Exploring Earth's Oceans Since 1999 · Founded by Blane Perun
3,072 Articles·80+ Countries·25 Years of Ocean Science·Site Map
◆ Trending
25 years exploring Earth's oceans,
coral reefs, and the creatures within.
3,072Articles
80+Countries
1999Founded

Paulsgrave Williams: The Wealthy Man Who Chose Piracy

Paulsgrave Williams — The Wealthy Silversmith Who Chose the Pirate Life

Pirates
13 min read
Who was Paulsgrave Williams?

A Rhode Island jeweller and silversmith from a well-to-do family who left his trade and family to become Samuel Bellamy’s quartermaster and fellow captain in 1716. He missed the Whydah wreck because he was visiting relatives on Block Island, took the royal pardon in the Bahamas, then went back to sea under Olivier Levasseur. His final fate is unknown.

Quick facts
Background
Jeweller/silversmith from a wealthy Newport and Block Island family
Partner
Samuel Bellamy — treasure hunt, then piracy from 1716
Ship
Marianne, a converted sloop of about 10 guns (from December 1716)
Survived
Whydah wreck, April 1717 — he was visiting family on Block Island
Fate
Took the 1717–18 pardon; Levasseur’s quartermaster c. 1720; later fate unknown

Paulsgrave Williams is one of the strangest recruits of the Golden Age of Piracy. Most pirates of the 1710s were poor, unemployed seamen with little to lose. Williams was a middle-aged craftsman from one of Rhode Island’s better-connected families, with a wife, children and a trade, when he bankrolled a treasure-hunting voyage with a young sailor named Samuel Bellamy and ended up as Bellamy’s quartermaster and fellow captain. He was not aboard the Whydah Gally when it was wrecked on Cape Cod in April 1717, and that accident of timing let him live on, accept a royal pardon and then return to piracy off Africa and in the Indian Ocean.

Who was Paulsgrave Williams?

He was a Rhode Island jeweller and silversmith, born around 1675–1678, who turned pirate with Samuel Bellamy in 1716, commanded the sloop Marianne in Bellamy’s company, took the king’s pardon after Bellamy died, and was last recorded as quartermaster to the French pirate Olivier Levasseur around 1720.

His first name appears in many spellings: Paulsgrave, Palsgrave and Palgrave are all found, and some records simply call him Paul Williams or even “William Paul”. Birth dates vary too. Wikipedia gives about 1675 in Newport, Rhode Island; other popular accounts give 1678. Either way, he was close to forty when he turned to crime, which made him much older than most of the men he sailed with and far older than Bellamy, who was in his late twenties.

His trade is described in slightly different ways: a Newport jeweller in local histories, a silversmith in Colin Woodard’s history The Republic of Pirates, and a goldsmith in some popular accounts. The common thread is that he worked precious metals, a skilled and respectable occupation in a busy colonial port. What all the sources agree on is that he had a family, money and standing, and that he gave them up.

c. 1675
Approximate birth year (Newport, Rhode Island); some accounts say 1678
53+
Ships captured by the Bellamy–Williams company in about a year
1720
Recorded as quartermaster to Olivier Levasseur
Paulsgrave Williams: The Wealthy Man Who Chose Piracy: Paulsgrave Williams: The Wealthy Man Who Chose Piracy
Paulsgrave Williams: The Wealthy Man Who Chose Piracy

What was his family background?

According to Woodard, Williams’ father was a wealthy merchant who served as Rhode Island’s attorney general, and his mother claimed descent from the Plantagenet kings of England. His father died when Paulsgrave was about eleven. His mother then married a Scottish exile and moved the family from Newport to Block Island, a small island off the Rhode Island coast that was, at the end of the seventeenth century, a busy centre of smuggling and black-market trade.

Block Island shaped him. Local historians record that his family had long-standing ties there, and that as a young man he met Captain William Kidd and Kidd’s wife Sarah on the island. Kidd’s privateering cruise had turned into the most notorious piracy case of its day, and his visit to the New England coast in 1699, before his arrest in Boston, brought him into contact with exactly the kind of island families who traded quietly with pirates. Woodard suggests that growing up in this outlaw-friendly world helps explain why a prosperous craftsman would later find the pirate life thinkable.

By 1715 Williams had a wife, Elizabeth, and young children; sources differ on whether there were two or three. Accounts also differ on where he was living, with some placing him in Newport and others in Boston, where he is said to have met Bellamy. His mother and sisters were still on Block Island, and he would return there at a key moment in 1717.

How did he meet Samuel Bellamy?

The trigger was a natural disaster. In July 1715 a hurricane wrecked the Spanish treasure fleet on its way home from Havana, scattering silver coins and other cargo along the shallow reefs of Florida’s east coast. News of the wrecks drew salvagers and opportunists from all over the Caribbean and the English colonies, and the event is the starting point for a whole generation of pirates. It is told in more detail on our page about the treasure found on the 1715 Treasure Fleet.

Samuel Bellamy was a young English sailor on Cape Cod who, according to tradition, wanted to make his fortune quickly, in part to win over the family of a local woman, Mary Hallett. Williams had the money and connections that Bellamy lacked. The two formed a partnership, with Williams acting as backer and investor, and in early 1716 they sailed south with a few dozen treasure hunters to try their luck on the wrecks. They found little or nothing. Faced with a failed investment and a crew who had nothing to show for the voyage, they traded their small boats for periaguas, large dugout canoes widely used in the Caribbean, and began taking ships instead.

How did the partnership turn to piracy?

Their first steps were clumsy. Early in their career they were chased off a captured sloop by approaching vessels which turned out to be fellow pirates under Henry Jennings, a former privateer who had made his name raiding the Spanish salvage camps. After watching from nearby marshes, Bellamy and Williams joined forces with Jennings to take a French ship. When Jennings sailed off in pursuit of another prize, the two partners looted the French vessel themselves and slipped away before he returned, a move that made them an enemy of one of the most powerful men in the Bahamas.

They found a more useful patron in Benjamin Hornigold, one of the founders of the pirate base at Nassau on New Providence, who disliked Jennings. Hornigold took them into his company, which also sailed alongside the French pirate Olivier Levasseur, known as La Buse, in his ship Postillion. For a time this mixed English and French squadron cruised the Caribbean together, and Williams gained experience under two of the most capable pirate captains of the era.

Hornigold’s reluctance to attack English ships eventually turned his crew against him. In 1716 the men voted him out, elected Bellamy captain of Hornigold’s sloop Marianne, and sent Hornigold and his supporters off in a captured vessel. Bellamy made Williams his quartermaster.

What did a pirate quartermaster do?

On a pirate ship the quartermaster was not a junior officer in the naval sense but the crew’s elected representative and, in practice, the second most powerful person aboard. The captain had absolute authority only during a chase or a fight. At other times the quartermaster kept order, settled quarrels, handed out food and drink, and decided what to take from a captured ship and how it should be shared under the articles the crew had signed. He often led the boarding party and took charge of a prize.

The job suited Williams. As an older man with a background in valuable metals, he was well placed to judge and divide plunder, and his partnership with Bellamy seems to have been closer to an alliance between equals than a captain and subordinate. When the company expanded, Bellamy’s practice was to give captured vessels to trusted men, and Williams was the obvious first choice.

How did Williams come to command the Marianne?

In December 1716, near the Virgin Islands, the company captured two ships, Pearl and Sultana. Bellamy moved into the larger Sultana, armed with 26 guns, and handed the Marianne to Williams as captain. The Pearl was released with the sailors who refused to join. From then on Williams commanded the Marianne, a converted sloop of about ten guns, as the second ship of Bellamy’s squadron.

Over the winter the two ships worked together, taking prizes, meeting a former pirate named John Ham to sell off captured goods, and finally parting company with Levasseur. In February 1717, in the Windward Passage, they sighted the English slave ship Whydah Gally, which was on the last leg of a voyage from West Africa via the Caribbean. They chased her for three days before she surrendered. Bellamy took the Whydah as his flagship and gave her captain the Sultana in exchange, a remarkably generous gesture that suggests the pirates were interested in the ship, not the slaving voyage.

Why wasn’t Williams aboard the Whydah when it sank?

With the Whydah and the Marianne, the company sailed north along the American coast, taking ships as it went. The two vessels were separated by fog and storms off Virginia, then met again and headed towards New England. In April 1717 they agreed to split up for a while. Bellamy took the Whydah towards Cape Cod, while Williams put the Marianne into Block Island to visit his mother and sisters. The arrangement was to meet again later off the coast of Maine.

That family visit almost certainly saved his life. On the night of 26–27 April 1717 a violent nor’easter drove the Whydah onto the outer beach of Cape Cod at what is now Marconi Beach in Wellfleet. Of the 146 people aboard, only two reached the shore alive: the pilot John Julian and the carpenter Thomas Davis. Bellamy was among the dead. A captured wine ship, the Mary Anne, with seven of Bellamy’s men aboard, also ran aground about ten miles to the south, near Pochet Island. The survivors of both wrecks, nine in all, were tried in Boston; six were hanged on 15 November 1717.

The similarity of the names caused confusion that has lasted three centuries. Captain Charles Johnson’s General History of the Pyrates claimed that Williams had died in the storm, probably because the author mixed up Williams’ sloop Marianne with the prize Mary Anne that was lost. Some modern summaries make the opposite mistake and say that Williams’ crew were captured and tried. In fact the men tried in Boston came from the Whydah and the prize; the Marianne and her captain were miles away.

What did Williams do after Bellamy died?

Williams learned of the disaster while waiting off Maine in May 1717. Some accounts suggest he visited the wreck site before sailing south, though this is not certain. His crew included a number of men who had been forced into piracy, among them his carpenter, and on the way south he had to put down a mutiny led by some of these unwilling sailors. He reached the Bahamas at almost the same moment as Richard Noland, Bellamy’s former quartermaster, who had survived the storm in another prize.

By then the Marianne was worn out, and Williams sold her. The timing was significant. On 5 September 1717 King George I issued a proclamation offering a pardon to any pirate who surrendered before a deadline in September 1718, and the offer split the Nassau pirates into those who would accept and those who would hold out. Williams, like Hornigold and many others, took the pardon.

Did he go back to piracy?

He did. The pardon did not keep him ashore for long. Williams went back to sea, first under the pirate captain William Moody and then, by 1720, as quartermaster to his old ally Olivier Levasseur. Moody’s crew had deposed him in late 1718 and elected Levasseur in his place, and the reunited company cruised off West Africa before moving into the Indian Ocean, where Levasseur’s men later operated from Sainte-Marie, a small island off Madagascar. Levasseur went on to one of the richest captures of the age, the Portuguese galleon Nossa Senhora do Cabo, in 1721.

A small human detail survives from this period. Williams was said to resent no longer being a captain, and sailors who wanted to stay on his good side were advised to keep calling him “Captain”. It is a revealing glimpse of a man who had once commanded his own ship and who, now in his mid-forties, found himself back in a subordinate role.

How did Paulsgrave Williams die?

Nobody knows. There is no record of a capture, trial or execution after 1720. Some writers say he retired from piracy around 1723, perhaps under another name and with a new family, and died quietly; Wikipedia notes that this version is not supported by period sources. The likeliest explanation is simply that he left the sea in the Indian Ocean or returned to a settled life somewhere the records do not reach. Unlike most of his shipmates, he does not seem to have ended on a gallows or at the bottom of the sea.

“Williams was a goldsmith with a family and a trade. He left all of it for piracy. He survived the Whydah disaster by accident — he was in a different ship. Then he simply disappears. No trial, no execution, no record.”
— Blane Perun, TheSea.Org

Why is Williams historically important?

Williams matters for three reasons. First, he is a reminder that Golden Age piracy was not only a revolt of the desperate; it could attract men of property who were drawn by money, adventure and perhaps resentment of colonial authority. He is often compared with Stede Bonnet, the Barbados planter who also gave up wealth for piracy, but unlike Bonnet he was a competent seaman whose crews kept him in command.

Second, his career links many of the best-known names of the era. Through him, Bellamy’s company connects to Jennings, Hornigold, Levasseur and Moody, and to the shift of piracy from the Caribbean to West Africa and the Indian Ocean after the pardon of 1717–1718. Third, his absence from the Whydah has shaped the story of that ship. Had he been aboard, Bellamy’s company would have ended completely on Cape Cod in 1717.

Where to see the story today
Artefacts from the Whydah, discovered by Barry Clifford in 1984 and identified beyond doubt when the ship’s bell was recovered in 1985, are displayed at the Whydah Pirate Museum in West Yarmouth on Cape Cod, which opened in 2016. The Marianne was never found, but Williams appears throughout the museum’s account of Bellamy’s company. See Whydah Gally museum.
Frequently asked questions

Who was Paulsgrave Williams?

A Rhode Island jeweller or silversmith, born around 1675, who turned pirate with Samuel Bellamy in 1716, served as his quartermaster and then captained the sloop Marianne, and later sailed with Olivier Levasseur.

Why did Williams become a pirate?

No statement from him survives. He financed a failed 1716 treasure hunt on the wrecks of the 1715 Spanish fleet with Bellamy, and the partners turned to piracy rather than return empty-handed. A Block Island upbringing among smugglers may have made the choice easier.

How did Williams survive the Whydah wreck?

He was not with Bellamy. In April 1717 he had taken the Marianne to Block Island to visit his family, planning to meet the Whydah later off Maine, so he missed the storm that wrecked her on Cape Cod.

Was Williams’ crew captured and hanged?

No. The nine men tried in Boston came from the Whydah and from a captured wine ship called the Mary Anne, which is often confused with Williams’ sloop Marianne.

Did Paulsgrave Williams accept a pardon?

Yes. After Bellamy’s death he returned to the Bahamas, sold the Marianne and accepted King George I’s pardon of 1717–1718, but he was back at sea within a year or two.

What happened to Williams in the end?

He was quartermaster to Olivier Levasseur around 1720. After that his fate is unknown; claims that he retired in 1723 are not supported by period sources.

Where can you see Whydah artefacts?

At the Whydah Pirate Museum in West Yarmouth, Cape Cod, which displays finds from the wreck discovered by Barry Clifford in 1984.

Sources & further reading
  1. Woodard, C. (2007). The Republic of Pirates. Harcourt. Williams’ family, Block Island and partnership with Bellamy.
  2. Johnson, C. (1724). A General History of the Pyrates, vol. 2. London: T. Woodward.
  3. Jameson, J.F. (1923). Privateering and Piracy in the Colonial Period. New York: Macmillan, 293–295.
  4. Konstam, A. (2011). Pirates: The Complete History from 1300 BC to the Present Day. Lyons Press.
  5. Clifford, B. & Perry, P. (1999). Expedition Whydah. Cliff Street Books.
  6. Sandler, M.W. (2017). The Whydah: A Pirate Ship Feared, Wrecked, and Found. Candlewick Press.
  7. Selinger, G. (2017). Pirates of New England: Ruthless Raiders and Rotten Renegades. Rowman & Littlefield.
  8. Newport Historical Society, notes on Paulsgrave Williams and Block Island.
BP
Last updated May 18, 2026
Written by
Blane Perun

Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.

About Blane Perun →More on Pirates →
Coral Aquaculture · The Pioneer Story
Blane Perun, A coral aquaculture pioneer

Built one of the first home reef tanks designed as a multi-zone replica of natural reef conditions. Author of long-form profiles cited by Wikipedia, Quality Marine, and SeaScope. Independent — no advertisers, no sponsored placements, no editorial board outside the dive log.

Widely credited as the pioneer of named-coral culture in the reef-keeping hobby. The original — “Perun's Purple People Eater”, a Protopalythoa morph from his coral farm — became the first hobbyist coral to carry an aquaculturist's name in trade, sparking the now-standard practice of naming individual coral strains across the industry.

Founded1999 Articles3,072 Countries80+ Cited inWikipedia · Quality Marine · SeaScope
Read Blane's full bio →
The Dispatch · Monthly

Field notes from eighty countries worth of ocean.

One monthly email. New long-form reporting, species profiles, and dive reports — no filler, no tracking pixels, no sponsored placements. Ever.

Sign up and get my one-click underwater color-correction actions for Photoshop — the set I run on my own dive shots. Free.

Get the action now + monthly field notes
No spam · Unsubscribe anytime
Underwater reef photo before and after Blane Perun's Photoshop color-correction action — washed-out blue-green on the left, full natural color restored on the right
Same shot · one click