Reef Aquarium Fish Selection — Choosing Reef-Safe Fish That Get Along
Many species of fish can live in a reef aquarium, and choosing among them is one of the most enjoyable parts of planning a tank. It is also where many reef tanks go wrong. The basic rule of thumb is to remember that reef animals are survivors by nature. Not every fish will live in harmony with every other fish, or with corals and invertebrates, and you may have to remove a fish that harms its tankmates. My crowded 40-gallon reef, with about 35 fish, taught me a great deal about how fish behave in a confined reef space, and those lessons shaped how I stocked my multi-zone system. This guide covers the main groups of reef fish and how to choose a community that works.
What does reef safe mean?
A reef-safe fish is one that will not normally eat or damage corals, clams, shrimps, crabs, snails and other invertebrates. The term is a guide, not a guarantee. Many fish are reef safe with caution: usually fine, but individuals may develop a taste for a particular coral or clam mantle. Others are safe with corals but will eat small shrimps or crabs. And a fish that is reef safe as a juvenile may change its habits as it grows. When choosing fish, check what each species eats in the wild and what experienced keepers report, and be prepared to rehome a fish that misbehaves.

Which fish are most common in reef tanks?
The groups most often seen in reef aquariums include the dwarf angelfish of the genus Centropyge, clownfish of the genus Amphiprion, dragonets including mandarinfish, gobies, tangs or surgeonfish, wrasses, blennies, cardinalfish, chromis and other damselfish, anthias, and dottybacks. Each group has its own requirements and quirks.
Are dwarf angelfish reef safe?
Dwarf angelfish of the genus Centropyge are among the most colourful small fish available and are generally a good choice for larger reef tanks, but they are best described as reef safe with caution. In the wild they graze algae and detritus and pick at small invertebrates, and in aquariums some individuals nip at large-polyp stony corals, zoanthids or clam mantles. Larger tanks with plenty of rock to graze reduce the risk.
Common species include the coral beauty (Centropyge bispinosa), Fisher’s angelfish (C. fisheri), flame angelfish (C. loricula), lemonpeel angelfish (C. flavissima), multicolor angelfish (C. multicolor), Eibl’s angelfish (C. eibli) and Potter’s angelfish (C. potteri). Keep only one dwarf angel in most tanks; two will often fight unless the tank is large and they are added together.
What about swallowtail angelfish?
Swallowtail angelfish of the genus Genicanthus are a different group from the dwarf angels, and an earlier version of this page wrongly grouped them with Centropyge. They are open-water planktivores that feed on zooplankton rather than grazing on rock, which makes them among the safest angelfish for coral tanks. The Japanese swallowtail (Genicanthus semifasciatus), the black-spot angelfish (G. melanospilos) and the masked angelfish (G. personatus) are examples. They need large tanks with open swimming space, and the masked angelfish is a rare and expensive deep-water fish best left to specialists.
Are clownfish good reef fish?
Clownfish are among the most popular reef fish and most are excellent choices. The ocellaris clownfish (Amphiprion ocellaris), with its vivid orange body and white bands, is one of the most recognisable aquarium fish and is widely captive-bred, which makes it hardy and reduces pressure on wild populations. The percula clownfish (A. percula) is similar. Clownfish do not need an anemone, though many will adopt one or will host a coral instead.
Most clownfish are good reef fish, with the main exception of the maroon clownfish (Premnas biaculeatus), which grows large and can become very aggressive, especially females. Clownfish of all species become territorial around their chosen host, and keeping more than one pair, or mixing species, often leads to fighting in all but very large tanks.
Which gobies are best for reef tanks?
Gobies are one of the largest families of fish and include many excellent reef species. They fall roughly into three groups in the hobby: sand-sifting gobies, shrimp gobies and small reef gobies. Sand sifters such as the diamond goby or maiden goby (Valenciennea puellaris) and the orange-marked goby (Amblygobius decussatus) take mouthfuls of sand and filter out small animals, keeping the sand bed turned. They need a mature tank with a healthy sand bed, and some can starve in tanks that lack enough food in the sand.
Shrimp gobies live in burrows with alpheid pistol shrimps. The shrimp digs and maintains the burrow; the goby, with better eyesight, keeps watch and warns the shrimp of danger. The diagonal shrimp goby (Amblyeleotris diagonalis) and the black-ray shrimp goby (Stonogobiops nematodes) are examples. Watching a goby and shrimp pair is one of the great pleasures of a reef tank.
Small gobies such as the clown gobies of the genus Gobiodon, including the yellow clown goby (G. okinawae), and the panda clown goby (Paragobiodon lacunicola) live among coral branches and generally leave corals and invertebrates alone, though some clown gobies are reported to nip Acropora polyps. The yellowline goby (Elacatinus species) is a cleaner goby from the Caribbean.
The so-called engineer goby (Pholidichthys leucotaenia) is not a true goby. It belongs to its own family, the convict blennies, Pholidichthyidae. Juveniles look like striped catfish and adults become long and eel-like, and they dig extensive tunnels under rockwork, which can undermine an unstable aquascape.
Are tangs reef safe?
Tangs or surgeonfish are herbivores by nature and generally leave corals and invertebrates alone, which makes them popular in reef tanks. They graze algae constantly and can help control it. They are also bright, active and full of character. But they come with serious caveats. Many grow large and are fast, active swimmers that need long tanks; most experienced keepers recommend tanks of at least 4 to 6 feet for the larger species. They are prone to marine ich and other parasites. And they are often aggressive towards other tangs, especially those of similar shape or colour.
Species range from relatively manageable to very demanding. The purple tang (Zebrasoma xanthurum) and the chevron tang (Ctenochaetus hawaiiensis) are kept successfully in larger reef tanks. The Pacific blue tang (Paracanthurus hepatus) is popular but grows to around 30 centimetres and is prone to ich. The Achilles tang (Acanthurus achilles) is beautiful but is regarded as one of the most difficult tangs to keep, needing very high oxygen, strong flow, a large tank and great care with disease. The clown surgeonfish (Acanthurus lineatus) is large and notoriously aggressive. Choose tangs with care, plan for their adult size, and add them last or near last.
What about mandarinfish and dragonets?
Mandarinfish and other dragonets are stunning, peaceful fish that do not harm corals. Their problem is food. In the wild they pick tiny crustaceans such as copepods and amphipods from rock and sand all day long, and many will not accept prepared foods. Without a large, mature tank and a refugium producing a steady supply of live copepods, they often starve slowly. Some captive-bred mandarins now accept frozen foods, which makes them easier, but they are still best kept only in established tanks.
Which other fish suit reef tanks?
Many wrasses are excellent reef fish. Fairy wrasses (Cirrhilabrus) and flasher wrasses (Paracheilinus) are colourful, active and coral safe. Six-line and some other small wrasses eat pests such as flatworms but can bully peaceful fish and eat small shrimps. Larger wrasses can eat invertebrates. Blennies such as the lawnmower blenny and the bicolor blenny graze algae and add personality, though some nip at corals. Cardinalfish, especially the captive-bred Banggai cardinal, are peaceful and slow. Chromis and anthias are schooling planktivores that add movement in the water column, though anthias need frequent feeding.
Which fish should you avoid in a reef tank?
Most large angelfish (Pomacanthus and Holacanthus) eat sponges, tunicates and coral polyps and are not reef safe, though some keepers succeed with them in very large tanks. Most butterflyfish eat coral polyps. Triggerfish and puffers crush invertebrates, and many are aggressive. Large groupers, lionfish and eels eat small fish and crustaceans. Some damselfish, though reef safe, are so aggressive that they make adding any later fish very difficult. Research every species before buying.
How do you match fish to reef zones?
Fish on a real reef are sorted by habitat as much as corals are. Surgeonfish and wrasses patrol the crest and upper slope; planktivores hover above the slope in the current; gobies and blennies live among rubble and branching corals; sand sifters, seahorses and pipefish live in the lagoon. In my earlier 40-gallon tank, many fights broke out because fish that would never share space on a reef were forced into the same few square feet. In my multi-zone system, fish could be placed in the tank whose habitat suited them.
In a single tank, think about where each fish will live. A community of a few open-water fish, a few rock dwellers and one or two sand-bed fish will use the whole tank with less conflict than several fish all competing for the same caves.
Why choose captive-bred fish?
A growing number of reef fish are bred in captivity, including several clownfish, the Banggai cardinalfish, some dottybacks, gobies, blennies and dragonets, and a few angelfish and tangs. Captive-bred fish have several advantages. They are already used to aquarium foods and conditions, so they settle faster and are less likely to refuse food. They usually carry fewer parasites. They are often hardier, having never been through the stress of capture and long-distance shipping. And buying them reduces pressure on wild reefs, where collection practices vary and some species, such as the Banggai cardinalfish, have been heavily depleted. When a captive-bred version of a species is available, it is almost always the better choice.
How do you choose a healthy fish in the shop?
Look before you buy, and if possible watch the fish over more than one visit. A healthy fish swims normally, holds its fins open, has clear eyes and intact fins, and shows no white spots, cloudy patches, rapid breathing or scratching against rock. Its belly should be rounded, not pinched. Ask to see it eat; a fish that ignores food in the shop may never eat in your tank. Avoid fish from tanks with dead or obviously sick fish, even if the one you want looks fine, because diseases spread quickly through shared systems. Ask where the fish came from and how long the shop has had it, since fish that have settled for a week or two are generally safer buys than fresh arrivals.
In what order should you add fish?
Add the most peaceful and least territorial fish first and the most territorial last. Fish that arrive in an empty tank claim territory; fish added later have to find space in an established community. Adding the bullies last means they arrive as newcomers rather than as owners. Add fish a few at a time, allowing the biological filtration to adjust to each increase in load, and watch closely for aggression after each addition. Rearranging a little rockwork before adding a new fish can reset territories.
Should new fish be quarantined?
Yes. Most serious disease outbreaks in reef tanks start with a new fish. Marine ich, velvet and other parasites are difficult to treat in a reef tank because the medications that kill them, such as copper, also kill invertebrates. A separate quarantine tank, where new fish can be observed and treated for several weeks before joining the display, is the best protection. Many reef keepers now use a treatment-based quarantine as standard, especially for tangs and other species prone to parasites.
How many fish can a reef tank hold?
Fewer than most people think. My 40-gallon tank held about 35 fish, which was possible with very careful management but left no margin for error and contributed to the constant territorial disputes. A reef tank needs low nutrient levels for corals, and every fish adds waste. A lightly stocked tank with a few well-chosen fish will be healthier, more stable and often more interesting than a crowded one, because the fish behave naturally rather than fighting for space.
What does reef safe mean?
A fish that normally leaves corals and invertebrates alone. It is a guide, not a guarantee.
Are dwarf angelfish reef safe?
With caution. Some nip LPS corals, zoanthids or clam mantles.
Is the engineer goby a goby?
No. Pholidichthys leucotaenia belongs to the convict blenny family.
Are tangs reef safe?
Usually with corals, but they need large tanks and fight with other tangs.
Which clownfish is most aggressive?
The maroon clownfish, Premnas biaculeatus.
Why do mandarinfish starve?
They eat live copepods and often refuse prepared foods.
In what order should fish be added?
Peaceful fish first, territorial fish last.
Should I quarantine new fish?
Yes, for several weeks, because reef tanks are hard to treat for parasites.
- FishBase, species accounts for Centropyge, Genicanthus, Amphiprion and Acanthurus
- Fenner, R. M. (2001), The Conscientious Marine Aquarist, Microcosm
- Michael, S. W. (2001), Reef Fishes, Vol. 1, Microcosm
- Blane Perun, notes on the 40-gallon and multi-zone reef systems
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.
About Blane Perun →