Scuba Spearfishing — Where It’s Legal, What’s Banned and How to Do It Right
It depends on where you dive. Spearfishing on scuba is allowed in Florida state waters, with banned species, closed areas and gear limits, and it is widespread in Norway. It is banned in the Bahamas (where spearguns are banned too), along the West Hawaii coast of the Big Island since late December 2013, and, according to a 2023 Wikipedia summary, in Mexico and Puerto Rico. In Florida, invasive lionfish are the big exception: no size or bag limit, an open season all year, and rebreather divers may spear them. Always check the fisheries agency for the exact place you will dive.
A scuba diver can stay down far longer than a breath-hold diver and pick out the largest fish, which in many species are the most productive breeders. Spearfishing has been linked to local declines of large groupers and sea bass. Supporters point out that spearing is highly selective, uses no bait and has no bycatch, and that bag limits apply whatever the method.
Is it legal to spearfish with scuba gear?
There is no single answer: many places that welcome breath-hold spearfishing close it to divers on scuba.
Wikipedia’s overview of spearfishing (2023 snapshot) puts it plainly: spearfishing can be done by freediving, snorkelling or scuba diving, but spearfishing while using scuba equipment is illegal in some countries, and some jurisdictions, New Zealand among them, also outlaw mechanically powered spearguns. The rules are set nation by nation, and often state by state or park by park, so a technique that is routine off one coast can lead to confiscated gear a short boat ride away.
| Place | Spearfishing on scuba | Key details (check before you dive) |
|---|---|---|
| Florida state waters | Allowed, with restrictions | Prohibited species and areas; powerheads, bangsticks and rebreathers banned (rebreathers allowed for lionfish only) |
| Bahamas | Not allowed | Spearguns also banned; visitors need a spear endorsement on a sportfishing permit; Hawaiian sling or pole spear only |
| West Hawaii (Big Island) | Not allowed | Scuba and rebreather spearfishing banned in the West Hawaii Regional Fishery Management Area since late December 2013 |
| Mexico | Not allowed | Per a 2023 Wikipedia summary; powerheads also banned; penalties can include fines, confiscation and imprisonment |
| Puerto Rico | Not allowed | Per a 2023 Wikipedia summary; freediving with a speargun is allowed in marine waters |
| Norway | Widespread | Per a 2023 Wikipedia summary; restrictions centre on anadromous species and lobster |
| Marine parks and no-take zones | Generally not allowed | Most protected areas close to all spearing; Florida state park waters bar loaded spear gear |
The table summarises the places divers ask about most. It is a starting point, not legal advice. Regulations change, and the details that matter, such as which species are closed this season or exactly where a park boundary runs, are published by the fisheries agency for each area. Your dive operator will usually know the local position, and in places where spearfishing is restricted many dive boats simply do not allow spearguns on board.

What are Florida’s scuba spearfishing rules?
Florida is one of the most popular places in the United States to spear fish on scuba, and the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) publishes the state rules. The FWC defines spearfishing as catching or taking fish with a hand or mechanically propelled spear or lance, single or multi-pronged, barbed or barbless, operated by a person swimming at or below the surface. The definition does not depend on how the diver breathes, so the same rules apply to scuba divers and snorkellers, with one important gear exception: the use of powerheads, bangsticks and rebreathers remains prohibited.
The FWC lists the species that may not be taken by spearing. They are billfish of all species, spotted eagle ray, manta ray, sturgeon, sharks, bonefish, tarpon, goliath grouper, snook, Nassau grouper, spotted seatrout, red drum, weakfish, blue crab, stone crab, lobster, pompano, African pompano, permit and tripletail. Whole families of ornamental reef fish are also off limits: surgeonfish, trumpetfish, angelfish, butterflyfish, porcupinefish, cornetfish, squirrelfish, trunkfish, damselfish, parrotfish, pipefish, seahorses, puffers, and triggerfish other than gray and ocean triggerfish. Any species not on the list may be speared, subject to the normal size limits, bag limits and seasons that apply to every angler.
| Florida rule (FWC) | What it means |
|---|---|
| Gear | Powerheads, bangsticks and rebreathers prohibited |
| Near beaches, piers, bridges | No spearfishing within 100 yards of a public swimming beach, a commercial or public fishing pier, or a bridge open to public fishing |
| Jetties | No spearfishing within 100 feet of the above-water part of a jetty, except the last 500 yards of a jetty longer than 1,500 yards |
| Upper Keys | No spearfishing in Monroe County from Long Key north to the Dade County line |
| Fresh water | No spearfishing, and no possession of a speargun in or on fresh water |
| State parks | No spearfishing in waters under the Division of Recreation and Parks; gear must be unloaded and stored |
Location rules matter just as much. Spearfishing is banned within 100 yards of a public swimming beach, a commercial or public fishing pier, or any part of a bridge from which public fishing is allowed. It is banned within 100 feet of any part of a jetty that is above the surface, except for the last 500 yards of a jetty that extends more than 1,500 yards from shore. It is banned in fresh water, where even possessing a speargun is prohibited. It is banned in waters under the jurisdiction of the state Division of Recreation and Parks, where spearfishing equipment may only be carried unloaded and properly stored. Volusia County has its own inland-water rule, allowing only flounder and sheepshead to be speared, and only with a barbed spear of three or fewer prongs.
The best-known closure covers much of the Florida Keys. The FWC’s spearing page bans spearfishing in Monroe County from Long Key north to the Dade County line; the FWC’s lionfish page describes the same boundary as the Miami-Dade County line. Either way, the upper and middle Keys, which include some of the most-dived reefs in the state, are closed to spearfishing in state waters, and federal sanctuary zones within the Keys carry their own restrictions. Divers who want to spear in the Keys usually head south and west of Long Key or offshore, and check the sanctuary zone maps first.
Why are lionfish the exception?
Red lionfish and devil firefish are native to the Indo-Pacific and Red Sea, and the FWC describes them as an invasive species with a potential negative impact on native wildlife and habitat. The agency actively encourages divers, anglers and commercial harvesters to remove them. In Florida they have no minimum size, no daily bag limit and an open season all year, and these rules apply in both Gulf and Atlantic state and federal waters. The FWC notes that lionfish are now found year-round in Florida waters and from North Carolina to South America, in almost every estuarine and marine habitat, and in water as deep as 1,000 feet.
Several rules are relaxed for lionfish hunters. A recreational fishing licence is not required when a diver targets lionfish with a pole spear, a Hawaiian sling, a hand-held net, or a spearing device designed and marketed exclusively for lionfish; other methods, including hook and line, need a licence unless the angler is exempt. Divers using rebreathers are permitted to spear and remove lionfish, even though rebreathers are banned for all other spearfishing. Hand-held nets may be used in the places where spears are not allowed. The FWC also issues special event permits to tournaments, dive clubs and other organised events that want to remove lionfish and other invasive species by spearing in state waters that are otherwise closed to it.
Lionfish are rarely caught on hook and line, so the FWC lists spearing and hand-held nets as the most effective ways to remove them, and it asks divers to take care that spears do not hit and damage the reef. Feeding speared lionfish to sharks, groupers or eels is a common temptation; the FWC calls the practice dangerous and illegal, and says it has also proven ineffective. Many Florida dive operators run dedicated lionfish trips, and tournaments and removal events are held through the year.
Handling is the main hazard. The FWC warns that lionfish carry up to 18 venomous spines on the dorsal, pelvic and anal fins, and that stings can cause swelling, blistering, dizziness, tissue death and even temporary paralysis. Its first-aid advice is to soak the wound in hot but not scalding water for 30 to 90 minutes and seek medical attention if needed. The venom stays active in the spines after the fish is dead and on ice, and the venom tissue runs right to the base of each spine, so puncture-resistant gloves and a rigid containment tube are worth carrying. Read more in our lionfish guide.
Do you need a dive flag to spearfish in Florida?
Yes. Florida statute 327.331 requires all divers, whether on scuba or snorkel, to display a divers-down warning device in the area where they are diving, other than in areas customarily used only for swimming. The device is a red flag or buoy with a white diagonal stripe; the symbol must be at least 12 by 12 inches when displayed from the water and at least 20 by 24 inches when flown from a boat, and a flag must be stiffened so it stays unfurled with no wind. On open water, divers must make reasonable efforts to stay within 300 feet of the device, and boats must try to keep 300 feet away; on rivers, inlets and navigation channels the distance is 100 feet. A boat that comes inside those distances must slow to the minimum speed needed to steer. The flag must come down once all divers are out of the water.
For a spearfisher, the float that carries the flag has a second job. Spearfishing floats are often bright, torpedo-shaped buoys attached by a floatline, and they can hold a catch away from the diver as well as warn passing boats. See our guide to the diver-down flag for the differences between the red-and-white flag and the blue-and-white Alpha flag used elsewhere.
Can you spearfish on scuba in the Bahamas?
No. The Bahamas Department of Marine Resources’ sport fishing regulations guide answers the question directly: scuba gear or an air compressor may not be used for fishing. The same guide says the use of a speargun for fishing is not allowed in the Bahamas. Visitors fishing from a foreign-owned vessel are limited to hook and line unless the issuing officer specifically authorises a spear on their sportfishing permit. That permission covers a pole spear or a spear launched from a hand-held sling, which Bahamians call a Hawaiian sling, and it must be endorsed in writing on the permit. The guide describes the authorisation as easy to get.
Even with a sling, location limits apply. Spearfishing is not allowed within 1 mile of the coast of New Providence or of the southern coast of Freeport, Grand Bahama, and it is prohibited within 200 yards of the coast of any Family Island. Sharks have been protected in Bahamian waters since a 2011 amendment and must be released unharmed if hooked. Visitors’ catches are also capped; the guide limits demersal fish such as snappers and groupers to 60 pounds or 20 fish, whichever is less, alongside limits on pelagic fish, lobster in season and conch. The result is that Bahamas spearfishing is a breath-hold activity with simple tools, and scuba divers who want to hunt there need to leave the tank on the boat.
Is scuba spearfishing legal in Hawaii?
Not on the west side of the Big Island. The ban is part of a package of West Hawaii fishing rules that took about ten years to develop, spanning three state administrations, according to Honolulu Civil Beat. The Board of Land and Natural Resources voted in favour of the rules in June 2013, and Governor Neil Abercrombie signed them in mid-December 2013, about six months later, saying he had taken time to consider views from both sides. The rules took effect later that month. The board’s own chair, William Aila, an experienced fisherman, opposed them.
The rules apply in the West Hawaii Regional Fishery Management Area, which a Department of Land and Natural Resources release described as about 147 miles of coast from Upolu Point in North Kohala to Ka Lae in Kau. They prohibit scuba or rebreather spearfishing, and also the possession of such gear together with a spear or speared aquatic life. The same package banned taking nine species of inshore sharks and rays and two invertebrate predators of crown-of-thorns starfish, limited aquarium collectors to a list of 40 fish species, and created a 1,500-foot Fish Replenishment Area at Kaohe Bay in South Kona. Hawaii’s other islands follow statewide rules, which divers should check with the state Division of Aquatic Resources before bringing a speargun.
Where else is scuba spearfishing banned or allowed?
A 2023 snapshot of Wikipedia’s spearfishing article summarises several national rules, and it is worth treating each as a pointer to the official source rather than the final word. In Mexico, it says, a regular fishing permit allows spearfishing, but not with electro-mechanical spearguns; spearfishing with scuba gear is illegal, as are powerheads, and penalties are described as severe, including fines, confiscation of gear and even imprisonment. In Puerto Rico, freediving with a speargun is allowed in marine waters, but spearfishing with scuba gear or in fresh water is not.
Other countries take a different line. The same article describes Norway as having one of the most liberal spearfishing regimes in the northern hemisphere, with spearfishing on scuba widespread among recreational divers and restrictions limited mainly to anadromous species such as Atlantic salmon and sea trout, and to lobster. Australia, it says, allows only recreational spearfishing and generally only breath-hold diving, with state and territory rules on protected areas, protected species, size and bag limits and equipment. In the United Kingdom spearfishing is not regulated as such but falls under local bylaws and national rules on species and minimum sizes, and it is not permitted in fresh water or in non-tidal rivers.
Competition spearfishing has settled the scuba question for itself. CMAS, the world governing body, defines competitive spearfishing as hunting and capturing fish underwater without the aid of artificial breathing devices, using gear that depends entirely on the competitor’s physical strength. In practice that means sport spearfishing at the highest level is a breath-hold discipline, and record lists kept by bodies such as the International Underwater Spearfishing Association apply their own rules meant to ensure fair competition.
Why is spearfishing on scuba banned in so many places?
The core argument is efficiency. A breath-hold hunter has seconds to a few minutes at depth before returning to the surface; a scuba diver can stay down for much of an hour, wait out wary fish, search caves and ledges, and work deeper reefs that freedivers rarely reach. That extra time lets a hunter pick the largest fish on a reef. In many reef fish, particularly groupers and other slow-growing, long-lived species, the largest individuals produce a disproportionate share of the eggs, so removing them can depress a population faster than catch numbers alone suggest. Aggregations that gather to spawn are especially vulnerable to a diver who can stay among them.
History supports the concern. Wikipedia’s spearfishing article notes that spearfishing has been implicated in local disappearances of the Atlantic goliath grouper on Bonaire, the Nassau grouper on the barrier reef off Belize, and the giant black sea bass in California. It also describes a shift in spearfishing culture: in the 1960s and 1970s many spearfishers treated the ocean as an unlimited resource and sold their catch, a practice the article says is now heavily frowned upon in leading spearfishing nations. Florida’s closed list reflects the same history, with goliath and Nassau grouper and many of the most visible reef fish all protected from spears.
There is another side. The same source reports that in places where spearfishing is regulated by fisheries agencies, such as Australia and South Africa, it has been found to be among the most environmentally friendly forms of fishing, because it is highly selective, has no bycatch, causes no habitat damage, creates no pollution and need not harm protected species. Supporters of scuba spearfishing argue that bag and size limits control the catch whatever the method, and that a careful diver who identifies each fish before shooting takes fewer unwanted fish than a line or net. The debate is less about the spear than about time at depth, and different regulators have weighed it differently.
How did spearfishing on scuba begin?
Spearing fish is one of the oldest fishing methods. Modern underwater spearfishing grew up in the 1920s on the Mediterranean coasts of France and Italy, where sport spearfishers using simple watertight goggles drove the development of the modern mask, fins and snorkel. According to Wikipedia’s history of the sport, modern scuba diving itself had part of its genesis in the systematic use of rebreathers by Italian sport spearfishers in the 1930s, a practice that caught the attention of the Italian Navy and fed into its wartime frogman units.
In the United States, small groups in California had been spearfishing for less than a decade by 1940, mostly with imported European gear, while local innovators such as Charlie Sturgill, Jack Prodanovich and Wally Potts designed and built equipment for California divers. Sturgill is credited with winning a 1951 competition with his own pole spear design against rivals using spearguns. Attempts in the 1960s to make spearfishing an Olympic sport failed, and record-keeping passed instead to specialist bodies, which today list record catches by species under rules meant to ensure fair competition.
What gear do you need for scuba spearfishing?
Spearfishing adds a weapon and a catch to normal scuba kit, so streamlined gear matters.
| Tool | How it works | Where it fits |
|---|---|---|
| Pole spear | Shaft with a rubber loop at the back; the diver stretches the band and releases | Lionfish and small reef fish; legal in many places that ban guns |
| Hawaiian sling | Elastic band on a tube or handle launches a free spear | Short range; the only tool many Bahamas visitors may use |
| Band speargun | Latex bands launch a tethered shaft from a trigger mechanism | Most popular type of gun; banned in the Bahamas |
| Pneumatic speargun | Compressed gas drives the shaft | Compact, but generally less powerful than band guns |
The simplest tools are the pole spear and the Hawaiian sling. A pole spear is a long shaft with a point at one end and an elastic loop at the other, made of aluminium, titanium, fibreglass or carbon fibre, often in sections that screw together or fold for travel. A Hawaiian sling is a spear launched through a tube or handle by an elastic band. Both are short-range tools, which suits scuba divers hunting lionfish on a reef, and both are permitted in more places than spearguns. A speargun launches a tethered shaft from a trigger; the most popular are powered by latex rubber bands, while pneumatic guns use compressed gas and are generally less powerful.
The rest of the kit is about handling the catch safely. A stringer, typically a cable or cord with a sharp metal pin, holds speared fish; in areas with sharks, some divers clip it to the float rather than to themselves. Lionfish hunters use rigid containment tubes with a one-way opening so the spines never touch the diver. Cut-resistant gloves protect hands when retrieving fish from rock or coral and when loading bands. A knife or line cutter is carried in case the diver tangles in a spear line or floatline; see our guide to dive knives. Keep hoses and gauges clipped close, because spearfishers often work near the bottom where entanglement and reef contact are more likely.
Is scuba spearfishing safe?
Spearfishing adds hazards on top of ordinary diving. The first is task loading: stalking a fish draws attention away from depth, gas and buddy, and it is easy to follow a fish deeper or further than planned. Set a turn pressure before the dive and keep a surface reserve of about 500 psi or 50 bar. Ascend slowly, at no more than about 10 metres (30 feet) per minute, the rate PADI and the US Navy use, and make the usual three-minute safety stop at about 5 metres (15 feet), even with a stringer of fish pulling at you. A heavy catch also changes buoyancy and trim, so adjust the BCD as the load grows.
The second hazard is the spear itself. Treat a loaded gun like a firearm: load it only in the water, never point it at a person, and unload it before surfacing or climbing onto a boat. Know what is behind the target, since a missed shot can travel well past the fish and strike a buddy or the reef. The third is wildlife. A struggling, bleeding fish attracts sharks and other predators, so dispatch the catch quickly, get it out of the water or onto the float, and be prepared to give it up rather than contest it. Finally, fly the dive flag and surface close to it or to the boat. For the wider picture, read scuba diving dangers.
How can you spearfish on scuba ethically?
The best spearfishers take less than the law allows. Shoot only fish you will eat and can identify with certainty, because a closed species speared by mistake still counts as a violation and is still a dead fish. Avoid the biggest individuals of slow-growing species, leave spawning aggregations alone, and never shoot in marine parks or no-take zones. Stay off the reef while hunting; a spear that misses can break coral, and a diver kneeling to steady a shot does the same. Learn the local fish first with our guides to groupers and parrotfish, both of which include species that are protected or important to reef health.
In the western Atlantic, Gulf and Caribbean, hunting invasive lionfish is the clearest case where spearing on scuba helps the reef, and in Florida it is the form of spearfishing the state most actively encourages. If you are new to spearfishing, consider a lionfish or spearfishing specialty course with a local operator before going out alone, and build the skill on the easy target first. Good buoyancy, patience and restraint make a better spearfisher than a bigger gun.
Is it legal to spearfish with scuba gear?
It depends on the place. Florida allows it with species, area and gear limits; the Bahamas, West Hawaii, Mexico and Puerto Rico ban it.
Can you spearfish on scuba in Florida?
Yes, except for prohibited species and in closed areas such as Monroe County from Long Key north to the Dade County line.
Can you spearfish with scuba in the Bahamas?
No. Scuba and spearguns are banned for fishing; visitors may get permission for a pole spear or Hawaiian sling.
Is scuba spearfishing legal in Hawaii?
It is banned in the West Hawaii Regional Fishery Management Area on the Big Island; check state rules for other islands.
Why is spearfishing with scuba banned in some places?
Scuba gives hunters long bottom times to select the largest breeding fish, which can deplete slow-growing species.
Do you need a license to spear lionfish in Florida?
Not if you use a pole spear, Hawaiian sling, hand-held net or a lionfish-only spearing device.
Can you use a rebreather to spearfish in Florida?
No, except to spear lionfish.
What is the best spear for beginners?
A pole spear or Hawaiian sling: simple, legal in more places and ideal for lionfish.
- Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission — “Spearing” and “Lionfish” recreational regulations pages (myfwc.com, accessed November 2026).
- Florida Statutes — Section 327.331, Divers; divers-down warning device required.
- Bahamas Department of Marine Resources — Sport fishing regulations and updates guide (2020 edition).
- Honolulu Civil Beat — “Gov Approves New Big Island Fishing Restrictions,” December 15, 2013 (includes DLNR release on the West Hawaii rules).
- Wikipedia — “Spearfishing” (2023 snapshot): history, conservation, equipment and national regulations including Mexico, Puerto Rico, Norway and Australia.
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.
About Blane Perun → More on Scuba Diving →