Exploring Earth's Oceans Since 1999 · Founded by Blane Perun
3,072 Articles·80+ Countries·25 Years of Ocean Science·Site Map
◆ Trending
25 years exploring Earth's oceans,
coral reefs, and the creatures within.
3,072Articles
80+Countries
1999Founded

Black Caesar

Black Caesar — The Escaped Slave Who Became a Caribbean Pirate

Pirates
12 min read
Who was Black Caesar?

Black Caesar was an enslaved African crewman of Blackbeard who, according to a 1726 account, was posted in the powder room of the sloop Adventure with orders to blow it up during Blackbeard’s last fight at Ocracoke on November 22, 1718; two prisoners talked him out of it. He was captured with the crew, but whether he was later hanged in Virginia is disputed. His celebrated career as a Florida Keys pirate chief is a later legend with no contemporary evidence.

Quick facts
Known as
Cesar / Caesar; “Black Caesar” in legend
Status
Enslaved crewman, listed as “Common Sailor”
Ship
Sloop Adventure, Blackbeard’s last command
Captured
Ocracoke, North Carolina, Nov 22, 1718
Famous act
Ordered to blow up the powder room; stopped by two prisoners
Trial
Blackbeard’s crew tried in Virginia, Mar 12, 1719
Fate
Disputed: hanged in Virginia, or alive in Bath in 1719
Legend
Florida Keys pirate chief; Caesar’s Creek, Biscayne NP

Black Caesar is two people at once. One is a man named Cesar who appears in the contemporary record of Blackbeard’s last fight in November 1718: an enslaved African crewman posted in the powder room of the sloop Adventure with a lit match and orders to blow the ship up. The other is a legend: a towering West African chief who escaped a wrecked slave ship, ruled the islands of Biscayne Bay for a decade, hid treasure on Elliott Key and kept prisoners in stone huts before sailing off to join Blackbeard. The first rests on a handful of lines in a 1726 book and on court and colonial papers. The second grew up in plays, novels and tourist lore over the following two centuries. This page separates the two, explains where each comes from, and looks at what historians are still arguing about.

What does the contemporary record say?

The only near-contemporary account of Caesar comes from A General History of the Pyrates by “Captain Charles Johnson,” and it describes one dramatic moment rather than a career.

Johnson’s account of Blackbeard’s death says that Edward Teach, seeing he had “little or no Hopes of escaping,” had “posted a resolute Fellow, a Negro, whom he had bred up, with a lighted Match, in the Powder-Room, with Commands to blow up when he should give him Orders.” The plan was to wait until the lieutenant and his men had boarded, “that so he might have destroy’d his Conquerors.” When the man in the powder room learned that Blackbeard was dead, Johnson writes, “he could hardly be perswaded from the rash Action, by two Prisoners that were in the Hold of the Sloop.” The Adventure did not explode.

Johnson’s list of the captured crew includes a “Common Sailor” named Cesar, one of at least five enslaved Black men taken at Ocracoke. North Carolina researcher Kevin Duffus puts the number of enslaved African Americans in Blackbeard’s crew at six. Johnson does not explicitly say that the man in the powder room was Cesar, and some writers note that the General History may describe him without naming him. The identification of the powder-room man with Cesar has nonetheless become the standard reading. Beyond that, the record is silent on where Caesar was born, how he came to be enslaved, or what he did before 1718. A Florida Keys historian, reviewing the passage in 2021, concluded that it “in no way supports any aspect of the Black Caesar legend as popularly told” and that the only act of piracy attributed to Cesar was being put in the wrong place at the wrong time.

Early-1700s pirate ship off the Florida Keys at sunset - Black Caesar
Black Caesar

Blackbeard’s last months, and why Caesar was on the Adventure

The setting matters, because the legend usually puts Caesar aboard the wrong ship. Blackbeard’s famous flagship, the Queen Anne’s Revenge, ran aground at Topsail Inlet, near present-day Beaufort, North Carolina, on or about June 10, 1718. According to the deposition of David Herriot, the sloop Adventure, under Blackbeard’s sailing master Israel Hands, went to help and also ran aground. Blackbeard then marooned Herriot and about 15 others on a nearby shoal, picked his most capable men and left in a small Spanish sloop. He went to Bath, North Carolina, to accept the King’s pardon and appears to have lived there for a time.

By November 1718 he was back at sea, and on the night of November 21 his sloop Adventure lay at anchor off Ocracoke Island. Virginia’s governor, Alexander Spotswood, had sent a naval force under Lieutenant Robert Maynard to find him. Maynard’s men attacked early the next morning, November 22. In the close fighting on deck Blackbeard was killed. So when Caesar stood in the powder room with a match, he was on the Adventure, not the Queen Anne’s Revenge, which had been wrecked five months earlier.

Who was Caesar, really?

The most detailed modern research comes from Kevin Duffus, author of The Last Days of Black Beard the Pirate, who devoted two new chapters to Caesar in a revised edition. Duffus argues that Caesar was enslaved by Tobias Knight, the secretary of the North Carolina colony, who was later accused of dealing with Blackbeard. Duffus describes Caesar as “Tobias Knight’s investment in Blackbeard’s enterprises,” says he can place Caesar in Bath in 1716, two years before Ocracoke, and links the men’s departure from Bath in July 1716 to news of the wreck of a Spanish treasure fleet off central Florida. These claims rest on Duffus’s archival work and have not all been published in peer-reviewed form, so they are best treated as a well-researched argument rather than settled fact.

If Duffus is right, Caesar’s story is less a tale of a free African warlord than of an enslaved man whose labour was put to work in piracy by colonial officials, and who was then caught up in its violent end. That reading fits what is known more broadly about Black men in Golden Age pirate crews. Some were runaways or freedmen who joined as crew; others were captives who were treated as property by the pirates themselves. Historians quoted in Florida coverage of the legend estimate that a quarter to almost a third of the pirates working the Florida Straits and the Gulf in the decade after 1715 were Black men who had escaped slavery or been freed by pirates, though such estimates are rough.

The trial in Virginia, and was Caesar hanged?

After Ocracoke, sixteen of Blackbeard’s men were brought to Virginia for trial. According to Queen Anne’s Revenge project historians, the trial took place on March 12, 1719, and all but two of the accused were condemned. Samuel Odel was released after showing that he was a trader from Bath who had come aboard only the night before and fought in self-defence. Israel Hands, Blackbeard’s former sailing master, was pardoned. Some crewmen gave evidence to Governor Spotswood, hoping to trade a death sentence for a life in slavery, but it did not save them. Tobias Knight, accused by the informants, was later acquitted. The condemned were marched from Williamsburg along the road toward the James River and hanged; the exact date is not known but was probably shortly after the trial.

The popular story says Caesar was among them. Most older accounts state that he was hanged at Williamsburg, often giving the year as 1718, which cannot be right if the trial took place in March 1719. Duffus disputes the hanging altogether. He told the Ocracoke Observer in 2014 that he had found proof Caesar was alive in Bath a year after Ocracoke, and that Caesar “survived well beyond the rest of the crew.” Other summaries note that sources simply differ, some saying Caesar was hanged and others that he was acquitted. The honest answer is that his fate is unresolved. What is clear is that the common claim that he was tried, convicted and hanged in 1718 does not match the documented trial date.

How the Florida Keys legend was born

The Florida version of Black Caesar has almost nothing to do with the man in the Adventure’s powder room. In it, Caesar is a West African war chief of huge size and strength who is lured aboard a slave ship with about twenty of his warriors on a promise of trade goods. A sympathetic sailor befriends him; when a hurricane wrecks the ship on the Florida Reef, the two seize a longboat and are the only survivors. For years they pose as castaways to lure passing ships close, then rob them at gunpoint. After the sailor dies in a duel over a woman, Caesar gathers a larger crew, raids shipping, keeps captives in stone huts, buries treasure (one version says 26 bars of silver) and finally sails north to join Blackbeard.

None of this can be found in contemporary sources. Writers who have traced the story suggest it drew on a 1798 stage play, Blackbeard, or The Captive Princess, and was later fixed in popular imagination by Albert Payson Terhune’s novel Black Caesar’s Clan, published in the early 1920s and set in the mangrove country near Miami. The Keys historian quoted above describes a second wave of the legend appearing roughly a century after 1718. To muddy things further, a separate figure, Henri Caesar, is linked in Haitian and Florida tradition to piracy in the early nineteenth century, and some versions of the Keys tale blend him with Blackbeard’s Caesar. Kevin M. McCarthy’s books on Florida pirates and African American sites in Florida are among the modern works most often cited for the Keys version.

Caesar’s Creek and Caesar’s Rock today

The legend survives in place names. Caesar’s Creek is the channel at the southern end of Elliott Key, an island in what is now Biscayne National Park, south of Miami. Caesar’s Rock, a plain, nondescript rock in the creek, is often named as the site of his headquarters, and the legend has his crew using the creek, nearby inlets and mangrove islands to hide from patrols. Elliott Key can be reached only by boat, and camping is allowed there. Many people have searched these islands for buried treasure, and none has been found. The upper Keys have yielded little evidence that any such lair existed.

Place names like these are worth treating with care. They show that a story was told and believed, not that the events happened. Across the Caribbean, coves, keys and channels were named after famous pirates long after the Golden Age, often by later settlers or mapmakers who knew the legends. Caesar’s Creek tells us that by the time the Biscayne islands were charted, the Black Caesar story was already part of local lore; it does not tell us that an eighteenth-century pirate ever anchored there.

Nov 22, 1718
Blackbeard killed at Ocracoke; Caesar captured
Mar 12, 1719
Trial of Blackbeard’s crew in Virginia
0
Contemporary records of a Keys pirate career

How reliable is Johnson’s General History?

Because almost everything documented about Caesar passes through one book, its reliability matters. A General History of the Robberies and Murders of the most notorious Pyrates first appeared in London in 1724 under the name “Captain Charles Johnson,” and was expanded in later editions, including the 1726 edition quoted here. Nobody knows for certain who Johnson was; the name is generally treated as a pseudonym, and several writers have been proposed as the author. The book mixes material drawn from trial reports, newspapers and official letters with embellishment and invented speeches, so historians check its claims against other records wherever they can.

For Blackbeard’s death the General History is comparatively well grounded, because the battle at Ocracoke was reported in official correspondence and the surviving crew were tried in Virginia. The powder-room episode fits the known course of the fight, and the presence of enslaved men among the prisoners is consistent with what researchers have found in colonial records. What the book does not do is give Caesar a biography. Every detail of his African origin, shipwreck and island kingdom was added later, by writers who had a name and a dramatic scene to build on.

Why the legend matters

It is easy to dismiss the Keys story as tourist folklore, but it reflects something real. Enslaved and formerly enslaved Africans were present throughout Caribbean piracy, and their stories were almost never written down in their own words. The legend of a proud chief who escapes slavery, outwits slave traders and takes revenge on shipping gave later audiences a Black hero in a world of white captains. The historical Caesar, as far as the record shows, had far less freedom: he was probably the property of a colonial official, was placed in a powder room with orders to die for his captain, and was talked out of it by two prisoners in the hold.

Both versions are worth knowing. The legend explains why a creek in a national park carries his name and why his story still features in pirate books, films and video games. The record explains how much we do not know about the ordinary men, free and enslaved, who sailed with famous captains like Blackbeard, Stede Bonnet and Benjamin Hornigold, and how quickly their lives were overwritten by better stories. For the wider history, see our guide to pirates.

Frequently asked questions

Was Black Caesar a real person?

A man named Cesar was among the crew captured with Blackbeard’s sloop Adventure at Ocracoke in November 1718, and a 1726 account describes a Black crewman ordered to blow up the ship. His Florida Keys career is legend with no contemporary evidence.

Was Black Caesar on the Queen Anne’s Revenge?

Not at Blackbeard’s death. The Queen Anne’s Revenge ran aground near Beaufort, North Carolina, in June 1718; Blackbeard died aboard the sloop Adventure off Ocracoke on November 22, 1718.

What did Caesar try to do at Ocracoke?

He was posted in the powder room with a lit match and orders to blow up the sloop once the attackers boarded. After Blackbeard was killed, two prisoners in the hold persuaded him not to.

Was Black Caesar hanged?

It is disputed. Most accounts say he was hanged in Virginia, but the crew’s trial took place on March 12, 1719, and researcher Kevin Duffus says he can show Caesar was alive in Bath after Ocracoke.

Was Black Caesar enslaved?

Yes, according to the contemporary record he was one of at least five enslaved Black men in the crew; Duffus argues he belonged to North Carolina official Tobias Knight.

Where is Caesar’s Creek?

At the south end of Elliott Key in Biscayne National Park, south of Miami. Caesar’s Rock is a rock in the creek linked to the legend.

Did Black Caesar bury treasure in Florida?

Legend says so, but no treasure has been found and there is no contemporary evidence that he ever operated in the Keys.

Sources & further reading
  1. Johnson, Captain Charles (1726 ed.). A General History of the Pyrates: account of Edward Teach and list of captured crew.
  2. Keys Weekly (2021). Keys pirates: Black Caesar, Blackbeard, and the creation of a legend.
  3. Ocracoke Observer (2014). Caesar, the earliest notable Black resident of North Carolina (interview with Kevin Duffus).
  4. Duffus, K. The Last Days of Black Beard the Pirate (revised edition).
  5. North Carolina Department of Natural and Cultural Resources, Queen Anne’s Revenge Project blog: “The day the ship’s fate was sealed” (2018) and “Did you know Blackbeard’s crew was tried in Virginia?” (2019).
  6. McCarthy, K.M. (1994). Twenty Florida Pirates. Pineapple Press; McCarthy, K.M. African American Sites in Florida.
  7. Florida Rambler. Legend of Black Caesar haunts the Florida Keys; HeritageDaily (2024). Black Caesar, the pirate.
BP
Last updated May 18, 2026
Written by
Blane Perun

Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.

About Blane Perun →More on Pirates →
Coral Aquaculture · The Pioneer Story
Blane Perun, A coral aquaculture pioneer

Built one of the first home reef tanks designed as a multi-zone replica of natural reef conditions. Author of long-form profiles cited by Wikipedia, Quality Marine, and SeaScope. Independent — no advertisers, no sponsored placements, no editorial board outside the dive log.

Widely credited as the pioneer of named-coral culture in the reef-keeping hobby. The original — “Perun's Purple People Eater”, a Protopalythoa morph from his coral farm — became the first hobbyist coral to carry an aquaculturist's name in trade, sparking the now-standard practice of naming individual coral strains across the industry.

Founded1999 Articles3,072 Countries80+ Cited inWikipedia · Quality Marine · SeaScope
Read Blane's full bio →
The Dispatch · Monthly

Field notes from eighty countries worth of ocean.

One monthly email. New long-form reporting, species profiles, and dive reports — no filler, no tracking pixels, no sponsored placements. Ever.

Sign up and get my one-click underwater color-correction actions for Photoshop — the set I run on my own dive shots. Free.

Get the action now + monthly field notes
No spam · Unsubscribe anytime
Underwater reef photo before and after Blane Perun's Photoshop color-correction action — washed-out blue-green on the left, full natural color restored on the right
Same shot · one click