Treasure of the SS City of Cairo — Silver Rupees From 5,150 Metres Down
Silver rupee coins. The British passenger-cargo liner SS City of Cairo was torpedoed by U-68 about 770 km south of St Helena on November 6, 1942, carrying about 100 tons (some accounts say 122) of silver coins in 2,182 boxes for the British Treasury. In 2013, Deep Ocean Search recovered a large share of the coins, reported as worth about $50 million, from about 5,150 m, the deepest cargo salvage on record.
Most of the people who died because of the SS City of Cairo did not die when the torpedoes hit. They died in open lifeboats over the following weeks in the South Atlantic. Seventy-one years later, the silver she carried was lifted from about 5,150 m, deeper than any cargo had ever been salvaged.
What was the SS City of Cairo?
The City of Cairo was a British passenger-cargo steamship of the Ellerman Lines of London, registered in Liverpool. She was launched on 21 October 1914 at Earle’s Shipbuilding and Engineering in Hull and completed in January 1915. At 8,034 gross register tons and about 137 m (450 ft) long, with two decks and two masts, she was a typical intermediate liner of the period: big enough to carry several hundred people and thousands of tons of cargo between Britain and India, but driven by a single quadruple-expansion steam engine that gave her a service speed of only about 12 knots. Her listed capacity was 7,422 tons of general cargo and 311 passengers and crew.
For most of her career she worked the long route east of Suez. In the Second World War she was requisitioned to carry supplies to the United Kingdom, and in late 1942 she was sailing alone on that duty. Her master was Captain William A. Rogerson.

Why was she carrying so much silver?
In the hold, alongside pig iron, timber, wool, cotton and manganese ore, were 2,182 wooden boxes of silver coins. Contemporary and modern accounts describe them as rupees that had been called in by the British Treasury to help pay for the war, and the coins recovered decades later carry the effigies of Queen Victoria, Edward VII and George V. The total weight is given differently in different sources. Guinness World Records and press reports of the salvage give about 100 tonnes; the salvor’s own account published by the marine insurer Gard and a survivors’ memorial website give 122 tons; and the standard reference account of the ship lists “2,000 boxes of silver coins” without a weight. The shipment was secret, and it was this consignment, rather than any personal valuables, that made the wreck worth searching for.
The City of Cairo left Bombay at the start of October 1942; dates of 1, 2 and 5 October appear in different accounts. She called at Durban and then sailed from Cape Town at 06:00 on 1 November, bound for Pernambuco (Recife) in Brazil and then Britain. On board were 101 passengers, including 28 or 29 women and 19 children depending on the source, a crew that included two spare Lascar crews recruited in India, and ten DEMS gunners to man her defensive guns.
How was the City of Cairo sunk?
After Cape Town the ship ran about 800 miles (1,300 km) north, zigzagging by day and keeping roughly 45 miles off the African coast, before turning west across the South Atlantic toward Brazil. She was unescorted, slow and, by one account, betrayed by unusually smoky engines. On the evening of 6 November 1942 her smoke was sighted by the German submarine U-68, commanded by Karl-Friedrich Merten, on a patrol that had taken it to South African waters with the Eisbär (“Polar Bear”) wolf pack.
At 21:36 U-68 fired a torpedo that struck abreast of the after mast. Rogerson ordered the ship abandoned, and most people got away in the boats; six men, two crew and four passengers, were lost in the evacuation. The ship settled by the stern but stayed afloat, and Merten fired a second torpedo some 10 to 20 minutes later, depending on the account. It smashed one lifeboat, capsized another and sent the liner down about 480 miles (770 km) south of St Helena. Chief Radio Officer Harry Peever, who had stayed in the wireless room sending distress calls, was killed by that second strike.
U-68 then surfaced among the boats. Merten asked the occupants of Boat 6 for the ship’s name, cargo and whether she carried prisoners of war, gave them a course for the nearest land and left with the words that became the title of the best-known book about the sinking: “Goodnight, sorry for sinking you.” St Helena lay roughly 500 miles away, Africa about 1,000 and Brazil about 2,000. Merten is reported to have privately thought their chances of survival were poor.
What happened in the lifeboats?
Six boats got away. The survivors decided to steer for St Helena, a small target in a very large ocean, with one sextant between them, rescued from the ship by Second Officer Les Boundy, plus the boats’ compasses and the captain’s wristwatch for timekeeping. Water was rationed to about 110 ml per person per day in tropical heat. Rogerson tried to keep the boats together, but damaged rudders and masts, leaks and different sailing speeds drove them apart over the following days, and people began to die of thirst, exposure and exhaustion.
On 19 November, after 13 days at sea, the ship Clan Alpine found Boat 6 and then, guided by its survivors, Boats 7 and 5, and landed the survivors at St Helena. The same evening the steamer Bendoran picked up another boat and took its survivors to Cape Town. In those four boats the dead were disproportionately Lascar seamen, as the boat-by-boat tallies show, and several more people died after rescue aboard the ships or in hospital on St Helena.
The last two boats had far longer ordeals. On 12 December three survivors who had been adrift for 36 days were picked up by the German blockade runner Rhakotis, on passage from Japan to Bordeaux; one of them, Diana Jarman, died aboard. On 1 January 1943 the Rhakotis was intercepted and sunk by the cruiser HMS Scylla off Cape Finisterre, and the two remaining City of Cairo survivors lived through their second sinking, one rescued by U-410 and landed in France, the other reaching Spain in a lifeboat. Boat 4, carrying 17 people, missed St Helena and turned west for South America. When the Brazilian minelayer Caravelas found it on 27 December, after 51 days and within about 80 miles of the coast, only Third Officer James Whyte and a passenger, Margaret Gordon, were alive. Whyte was awarded the MBE and Gordon the BEM. Whyte was killed months later when the City of Pretoria, the ship taking him home, was torpedoed in March 1943.
How many people died?
Totals differ slightly between sources. The detailed reconstruction in the standard account counts 302 people aboard, of whom 107 died and 195 survived: 6 in the sinking, 94 in the boats and 7 after rescue. Press coverage of the salvage and the salvor’s account give 104 dead out of 302, and one report gave 311 aboard, the ship’s nominal capacity. Either way, roughly a third of the people aboard died, nearly all of them after reaching the lifeboats. Some of the names of those lost are inscribed on the Tower Hill Memorial in London, the memorial to merchant seafarers lost in the two world wars.
The sinking did not end Merten’s story. He was credited with 27 ships totalling about 170,000 gross register tons and received the Oak Leaves to his Knight’s Cross on 16 November 1942, ten days after the City of Cairo went down. After the war he worked in ship salvage and shipbuilding. On 14 September 1984 he attended a reunion of 17 City of Cairo survivors aboard HMS Belfast in London, held to mark the publication of Ralph Barker’s book Goodnight, Sorry for Sinking You. U-68 herself was sunk northwest of Madeira on 10 April 1944 with the loss of 56 men; one survived.
How was the wreck found?
For nearly seventy years the silver was simply out of reach. That changed with the development of commercial deep-water search and recovery systems in the 2000s. Deep Ocean Search, a company led by the British salvor John Kingsford, began searching in 2011 under a contract with the UK government; one account specifies the UK Ministry of Transport, and it was the Department for Transport that later gave permission for the recovery to be announced. Kingsford’s team reconstructed the sinking position from declassified government papers, the sinking reports of both the ship and the U-boat, and the eyewitness account of the ship’s surgeon, Dr Douglas Quantrill.
From the survey vessel John Lethbridge, the team towed sonar over a box of about 1,500 square nautical miles in a “mowing the lawn” pattern, paying out roughly 11,000 m of cable to reach the bottom. After about three weeks they had a candidate target. A remotely operated vehicle (ROV) was sent down to look. No name board or bell was visible, so the identification rested on matching the pattern of portholes in the ROV images against the ship’s plans and photographs, a comparison that took about six hours. The hull was found broken in two and deeply buried in seabed silt, and the tail section of the second torpedo was lying nearby.
How was the silver recovered from 5,150 m?
Working at about 5,150 m (some 17,000 ft), the salvors faced a water pressure of around 500 bar, roughly 500 times atmospheric pressure at the surface. Their ROV was rated to 6,000 m, but every operation meant lowering it through five kilometres of water on a cable from a ship holding position on the surface to work on a broken hull half buried in silt. According to Kingsford’s own account, the vehicle broke down repeatedly and the team was lucky to get two hours of useful work on the seabed in a day.
The logistics were as punishing as the engineering. The ship could stay on site for about three weeks at a time; then it was three days to port, two days in port and three days back. The operation ran for eight months and ended in September 2013; the team finally left the site on 25 September, leaving behind a memorial plaque for those who died, reported to read: “We came here with respect.” The government permitted the recovery to be announced only in April 2015.
Deep Ocean Search has never said exactly how much of the cargo it raised. A memorial website for the ship describes “several tens of tons” of coins recovered, and reports at the time valued the recovered silver at about £34 million, or around US$50 million, describing it as a large share of the total. Guinness World Records recognizes the operation as the deepest salvage of cargo from a shipwreck. The team’s previous recoveries had been at roughly 3,000 to 4,000 m, and the best-known earlier deep silver salvage, Odyssey Marine Exploration’s recovery of about 110 tons of silver from the SS Gairsoppa off Ireland, was carried out at about 4,700 m.
What happened to the coins?
The silver belonged to the British Treasury, and under the salvage contract the proceeds were shared between the government and the salvors in proportions that were not made public. Most of the coins were melted down in the UK and sold as bullion. Not all of them were destroyed, however: the London Mint Office, part of the Norwegian Samlerhuset group, saved 21,993 coins, which were conserved and sold to collectors as single coins and small sets, with a donation planned for a Merchant Navy charity. A handful were given to people connected with the ship’s story through Kingsford. The recovered rupees, struck under three British monarchs, are among the few pieces of the cargo now in private hands.
One report in 2015 also noted that the money generated by the recovery was the subject of a legal dispute over ownership, a common complication in modern deep-water salvage, where the rights of governments, insurers, cargo owners and salvors overlap. Compared with many older treasure wrecks, the starting position was simpler: the ship was British, the cargo had belonged to the British state, and the search was carried out under a government contract rather than by a freelance treasure hunter claiming finders’ rights.
Why does the City of Cairo matter?
The City of Cairo sits at the meeting point of two very different stories. One is the human cost of the Battle of the Atlantic for merchant seafarers and passengers, including the Indian Lascar crews whose losses were heavy and are often left out of popular accounts. The other is a technical milestone: proof that a small private company could find a wreck by archival detective work, identify it by its portholes and recover cargo from more than five kilometres down. For a comparison with treasure recovered from much older and shallower wrecks, see the shipwreck treasure index, the gold of the SS Central America and the colonial silver of the Mercedes, whose recovered coins were returned to Spain after a court battle.
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 21 Oct 1914 | Launched at Hull for Ellerman Lines |
| Early Oct 1942 | Sails from Bombay with silver coins in 2,182 boxes |
| 1 Nov 1942 | Leaves Cape Town for Pernambuco |
| 6 Nov 1942 | Torpedoed twice by U-68, about 770 km south of St Helena |
| 19 Nov 1942 | Four boats rescued by Clan Alpine and Bendoran |
| 12 Dec 1942 | Three survivors picked up by the blockade runner Rhakotis |
| 27 Dec 1942 | Boat 4 found off Brazil after 51 days; two alive |
| 14 Sep 1984 | Survivors’ reunion with Merten aboard HMS Belfast |
| 2011 | Deep Ocean Search begins the search under UK government contract |
| Sept 2013 | Eight-month salvage from about 5,150 m completed |
| April 2015 | Recovery announced |
What treasure was on the SS City of Cairo?
Silver rupee coins packed in 2,182 boxes, reported as about 100 tonnes (some sources say 122 tons), shipped from Bombay for the British Treasury.
How deep is the City of Cairo wreck?
About 5,150 m (17,000 ft) in the South Atlantic, roughly 770 km south of St Helena.
Who recovered the City of Cairo silver?
Deep Ocean Search, led by John Kingsford, working under a UK government contract. The salvage was completed in September 2013 and announced in 2015.
How much silver was recovered?
The exact amount was not disclosed. Reports valued the recovered coins at about £34 million (around US$50 million), a large share of the cargo.
What sank the City of Cairo?
Two torpedoes from the German submarine U-68, commanded by Karl-Friedrich Merten, on 6 November 1942.
How many people died?
Sources give 104 or 107 of about 302 aboard. Only six died in the sinking itself; most died in the lifeboats.
What does “Goodnight, sorry for sinking you” mean?
Those were the words Merten spoke to survivors in Boat 6 before leaving. Ralph Barker used them as the title of his book about the sinking.
What happened to the coins?
Most were melted down and sold; 21,993 were saved by the London Mint Office and sold to collectors.
- Gard (2015). Pioneering cargo salvage at record depth recovered tons of wartime silver. gard.no.
- Guinness World Records. Deepest salvage of cargo from a shipwreck.
- BBC News (April 2015). Divers recover £34m of silver coins from ship sunk by U-boat (via newssniffer archive).
- SS City of Cairo memorial website. The wreck. sscityofcairo.co.uk.
- Wikipedia contributors. SS City of Cairo; Karl-Friedrich Merten; German submarine U-68 (1940); SS Gairsoppa (accessed via Kiwix mirror, 2023 edition).
- Barker, R. (1984). Goodnight, Sorry for Sinking You: The Story of the SS City of Cairo. Collins.
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.
About Blane Perun → More on Shipwreck Treasure →