Exploring Earth's Oceans Since 1999 · Founded by Blane Perun
3,072 Articles·80+ Countries·25 Years of Ocean Science·Site Map
◆ Trending
25 years exploring Earth's oceans,
coral reefs, and the creatures within.
3,072Articles
80+Countries
1999Founded

Treasure Found on the Santa Margarita: Gold, Pearls and Silver From 1622

Treasure of the Santa Margarita — The Atocha’s Sister Ship Still Giving Up Gold

Shipwreck Treasure
November 8, 2026
14 min read
What treasure was found on the Santa Margarita?

The Santa Margarita, a Spanish galleon wrecked in the Quicksands west of the Marquesas Keys in the September 1622 hurricane that also sank the Atocha, has yielded gold bars, gold chains and jewellery, rare silver coins, a gold chalice, a gold-and-crystal reliquary and a lead box of 16,184 pearls that were never on the manifest. Spanish salvors raised about 350 silver bars from 1626; Mel Fisher’s company found part of the wreck in 1980, and reported recoveries now exceed $16 million.

Quick facts — Santa Margarita
Ship
Spanish galleon, 600 tons, 25 guns (Wikipedia); built Cádiz 1620
Sank
September 1622, Quicksands off the Marquesas Keys
Deaths
142 (of ~550 lost across the fleet)
Registered cargo
166,574 silver coins, 550+ silver ingots, 9,000+ oz gold
Spanish salvage
Melián, 1626–c.1628: 350 silver bars, ~75,000 coins, 8 bronze guns
Rediscovered
1980, Treasure Salvors
Notable finds
16,184 pearls (2007), gold toothpick and gold chalice (2008), reliquary
Recovered value
$16 million+ (reported)

The Atocha gets the headlines, but its sister ship has arguably produced the more surprising treasures, including a lead box of smuggled pearls that no Spanish clerk ever recorded. The Santa Margarita is also the rare galleon whose story has been worked three times over: by the Spanish in the 1620s, by Mel Fisher’s Treasure Salvors from 1980, and by the Blue Water Ventures team that followed her scattered wreckage north across the sand in the 2000s.

What kind of ship was the Santa Margarita?

A Spanish galleon sailing with the 1622 Tierra Firme fleet, the convoy that carried South American silver and gold home to Spain.

Wikipedia describes her as a galleon of 600 tons armed with 25 cannon. The Spanish shipwreck database shipwrecks.es says she was built in Cádiz in 1620 and calls her smaller than the Atocha, which it rates at 550 tons; it gives no figure of its own for the Margarita. Tonnage in this period was measured in several competing ways, so the two accounts may simply be using different rules, but readers should know that the sources do not agree on which ship was the larger.

She was a fighting merchantman rather than a pure cargo carrier. According to the Mel Fisher Maritime Museum’s research files, Captain Bernardino de Lugo y Navarra commanded the 73 soldiers posted aboard to guard her, while the ship herself was handled by her master, Pedro Gutiérrez de Espinosa. De Lugo, born in Carmona in 1583 and made a knight of the Order of Santiago in 1617, had already served as admiral of the Tierra Firme fleet in 1620, so the Margarita carried an unusually experienced officer.

santa margarita treasure: Treasure Found on the Santa Margarita: Gold, Pearls and Silver From 1622
santa margarita treasure

Why was the 1622 fleet carrying so much treasure?

The Tierra Firme fleet was Spain’s annual pipeline for the bullion of Peru and New Granada, gathered at Cartagena and Portobelo and sent home through Havana.

Ships of the fleet loaded gold, silver and emeralds at Cartagena de Indias before regrouping at Havana for the Atlantic crossing. The 1622 convoy numbered 28 vessels under the Marquis of Cadereita. NOAA Ocean Exploration lists its cargo as gold and silver bullion and coins, along with indigo, tobacco, cochineal, rosewood and copper ingots. Silver dominated by volume; most of it came from the mines of Potosí in what is now Bolivia, minted into cobs or cast into heavy bars stamped with assay marks.

The crown had good reason to watch this fleet closely. Spain had renewed its war with the Dutch Republic in 1621, the Thirty Years’ War was spreading across Europe, and every delay to the silver shipments strained royal credit. That pressure helps explain why the fleet sailed late in the hurricane season, and why the crown spent years afterwards trying to recover what was lost.

How did the Santa Margarita sink?

She was wrecked in the hurricane that struck the fleet within days of leaving Havana in September 1622, with 142 of her people killed.

The storm caught the convoy in the Florida Straits. NOAA says eight ships were lost, some grounding on the shoals between the Marquesas Keys and the Dry Tortugas and others sinking in deeper water; Wikipedia counts the Margarita among six ships wrecked near the Marquesas, about 40 miles (64 km) west of Key West, with some 550 people lost across the fleet. Her own death toll was 142.

The museum’s biography of de Lugo, drawing on Spanish records, describes the end. The galleon was anchored with her sails furled when the sea turned her sideways, and she broke apart. De Lugo was left swimming and floating on a plank until about five in the afternoon, and a 1626 sketch of his life says he held up a ship’s boy the whole time and saved him from drowning. When the weather eased, a small boat from a ship bound for Jamaica picked him up.

Before he left, de Lugo did something that shaped the next four centuries of the story. The Marquis of Cadereita, writing to King Philip IV on 10 January 1623, reported that de Lugo had buoyed the site of the two lost galleons with a cannon, a spar and other poles flying a pennant. That marker gave the first Spanish salvors a place to start, and it explains why the Margarita, unlike the Atocha, was found again within a few years.

What did the Santa Margarita carry?

Her registered cargo was 166,574 silver pieces of eight, more than 550 silver ingots weighing about 10,000 lb, and over 9,000 oz of gold in bars, discs and small pieces.

The manifest also listed copper, silverware, indigo and the personal belongings of passengers, from medical and navigational instruments to gold coins and jewellery. What the manifest did not show was contraband. Goods shipped off the books escaped the king’s fifth, the 20 percent royal tax on precious metals, and smuggling was so routine on the treasure fleets that modern salvors expect to find unregistered gold and gems on every galleon they work.

The Margarita proved that expectation right. Her most famous single find, a box of more than sixteen thousand pearls, appears on no list at all. Historians believe the pearls came from the fisheries around Margarita Island off Venezuela, which shares the ship’s name only by coincidence. Those beds had been worked since the early 1500s, largely by enslaved Indigenous and African divers, and pearls were among the easiest valuables to hide in a cabin.

How much did the Spanish recover in the 1620s?

A great deal. A Havana official, Francisco Núñez Melián, found the wreck in 1626 and raised hundreds of silver bars, tens of thousands of coins and her bronze guns.

The first attempts came almost at once. Wikipedia says Gaspar de Vargas began salvage soon after the wreck using pearl divers from Margarita Island, the same free-diving skill set that the pearl beds had trained. Those efforts recovered little. In 1624 Philip IV licensed Melián to search for both the Margarita and the Atocha. A crew he sent out in 1625 disappeared at sea, so in 1626 he led the expedition himself, setting up camp on the Marquesas Keys.

His divers were enslaved men sent from New Spain. Melián promised freedom to the first of them to bring up a silver bar, and in 1626 a 40-year-old diver recorded as Juan Casta Bañon did so. The museum’s archive notes that Melián asked the royal treasury to honour the promise as he prepared to leave for Venezuela, and that Bañon’s freedom was approved in Madrid on 1 October 1630. Wikipedia’s article on Melián gives the date of the find as 3 June 1626 and records the diver as Casta Bañon. Nothing is known of what became of him.

The Mel Fisher museum lists that first summer’s haul as 350 silver bars, nearly 75,000 coins, eight bronze cannon and 109 copper ingots, with recovery continuing until about 1628. Live Science, reporting Melián’s own account, also gives 350 ingots and eight cannons but describes the coins as thousands of gold coins. Set against the manifest, the museum figures suggest Melián raised well over half of the registered ingots and roughly 45 percent of the registered coins, which fits the old estimate that about half the cargo was recovered in the seventeenth century.

The work was dangerous for reasons beyond the weather. Dutch raiders tried to seize silver from the camp and were driven off; this was the era in which a Dutch fleet under Piet Heyn would capture an entire Spanish treasure fleet off Cuba in 1628. Melián’s reward for his service was the governorship of Venezuela from 1630 to 1637. He later governed Yucatán and died in April 1644 after being thrown from his horse during a military parade.

Was a 400-year-old diving bell found at the wreck?

Possibly. A copper dome found near the site in 1980 has been proposed as the top of an early diving bell, though the idea has not been tested in a peer-reviewed study.

Melián wrote in 1625 that he had cast a bell to work the wrecks, and the museum describes his team using drag lines, grapnels, prybars and a brass diving bell. A diving bell traps air under an open-bottomed chamber so that a diver can breathe without surfacing; the earliest recorded use was in an Italian lake in 1535, and Spanish inventor Jerónimo de Ayanz tested a design in 1606 that was later used for pearling in Venezuela.

In 2023 maritime archaeologist Sean Kingsley, writing in Wreckwatch, and Jim Sinclair, who helped recover the object, argued that a 147 cm (58 in) copper dome made from two riveted sheets might be part of such a bell. It shows no sign of heating, which argues against the cooking-cauldron label it carried for years, and it lay near iron ingots that could have weighted it down. Live Science reported that the dome was found at about 50 m (160 ft), a figure hard to square with the much shallower depths reported for the galleon itself, and no surviving record states that a bell was used on the Margarita specifically. It is a tantalising lead rather than a settled fact.

How was the Santa Margarita rediscovered?

Through archival research. Historian Eugene Lyon traced the 1622 wrecks in Spanish records for Mel Fisher, and Treasure Salvors found part of the Margarita in 1980.

The salvage documents in the General Archive of the Indies in Seville referred to the wreck sites as lying off the Matacumbe Keys. Lyon’s work on Melián’s papers pointed the modern search to the Marquesas instead, and the name itself is a clue: NOAA notes that the Marquesas Keys are named after the Marquis of Cadereita, the fleet commander who led the first salvage. Lyon told the story of the 1980 discovery in a National Geographic article, “Treasure from the Ghost Galleon,” published in February 1982.

The find came five years before Treasure Salvors located the main pile of the Atocha in 1985, and for a while the Margarita was the more productive site. It was also a hard one to read. Repeated storms after 1622 had broken the hull apart and spread it across the seabed, where it was buried in sand and mud. In 1986 Fisher’s divers recovered a wrought-iron swivel gun 40.5 in (102.9 cm) long, weighing just over 114 lb (51.9 kg), from the ground between the two wrecks; the museum suggests it came from the boat of the Santa Cruz, the one fleet ship known to have sailed for Jamaica, which may tie it to de Lugo’s rescue.

Where does the Santa Margarita lie?

In the Quicksands, the shifting shoals that run west from the Marquesas Keys toward the Dry Tortugas, roughly 35 to 40 miles from Key West.

NOAA describes the Quicksands as a nickname for shoals in an area about 50 km (31 mi) long and 15 km (9 mi) wide, littered with wrecks from Spanish galleons to twentieth-century steamships. Shifting sand covered many of them soon after they sank, which is exactly what defeated later Spanish searchers and what still makes the site hard to work. The area now falls within the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary, where NOAA has run archaeological surveys.

Distances and depths vary from source to source. Mel Fisher’s company put the 2008 chalice find 35 miles off Key West, while NBC News reports of the 2007 and 2008 finds gave about 40 miles. Those same reports described the pearl box as buried beneath about 18 ft (5.5 m) of water and the gold toothpick at about 22 ft. The best reading is that the debris trail is shallow, but that depth changes along its length.

What has been found on the Santa Margarita since 2007?

Some of the most striking single objects from any 1622 wreck, including the pearl box, a gold chalice and a solid gold grooming tool.

Blue Water Ventures of Key West, working in partnership with the Fisher family’s company, took over the Margarita search in the 2000s. Its team included Lyon, archaeologist and conservator James Sinclair and operations manager Dan Porter, and it used digitised historic charts and a detailed record of every find to plot the scatter pattern of the wreck. Their search vessel, the Blue Water Rose, worked further north than earlier crews had.

In June 2007 the divers uncovered a sealed lead box measuring about 3.5 by 5.5 in (9 by 14 cm), along with a gold bar, eight gold chains and hundreds of other artifacts. Blue Water’s archaeologist Duncan Mathewson said at the time that nobody knew how many pearls it held and that they could be worth upwards of a million dollars. Sinclair noted that pearls do not normally survive well in the sea once they lose the oyster’s protection, since they are made of calcium carbonate. When the contents were counted after conservation, the box held 16,184 pearls. A later news report valued that season’s gold and pearls together at more than $2 million.

About a year later, in 2008, diver Chris Rackley found a solid gold tool that combines a toothpick with an earwax spoon. It weighs about an ounce and was valued at possibly more than $100,000. Mathewson called it the farthest point along the trail where gold had yet been found. On 24 June 2008 diver Michael DeMar found an ornate gold chalice with a threaded foot, an inscribed rim and a crest in the base that may identify an aristocratic owner; preliminary estimates put it at a million dollars or more. Captain Porter described it as the northernmost treasure yet recovered from the wreck.

Other finds listed for the Margarita include gold bars, gold chains and jewellery, rare silver coins and a reliquary of gold and rock crystal, a small case made to hold a holy relic. In all, reported recoveries have passed $16 million. Many of the objects are on display at the Mel Fisher Maritime Heritage Museum in Key West, and the pearls were conserved in the laboratory above it.

How do divers recover treasure from the Santa Margarita?

By moving sand. Salvage boats use “mailboxes,” elbow-shaped tubes that steer propeller wash down to the bottom and blow out shallow craters.

Mel Fisher’s team popularised the technique in the Keys. Divers then sweep the exposed seabed with handheld metal detectors and record each find’s position, so the spread of the wreck can be mapped. The chalice, for example, came from the berm, the pile of displaced sand at the edge of an excavation. Gold comes out looking almost new after four centuries, while silver coins turn black with sulphide and often fuse into heavy clumps that need months of conservation. Iron objects arrive inside thick concretions of sand and shell that must be X-rayed and chipped away.

All of this is permitted work. Historic wrecks in Florida waters are protected, and digging on the 1622 sites inside the marine sanctuary happens only under official permits. Recreational divers cannot excavate or remove anything from them.

Is there still treasure on the Santa Margarita?

Almost certainly. Neither the Spanish nor modern salvors are thought to have recovered everything listed on the manifest, and contraband adds an unknown amount on top.

The 2007 and 2008 finds came from a section of the trail that earlier crews had not searched, and storms keep moving the sand that covers the rest. Each new find also adds data to the scatter map, which helps the team predict where heavier objects such as bars and chests may have come to rest. For the wider 1622 story, see the Atocha and the Tortugas wreck; for a later Spanish disaster worked in the same way, see the 1715 Fleet.

Frequently asked questions

When did the Santa Margarita sink?

In September 1622, in the same hurricane that sank the Atocha, a few days after the fleet left Havana.

How many people died on the Santa Margarita?

142 people from the Margarita were lost, out of about 550 across the fleet.

When was the Santa Margarita found?

The Spanish found it in 1626. Mel Fisher’s Treasure Salvors found part of the wreck again in 1980.

What has been found on the Santa Margarita?

Gold bars and chains, rare silver coins, a gold chalice, a gold toothpick, a reliquary and 16,184 pearls.

How much has been recovered?

Reported modern recoveries exceed $16 million.

Did the Spanish salvage it?

Yes. Francisco Núñez Melián’s divers raised about 350 silver bars, nearly 75,000 coins and eight bronze cannon from 1626.

Where are the Santa Margarita artifacts displayed?

Many are at the Mel Fisher Maritime Heritage Museum in Key West.

Sources & further reading
  1. Wikipedia. Santa Margarita (shipwreck): ship, cargo, salvage, finds; citing Lyon, “Treasure from the Ghost Galleon,” National Geographic, Feb 1982.
  2. Wikipedia. Francisco Núñez Melián (1624 licence, 3 June 1626 find, later governorships).
  3. Mel Fisher Maritime Museum archive. Captain Bernardino de Lugo; Lugo’s marker buoy; Francisco Nuñez Melián, salvager of the Santa Margarita; freedom for enslaved diver Juan Bañon.
  4. shipwrecks.es. Santa Margarita (1622): Cádiz build, route, tonnage comparison.
  5. NOAA Ocean Exploration (2021). Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary Quicksands Archaeological Survey: 1622 fleet and the Quicksands.
  6. Live Science (7 Sept 2023). 17th-century “cauldron” may be an early diving bell.
  7. NBC News / AP (2007, 2008). Pearl box and gold chains; gold toothpick. Mel Fisher’s Treasures, gold chalice report (24 June 2008).
BP
Last updated November 8, 2026
Written by
Blane Perun

Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.

About Blane Perun → More on Shipwreck Treasure →
Coral Aquaculture · The Pioneer Story
Blane Perun, A coral aquaculture pioneer

Built one of the first home reef tanks designed as a multi-zone replica of natural reef conditions. Author of long-form profiles cited by Wikipedia, Quality Marine, and SeaScope. Independent — no advertisers, no sponsored placements, no editorial board outside the dive log.

Widely credited as the pioneer of named-coral culture in the reef-keeping hobby. The original — “Perun's Purple People Eater”, a Protopalythoa morph from his coral farm — became the first hobbyist coral to carry an aquaculturist's name in trade, sparking the now-standard practice of naming individual coral strains across the industry.

Founded1999 Articles3,072 Countries80+ Cited inWikipedia · Quality Marine · SeaScope
Read Blane's full bio →
The Dispatch · Monthly

Field notes from eighty countries worth of ocean.

One monthly email. New long-form reporting, species profiles, and dive reports — no filler, no tracking pixels, no sponsored placements. Ever.

Sign up and get my one-click underwater color-correction actions for Photoshop — the set I run on my own dive shots. Free.

Get the action now + monthly field notes
No spam · Unsubscribe anytime
Underwater reef photo before and after Blane Perun's Photoshop color-correction action — washed-out blue-green on the left, full natural color restored on the right
Same shot · one click