cemented sand, shell and everything nearby into rock-hard lumps called concretions. University of New Haven forensic scientist Tim Palmbach, who leads the team examining the remains, describes gold, guns, muskets, bones and clothing all hardened together into blocks that can weigh hundreds to thousands of pounds.

Concretions are a mixed blessing for forensic work. They destroy surface detail on many objects, but they also seal bone away from waves, scouring sand and scavengers, which is why skeletal material has survived at a shallow surf-zone wreck at all. Recovering it is painfully slow. The team X-rays each concretion first to find bones before any chipping starts, and Palmbach has said that extracting a single bone can take a month. Many concretions raised from the site have yet to be opened, so the human story of the wreck is still emerging piece by piece.

Have human remains been found in the wreck?

Yes. There are three main finds: a child’s leg bone, a femur tested against Bellamy’s family in 2018, and the partial skeletons of six people announced in 2021.

Year announcedFindWhat it showed
2006Fibula, with a child-sized leather shoe and French silk stockingBone from a child aged about 8–11, linked to John King, the youngest known crew member
2018Leg bone (femur) from a concretion near a pistol, DNA-tested against a living Bellamy descendantNot Bellamy: a man with general ties to the Eastern Mediterranean
2021Six skeletons in concretions (one complete, parts of five)Some bones broken as the ship capsized; one man had a pistol and probably gold in his pocket

John King: the boy pirate

The first human remains to be linked to a named crew member were found decades before anyone could test them. A small fibula, a silk stocking and a child’s shoe lay in storage for nearly 20 years before Clifford and the project’s historian connected them with John King. The shoe is only about 2 inches wide at its widest point and of an upper-class design, and the stocking is woven French silk. Expedition archaeologist John de Bry and Smithsonian anthropologist David Hunt agreed that the fibula came from a child aged about 8 to 11. The find was announced in 2006, almost 290 years after the wreck.

King’s story is known from a deposition by Abijah Savage, commander of the Antiguan sloop Bonetta, filed with the governor of Antigua on November 30, 1716. Bellamy’s company attacked the Bonetta on November 9 and held her for 15 days. King was a passenger, travelling with his mother from Jamaica to Antigua. According to Savage, the boy “deserted his sloop, and went with the Pirates,” declared he “would Kill himself if he was Restrained,” and even threatened his mother. Five months later he died on the Whydah. Sources put his age at the time at 10 or 11. He is the youngest pirate whose remains are thought to have been identified anywhere.

The 2018 DNA test: was it Bellamy?

In 2018 the museum put on display a human leg bone that had been recovered from a concretion near a pistol believed to have belonged to Bellamy. The location made the bone a natural candidate, and the museum enlisted forensic scientists to extract DNA and compare it with DNA from a living Bellamy descendant in England. In May 2018 the museum announced the result: the bone was not Bellamy’s. It came from a man whose DNA showed general ties to the Eastern Mediterranean.

A negative result was still informative. It confirmed that the method could recover usable DNA from a bone that had spent three centuries in a concretion in the surf zone, and it added to the evidence that Bellamy’s crew was extraordinarily mixed. The men tried in Boston carried English, Welsh and Dutch-sounding names, the surviving pilot was a Miskito Indian, and the ship had only recently been a slaver, so her company drew on seamen from across Europe, Africa and the Americas. A single sailor of Eastern Mediterranean descent, lying beside his captain’s pistol, is a reminder that the “pirates of Cape Cod” were an international company.

The six skeletons found in 2021

In February 2021 Clifford’s team announced that it had found the remains of at least six people inside several concretions: one complete skeleton and portions of five others. The complete skeleton was found with a pistol in hand and metal, probably gold, in a pocket. Clifford believes the man was killed by a roll of lead weighing about 400 pounds that lay on top of him in the concretion. Some bones were broken, probably as the ship capsized. “This shipwreck is very sacred ground,” Clifford said, adding that he hoped modern technology would help identify the pirates and reunite them with descendants.

The remains went to the University of New Haven’s forensic team, part of its Henry C. Lee College of Criminal Justice and Forensic Sciences. Palmbach described the goal as identifying as many as possible of the roughly 140 people who died, including the enslaved people believed to have been aboard, and returning remains for proper burial. He said the team remained “still really hopeful” of finding Bellamy. As of the most recent public reports found for this update, none of the remains has been publicly confirmed as Bellamy or matched to another named crewman.

How do you identify a 300-year-old pirate?

Identifying shipwreck dead combines several lines of evidence. The first is context: where in the wreck the bones lay and what lay with them, such as the pistol beside the 2018 femur or the child’s shoe beside John King’s fibula. The second is the skeleton itself. Forensic anthropologists estimate age from bone development and joint wear, sex from the pelvis and skull, and stature from long-bone lengths, and they note old injuries, healed fractures and signs of hard labour. For a ship where the crew list, trial testimony and depositions give names and rough ages, even these broad details can narrow the possibilities.

DNA is the decisive step, and the hardest. Bone left in seawater loses much of its DNA, and what survives is fragmented and easily contaminated by modern handling. Palmbach has explained that long bones, and especially their ends, tend to give the best results, and that because testing destroys the sample, the team tries to use the smallest piece possible. A profile from the bone is only useful if there is something to compare it with. That usually means tracing living relatives through genealogy and matching DNA passed down a family line, as was done with the Bellamy descendant in England. For most of the Whydah’s crew, including the Africans who had been held aboard her as a slave ship and the many men known only by a first name, no such family tree exists, so identification may never be possible. Even then, DNA can still reveal broad ancestry, as it did in 2018, and add to what is known about who the crew were.

What else science has learned from the wreck

The forensic approach extends beyond bones. In March 2026 a team including Clifford and archaeologist DeCorse published an analysis in npj Heritage Science of Akan gold ornaments from the Whydah, made in West Africa and probably taken aboard during her slaving voyage. Using portable X-ray fluorescence and scanning electron microscopy, they measured the gold’s elemental composition and compared it with ore from Ghana’s Ashanti Gold Belt. European writers of the period often claimed that African traders routinely passed off heavily adulterated gold; the study found that most of the Whydah gold fell within the natural variation of West African gold, and did not support claims of systematic heavy adulteration, although the methods could not rule out some deliberate additions of silver or copper.

Work like this matters for the human remains too. The Whydah was a slave ship before she was a pirate ship, and her maiden voyage carried captives from West Africa to the Caribbean. Studying her cargo, crew and bones together turns the wreck into evidence about the Atlantic slave trade as much as about piracy.

The ethics of raising the dead

Excavating human remains from a shipwreck raises questions that do not apply to coins or cannon. The men who died on the Whydah were buried by the sea, and for some of them, including any Africans still aboard from her slaving voyage, death at sea was the end of a life that had been taken from them long before the storm. Clifford’s own description of the site as sacred ground reflects that tension. The stated aims of the forensic work answer some of it: to give names back to people who were lost, to find living relatives where possible, and to return remains for proper burial rather than keep them indefinitely as exhibits.

There are also practical arguments for careful recovery. The site lies in a high-energy surf zone where storms strip and rebury the seabed, and concretions that are exposed can break apart and scatter. Bones already raised inside concretions are safer in a laboratory than they would be if returned to the surf. The open question is what happens next: how long remains are studied, who decides on reburial, and what happens to bones that can never be identified. Those decisions will shape how the Whydah’s dead are remembered as much as any DNA result.

Can you visit the Whydah wreck site?

Not as a dive site. The wreck lies in the surf zone off Wellfleet under constantly moving sand, in poor visibility, and is an active, privately permitted excavation with exclusive dive rights. You can stand on the beaches of the Cape Cod National Seashore at Wellfleet and look out toward where she went down. The recovered remains and artifacts are shown at the Whydah Pirate Museum in West Yarmouth and at Real Pirates in Salem, where the 2018 leg bone was put on display before its DNA test. For the objects themselves, see our guides to Whydah artifacts and the treasure found on the Whydah, and for the captain, Samuel Bellamy.

Frequently asked questions

Where are the remains of the Whydah Gally?

Scattered under sand in roughly 14–30 ft of water off Wellfleet, on the outer shore of Cape Cod, Massachusetts, along about four miles of coast.

Have they found Black Sam Bellamy’s body?

No. A leg bone tested in 2018 was not his, and none of the six skeletons announced in 2021 has been publicly confirmed as Bellamy.

How many people died on the Whydah?

About 144–145 of the 146 aboard. Only Thomas Davis and John Julian survived from the Whydah itself.

Whose leg bone was found on the Whydah?

A fibula from a child aged about 8–11, found with a child’s shoe and silk stocking and believed to belong to John King, who joined Bellamy from the sloop Bonetta in 1716.

Who is analysing the Whydah skeletons?

A forensic team at the University of New Haven’s Henry C. Lee College, led by Tim Palmbach, using X-rays of concretions, skeletal analysis and DNA.

What did the 2018 DNA test show?

The bone came from a man with general ties to the Eastern Mediterranean, not from Bellamy, based on comparison with a living Bellamy descendant in England.

What happened to the Whydah survivors?

Six men were hanged in Boston on November 15, 1717; Thomas Davis and Thomas South were acquitted, and John Julian was sold into slavery.

Is the Whydah the only pirate shipwreck ever found?

It is the only Golden Age pirate wreck fully authenticated by an inscribed bell and a placard naming the ship.

Sources & further reading
  1. Smithsonian Magazine (2021). Scholars discover six skeletons in Whydah pirate ship wreck.
  2. Connecticut Public (2021). Conn. researchers investigating skeletal remains found at pirate shipwreck (interview with Tim Palmbach, University of New Haven).
  3. WBUR (May 25, 2018). Bone found at Cape Cod shipwreck is not Black Sam Bellamy’s; Courthouse News (2018). Was pirate Black Sam Bellamy found? DNA test could tell.
  4. History News Network / AP (2006). Remains of youngest recorded pirate recovered from Whydah; NPR (2006). The strange and brief life of a young pirate.
  5. Massachusetts Historical Society (2017). The End of Piracy: Pirates hanged in Boston 300 years ago.
  6. Provincetown Independent. The Whydah’s survivors and the 1717 trials.
  7. Skowronek, T.B., Clifford, B. & DeCorse, C.R. (2026). Pirate gold provides new insights into West African trade using pXRF and SEM-EDS analysis. npj Heritage Science.
  8. Wikipedia, Whydah Gally (ship specifications, Southack, survivors and trial).
BP
Last updated November 7, 2026
Written by
Blane Perun

Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.

About Blane Perun →
Coral Aquaculture · The Pioneer Story
Blane Perun, A coral aquaculture pioneer

Built one of the first home reef tanks designed as a multi-zone replica of natural reef conditions. Author of long-form profiles cited by Wikipedia, Quality Marine, and SeaScope. Independent — no advertisers, no sponsored placements, no editorial board outside the dive log.

Widely credited as the pioneer of named-coral culture in the reef-keeping hobby. The original — “Perun's Purple People Eater”, a Protopalythoa morph from his coral farm — became the first hobbyist coral to carry an aquaculturist's name in trade, sparking the now-standard practice of naming individual coral strains across the industry.

Founded1999 Articles3,072 Countries80+ Cited inWikipedia · Quality Marine · SeaScope
Read Blane's full bio →
The Dispatch · Monthly

Field notes from eighty countries worth of ocean.

One monthly email. New long-form reporting, species profiles, and dive reports — no filler, no tracking pixels, no sponsored placements. Ever.

Sign up and get my one-click underwater color-correction actions for Photoshop — the set I run on my own dive shots. Free.

Get the action now + monthly field notes
No spam · Unsubscribe anytime
Underwater reef photo before and after Blane Perun's Photoshop color-correction action — washed-out blue-green on the left, full natural color restored on the right
Same shot · one click