Exploring Earth's Oceans Since 1999 · Founded by Blane Perun
3,072 Articles·80+ Countries·25 Years of Ocean Science·Site Map
◆ Trending
25 years exploring Earth's oceans,
coral reefs, and the creatures within.
3,072Articles
80+Countries
1999Founded

Treasure Found on the Nuestra Señora de las Mercedes: The Black Swan Case

Treasure of the Mercedes — 594,000 Coins, One Court Case, Back to Spain

Shipwreck Treasure
November 7, 2026
12 min read
What treasure was found on the Mercedes?

In 2007, Odyssey Marine Exploration recovered about 594,000 coins, mostly silver, some 17 tons announced and valued at around $500 million at the time, from a site it code-named “Black Swan.” Spain showed the wreck was the frigate Nuestra Señora de las Mercedes, blown up by the British off Portugal on October 5, 1804. US courts ruled the coins belonged to Spain, and in February 2012 two Spanish Air Force Hercules flew them home to be kept intact in Cartagena’s underwater archaeology museum.

Quick facts — Mercedes
Ship
Spanish frigate
Sank
October 5, 1804, Battle of Cape Santa Maria
Deaths
~200–250; 40–51 survived (sources vary)
Route
Montevideo to Cádiz
Recovered
2007, Odyssey Marine (“Black Swan”)
Coins
~594,000; ~17 t announced (14.5 t deposited 2012)
Estimated value
~$500–600 million (estimates)
Outcome
Returned to Spain Feb 2012; ARQUA, Cartagena
Peru’s claim
Rejected

In May 2007 a Florida company flew one of the largest hoards of coins ever taken from the sea out of Gibraltar under a code name. Five years later every coin flew back to Spain on military aircraft. The treasure of the Nuestra Señora de las Mercedes is the story of a frigate destroyed in a surprise attack, a deep-sea recovery, a five-year lawsuit and a ruling that changed how treasure hunters treat sunken warships.

What was the Nuestra Señora de las Mercedes?

A Spanish Navy frigate of 36 guns, launched at Havana, Cuba, in 1786 and named for Our Lady of Mercy, a title of the Virgin Mary. In 1804 she was one of four frigates carrying silver, gold and colonial goods from the Río de la Plata to Cádiz.

The Mercedes was a working warship of the Spanish Navy, not a merchant galleon. Spanish sources give her armament as 26 twelve-pounders and 8 six-pounders and her crew as about 300. Her last voyage began in the Pacific port of Callao, Peru; the squadron left Montevideo on 9 August 1804 for Cádiz under the command of Brigadier José de Bustamante y Guerra, flying his flag in the 40-gun Medea. The other ships were the Fama, the Santa Clara and the Mercedes, commanded by Captain José Manuel de Goicoa. Their holds carried coin and bullion from the mints and mines of Spanish South America along with vicuña wool, cinchona bark and cinnamon.

The value of the shipment is given differently in different sources. One account of the battle puts the four frigates’ coin at about 4.29 million Spanish dollars plus gold ingots and other cargo, of which some 1.2 million in silver went down with the Mercedes. Documents cited in the later court case put the Mercedes’ own cargo at about 900,000 silver pesos, 5,809 gold pesos and nearly 2,000 copper and tin ingots. The differences reflect what was counted, private cargo or royal, coin or bullion, but every version makes the Mercedes a very rich ship.

nuestra senora de las mercedes: Treasure Found on the Nuestra Señora de las Mercedes: The Black Swan Case
nuestra senora de las mercedes

How did the Mercedes sink?

In a short, one-sided action off Cape Santa Maria on the Algarve coast of Portugal on 5 October 1804, when a British shot hit her powder magazine and she blew up. Britain and Spain were not at war.

A Royal Navy squadron under Commodore Graham Moore, with the frigates Indefatigable, Medusa, Amphion and Lively, intercepted the Spanish ships as they approached Cádiz and ordered them to change course for a British port. The British government had reason to expect war: Spain had secretly agreed to pay France a large annual subsidy, 72 million francs a year according to one account, and London wanted to stop the treasure from reaching Spanish hands. Bustamante protested that the two countries were at peace, refused, and cleared for action although he was outgunned.

About ten minutes into the exchange of fire, a shot from HMS Amphion reached the Mercedes’ magazine and she exploded. Casualty figures vary with the source: one account gives 250 Spaniards lost and 51 survivors taken from the water, a Spanish account 249 dead and 51 survivors, and an account of the battle says all but 40 of her 240 crew were killed. Either way, roughly five out of six people aboard died in moments. The other three frigates surrendered and were taken to Britain.

One family’s loss became the best-known part of the story. Diego de Alvear y Ponce de León, a senior Spanish officer, was sailing home with his wife, María Balbastro, and their children. He and his 16-year-old son Carlos María survived; accounts differ on whether they were aboard the Mercedes or watching from the Medea. His wife and the other children aboard the Mercedes died. Diego was taken to England as a prisoner, held with honours, and in 1807 remarried and started a second family.

The attack had large consequences. The captured frigates and their cargo were valued at about £900,000, but the Admiralty Court ruled them “Droits of the Admiralty” rather than prize, so the crews received only an ex gratia payment. Spain declared war on Britain on 14 December 1804, and ten months later its fleet fought alongside the French at Trafalgar. The wreck of the Mercedes has been compared to the USS Arizona at Pearl Harbor, an unprovoked attack with heavy loss of life that led to war.

How did Odyssey find the treasure?

Odyssey Marine Exploration of Tampa, Florida, located a deep wreck in the Gulf of Cádiz, recovered coins from it, and in May 2007 flew about 17 tons of them from Gibraltar to the United States under the project name “Black Swan.”

Odyssey did not publicly identify the wreck or its location. It filed in federal court in Tampa on 4 April 2007 to “arrest” the unidentified site, the usual first step in an admiralty salvage claim, and on 18 May 2007 the coins, mostly silver, were flown out of Gibraltar to an undisclosed location in Florida. Early speculation linked Black Swan to the English merchant ship Merchant Royal, lost in 1641; that identification was later ruled out.

The haul was enormous. Odyssey’s figure, widely reported, was about 594,000 coins, with the company citing 595,000 in court, along with cannons and other artefacts; most were silver, and many were minted in Lima. Valuations in the press ranged from about $500 million in 2007 to the $600 million cited by a federal judge in 2013. Those figures were estimates of what the coins might fetch if sold, which, in the end, they never were.

The wreck lies deep. Spain’s later archaeological work took place at more than 1,100 m, and in 2017 Spanish scientists recovered two bronze guns from a depth of 1,137 m, a record for underwater archaeology at the time. Odyssey’s recovery was therefore a feat of deep-sea robotics, but it was not carried out under archaeological standards, and Spain later stated that its 2015 survey showed the site had been damaged during the coin extraction.

Why did the court give the treasure to Spain?

Because the Mercedes was a Spanish Navy warship on government service when she sank, so the wreck and its cargo were protected by sovereign immunity and remained Spanish property. US courts therefore had no jurisdiction to award them to a salvor.

Spain filed its claim on 31 May 2007, arguing that Black Swan was the Mercedes. Odyssey argued that the ship had been on a commercial voyage carrying private cargo for a fee, which in its view removed any immunity. Among Spain’s evidence were coins and objects showing damage consistent with an internal explosion, matching the documented fate of the Mercedes. A magistrate judge in Tampa ruled for Spain on 4 June 2009; on 22 December 2009 the district court adopted those findings, staying the handover pending appeal.

In September 2011 a three-judge panel of the US Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit upheld the ruling in a 54-page opinion by Judge Susan Harrell Black. The court found that the Mercedes was a Spanish Navy vessel under a Navy captain when she sank; that carrying private cargo for a charge was still a sovereign military function, especially in wartime conditions; and that the cargo could not be separated from the ship. The US courts therefore had no jurisdiction over the property, and Odyssey was ordered to release it to Spain.

Peru also claimed the coins, on the grounds that the silver had been mined, refined and minted in its territory, and 25 individuals with claimed interests in the cargo, including descendants of people who had shipped goods aboard, joined the appeal. The courts rejected those claims as well: in 1804 Peru was part of the Spanish Empire, not a separate state, and the immunity covered the whole wreck. The Eleventh Circuit refused a stay on 31 January 2012, Justice Clarence Thomas declined an emergency stay on 9 February, and on 14 May 2012 the US Supreme Court declined to hear the case.

How did the coins get back to Spain?

On two Spanish Air Force C-130 Hercules transport planes, loaded at MacDill Air Force Base in Tampa in February 2012 after a magistrate judge ordered the handover by 24 February.

On 17 February 2012 Magistrate Judge Mark Pizzo ordered the coins returned by 24 February and denied Odyssey’s claim for $412,814 in storage and preservation costs. The coins were moved from Odyssey’s secure storage in Sarasota to MacDill and loaded aboard the two Hercules. The shipment weighed about 49,000 pounds, or 24.5 US tons, according to contemporary reports, a figure that presumably included packing; Odyssey had earlier announced about 17 tons of coins, and the cargo later deposited in Cartagena was recorded as 14.5 tonnes. The aircraft flew to Torrejón de Ardoz near Madrid.

Not everything came back at once. A small number of coins and objects that Odyssey had left in Gibraltar, including pieces showing signs of the explosion that helped prove the wreck’s identity, were returned only in 2013 after a further court order. On 25 September 2013 US District Judge Steven Merryday ordered Odyssey to pay Spain $1,072,979 in fees and costs for what he called bad faith and abusive litigation, finding that the company had pursued its claim despite knowing early on that the wreck was most likely a Spanish Navy frigate. Spain had sought $3.3 million. Odyssey’s chief executive called the award disappointing.

Where is the Mercedes treasure now?

In Spain, in public collections. On 2 December 2012 the cargo was deposited at the National Museum of Underwater Archaeology (ARQUA) in Cartagena for cataloguing, study and permanent display, and Spanish law requires it to be preserved intact rather than sold or melted.

The coins first went on public show in 2014, when Spain’s Naval Museum and National Archaeological Museum in Madrid staged the exhibition “The last voyage of the frigate Mercedes: a recovered cultural treasure,” from June to December. Since then parts of the collection have been displayed in Spanish museums, with ARQUA as the main repository. The decision to keep the hoard intact is the clearest difference between this case and most commercial treasure recoveries, where coins are graded, conserved and sold to collectors.

What did Spain’s own expeditions find?

Three scientific campaigns, in 2015, 2016 and 2017, mapped the wreck and recovered artefacts from more than 1,100 m down, culminating in the raising of two bronze cannons from 1,137 m.

The work was organised by Spain’s culture ministry with ARQUA, the Spanish Institute of Oceanography and the Spanish Navy, and in 2017 used the research vessel Sarmiento de Gamboa of the national research council (CSIC) and the institute’s remotely operated vehicle Liropus. Observers from the culture ministries of Portugal and Mexico attended, and the project followed the 2001 UNESCO Convention on the Protection of the Underwater Cultural Heritage. The government stated that the 2015 expedition showed the site had been damaged during Odyssey’s extraction of coins.

The 2017 finds were striking. The ROV lifted two long bronze guns, or culverins, named Santa Bárbara and Santa Rufina. Santa Bárbara is dated 1586, is 4.3 m long and weighs around 2,800 kg; Santa Rufina is dated 1601, 3.8 m long and weighs around two tonnes. Both were cast by Bernardino de Tejeda for viceroys of Peru more than two centuries before the Mercedes sailed, which suggests they were travelling as cargo, perhaps as metal being returned to Spain, rather than as the frigate’s own armament; the government noted they may appear in the ship’s manifest in the General Archive of the Indies in Seville. The same campaign recovered a bronze griffin, a perforated copper ventilation sheet and three bronze pulleys with traces of wood. The finds were to be conserved and added to the ARQUA displays.

Why does the Mercedes case matter?

It confirmed in a US appeals court that a sunken state warship, and everything aboard it, remains the property of the state that lost it, however long ago and however far from home.

Before the Mercedes, salvage companies often argued that cargo carried for private owners could be separated from a warship, or that a vessel on a trading voyage was not acting as a warship at all. The Eleventh Circuit rejected both arguments for a ship under naval command. The ruling, the sanctions that followed and Spain’s refusal to sell the coins made deep commercial recovery of naval wrecks far riskier, and they gave weight to the archaeological approach in the UNESCO convention. The same arguments now hang over the Spanish galleon San José off Colombia, where ownership has also been fought over.

It also changed how the treasure is understood. To Odyssey the Black Swan coins were an asset worth hundreds of millions of dollars. To Spain the Mercedes is a war grave holding some 250 sailors and passengers, and the coins are part of a historical record that includes the Alvear family, the road to Trafalgar and the trade of the late Spanish Empire. Keeping the hoard together in a museum, rather than scattering it among collectors, was the point of the lawsuit.

Frequently asked questions

How much was the Mercedes treasure worth?

Estimates ranged from about $500 million at discovery in 2007 to $600 million cited by a US judge in 2013. It was never sold.

How many coins were found on the Mercedes?

About 594,000, mostly silver; Odyssey announced roughly 17 tons, and 14.5 tonnes were deposited in Cartagena in 2012.

Who found the Mercedes treasure?

Odyssey Marine Exploration of Tampa, Florida, in 2007, under the code name “Black Swan.”

Why did Spain get the treasure?

US courts ruled the Mercedes was a Spanish Navy ship on state service, protected by sovereign immunity.

When and where did the Mercedes sink?

On 5 October 1804 off Cape Santa Maria, southern Portugal, when a British shot exploded her magazine.

How deep is the Mercedes wreck?

More than 1,100 m; Spanish scientists recovered two bronze cannons from 1,137 m in 2017.

Where are the coins now?

At Spain’s National Museum of Underwater Archaeology (ARQUA) in Cartagena, with parts displayed elsewhere in Spain.

Did Peru get any of the treasure?

No. The courts held that Peru was part of the Spanish Empire in 1804 and had no separate claim.

Sources & further reading
  1. Wikipedia: Nuestra Señora de las Mercedes; Action of 5 October 1804; Diego de Alvear y Ponce de León.
  2. Hispanopedia: Nuestra Señora de las Mercedes (1786), armament, voyage, casualties and expeditions.
  3. Coin World (2011). Court upholds ruling granting coins to Spain (Eleventh Circuit opinion by Judge Susan Harrell Black).
  4. The History Blog (24 Feb 2012). $500 million “Black Swan” treasure flies to Spain.
  5. ABA Journal (30 Sep 2013). Salvage company that lost $600M sunken ship case must pay $1M to Spain for “abusive litigation.”
  6. La Moncloa, Government of Spain (30 Aug 2017). An unprecedented success for global underwater archaeology (Las Mercedes cannons at 1,137 m).
  7. Black Swan Project chronology (court dates, Supreme Court decisions).
  8. RNZ / AFP (2012). Treasure from galleon returns to Spain.
BP
Last updated November 7, 2026
Written by
Blane Perun

Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.

About Blane Perun → More on Shipwreck Treasure →
Coral Aquaculture · The Pioneer Story
Blane Perun, A coral aquaculture pioneer

Built one of the first home reef tanks designed as a multi-zone replica of natural reef conditions. Author of long-form profiles cited by Wikipedia, Quality Marine, and SeaScope. Independent — no advertisers, no sponsored placements, no editorial board outside the dive log.

Widely credited as the pioneer of named-coral culture in the reef-keeping hobby. The original — “Perun's Purple People Eater”, a Protopalythoa morph from his coral farm — became the first hobbyist coral to carry an aquaculturist's name in trade, sparking the now-standard practice of naming individual coral strains across the industry.

Founded1999 Articles3,072 Countries80+ Cited inWikipedia · Quality Marine · SeaScope
Read Blane's full bio →
The Dispatch · Monthly

Field notes from eighty countries worth of ocean.

One monthly email. New long-form reporting, species profiles, and dive reports — no filler, no tracking pixels, no sponsored placements. Ever.

Sign up and get my one-click underwater color-correction actions for Photoshop — the set I run on my own dive shots. Free.

Get the action now + monthly field notes
No spam · Unsubscribe anytime
Underwater reef photo before and after Blane Perun's Photoshop color-correction action — washed-out blue-green on the left, full natural color restored on the right
Same shot · one click