Mixed Reef Tank — Keeping Soft, LPS and SPS Corals in One Aquarium
A mixed reef tank is a reef aquarium that keeps soft corals, large-polyp stony (LPS) corals and small-polyp stony (SPS) corals together. It works by zoning: SPS high in the strongest light and flow, LPS in the middle and on the sand, and soft corals low or downstream, with water chemistry and nutrients set at a compromise that suits all three. It is the most popular style of reef tank, and the hardest to keep perfectly balanced.
Most reef tanks end up mixed whether or not the owner planned it, because frag swaps and impulse purchases add a bit of everything. The difference between a thriving mixed reef and a struggling one is usually planning: knowing which corals need what, and leaving room for them to grow without stinging or poisoning each other.
How do you zone light in a mixed reef?
Light falls off quickly with depth in a tank, so the vertical layout does most of the work. Place SPS such as Montipora, Pocillopora and hardy Acropora on the highest rock, where PAR is roughly 250 or more. Put LPS such as acans, favia, hammers and torches in the middle and on ledges at about 80–150 PAR, and the most light-tolerant soft corals, mushrooms and zoanthids lower still or in shaded areas at around 50–100 PAR. Measure with a PAR meter once the rock work is built; a light’s rated output tells you little about what reaches each shelf.
Plan the rock work with these zones in mind. A tall central structure or two separated islands give you a high SPS zone near the light, mid-level ledges for LPS and open sand for corals that belong on soft bottoms. Avoid a solid wall of rock against the back glass, which creates dead spots and makes it impossible to give corals the spacing they need.

How should flow be set up?
Flow should be strongest near the surface and the upper rock, where SPS live, and softer lower down. Point pumps across the top of the tank and let the flow break up on the rock work rather than aiming jets at corals. LPS should sway gently; soft corals such as leathers should inflate and shed their waxy coat regularly. Avoid placing corals that release toxins upstream of sensitive stony corals.
What water chemistry suits soft, LPS and SPS corals?
Run the tank to the standards of its most demanding corals, the SPS, for alkalinity, calcium, magnesium and temperature, and to the standards of the LPS and soft corals for nutrients. In practice that means alkalinity steady at about 8–9 dKH, calcium 400–450 ppm, magnesium 1,300–1,400 ppm, and temperature held around 25–26 °C. Nitrate around 2–10 ppm and phosphate around 0.03–0.08 ppm keep LPS and soft corals fed without overwhelming SPS colour.
The compromise means no group is at its absolute best. SPS in a mixed reef are rarely as intensely coloured as in a dedicated low-nutrient system, and soft corals rarely grow as explosively as in a nutrient-rich soft-coral tank. That is the trade-off for variety.
| Coral group | Placement | Light (PAR) | Main need |
|---|---|---|---|
| SPS (Montipora, Acropora) | Top of rock work | 250+ | Stable alkalinity, strong flow |
| LPS (acans, hammers, brains) | Middle ledges and sand | 80–150 | Spacing, target feeding |
| Soft corals (leathers, xenia) | Low, downstream | 50–150 | Room to spread, carbon to absorb toxins |
| Zoanthids, mushrooms | Low rock, shaded areas | 50–100 | Containment; they spread fast |
Why do corals fight in a mixed reef?
Corals compete for space in two ways. Stony corals use physical weapons: sweeper tentacles that reach several centimetres from the colony, and mesenterial filaments, threads of digestive tissue that some species extrude to digest a neighbour. Soft corals mostly use chemicals. Leather corals such as Sarcophyton and Sinularia release terpenes and other compounds that inhibit growth or cause tissue loss in nearby stony corals, and the effect builds up in a closed aquarium.
The practical defences are distance, carbon and choice. Leave 10–15 cm between aggressive species, run activated carbon continuously and change it monthly to absorb toxins, and limit the number of large leathers in a tank with SPS. Watch for spread: green star polyps, xenia and many zoanthids can carpet rock and overgrow stony corals, so many keepers put them on an isolated rock surrounded by sand.
Which corals make a good mixed reef?
A balanced starting list might include Montipora digitata and Montipora capricornis at the top, a Pocillopora or birdsnest colony, acans, a duncan colony and a hammer or frogspawn garden in the middle, a favia brain on a ledge, a small toadstool leather well downstream, and a contained rock of zoanthids and mushrooms on the sand. Add the demanding Acropora only after a year of stable results, and buy aquacultured frags wherever possible.
What fish and cleanup crew suit a mixed reef?
Because the tank holds every kind of coral, it needs fish and invertebrates that leave every kind alone. Most clownfish, gobies, blennies, cardinalfish, anthias, fairy wrasses and tangs are safe, and a tang or two plus a lawnmower blenny help keep algae in check. Dwarf angelfish are the classic risk: some individuals ignore corals for years, others start picking at LPS flesh and clam mantles. Butterflyfish, most large angelfish and triggerfish are best avoided altogether. For the cleanup crew, snails such as Trochus and Cerith, small hermit crabs and a few cleaner shrimp work well; skip large hermits and emerald crabs if you keep delicate zoanthids.
In what order should you add corals to a mixed reef?
Build from the forgiving end. Once the tank has cycled and the first fish are settled, start with hardy soft corals such as mushrooms, a small leather and a contained rock of zoanthids. They tolerate the swings of a new system and tell you whether lighting and flow are reasonable. After a few months of stable testing, add the easier LPS: duncans, candy canes, acans and a hammer or frogspawn. When alkalinity, calcium and magnesium have held steady for several more months and coralline algae is spreading, introduce the tolerant SPS such as Montipora and Pocillopora high on the rock. Demanding Acropora come last, often a year or more after set-up.
Adding corals in that order means each group arrives when the tank can support it, and it spreads the extra demand on alkalinity gradually rather than all at once. It also gives you time to learn how each coral behaves in your system before the next one goes in.
How should you feed a mixed reef?
Feed for the corals that need it most without polluting the rest. Fish are the main nutrient source in any reef, and a mixed reef benefits from generous feeding of quality frozen and pelleted foods once or twice a day. Target-feed LPS such as acans and blastomussa with small meaty foods once or twice a week, with pumps paused. Many soft corals and some SPS take up fine particulate foods and dissolved organics, so some keepers dose small amounts of plankton or amino acid products; start small, watch nitrate and phosphate, and stop if algae appears. The aim is the compromise nutrient band described above, not a sterile tank.
How do you troubleshoot a mixed reef?
In a mixed reef, the pattern of decline tells you where to look. If SPS are browning while LPS and soft corals thrive, nutrients are probably creeping up; increase export with skimming, a refugium or water changes. If SPS are pale and LPS are receding, nutrients are probably too low; feed more. If stony corals in general are losing tissue at the base, check alkalinity stability and temperature first. If one stony coral declines while its neighbours are fine, look for a stinging neighbour or a pest. If growth slows across the whole tank without obvious cause, consider chemical warfare from soft corals and change the carbon, or run an ICP test of the water to look for trace element shortages or contaminants such as metals.
What does a successful mixed reef look like over time?
Most mixed reefs change character as they mature. The fast growers, typically Montipora, xenia, leathers and euphyllids, claim space in the first two or three years, and the keeper’s job shifts from adding corals to pruning, fragging and trading them. Slower species such as brains and many Acropora come into their own later. A well-run mixed reef at five years often looks quite different from the plan, and that is part of the appeal. Keeping a photo log every few months is the easiest way to see how the reef is developing and to spot when one colony begins to crowd another.
What lighting suits a mixed reef?
A mixed reef needs a light that can produce both high intensity at the top of the rock and a gentle spread across the bottom. Multiple LED fixtures, hybrid LED and T5 set-ups and wide fixtures with good optics all work; a single narrow, intense unit tends to create a bright spot in the middle and dim corners. Map the tank with a PAR meter after installation and place corals by the numbers you find: the strongest readings for SPS, the moderate band for LPS, and the dim edges and shaded spots for soft corals and mushrooms. Programme a gradual ramp-up and ramp-down, and keep the peak period to around eight hours to limit algae.
How often should you test a mixed reef?
More often than a soft-coral tank and about as often as an SPS tank. Test alkalinity every day or two while you dial in dosing, then two or three times a week. Calcium and magnesium can be tested weekly, nitrate and phosphate once or twice a week, and salinity and temperature should be monitored continuously. Every few months, an ICP test sent to a laboratory measures dozens of major and trace elements at once and can reveal problems no hobby kit detects, such as rising copper, zinc or tin from failing equipment, or a slow drift in potassium, iodine or strontium. Many mixed-reef keepers schedule one before and after any big change in salt brand or dosing regime.
What size tank suits a mixed reef?
Bigger is easier. The more water a mixed reef has, the more slowly chemistry and temperature drift, and the more room there is to separate aggressive corals and create genuinely different light zones. A tank of 200 litres or more, with a sump, gives a comfortable margin; smaller tanks can work but leave less space between the SPS at the top and the soft corals below, and they need stricter discipline about spacing and pruning. Tank depth matters too: a tank around 50–60 cm deep gives a useful light gradient without forcing the bottom into darkness.
How do you plan the aquascape?
Plan the rock work on paper or on the floor before it goes into the tank. Mixed reefs suit two or three separate rock structures with sand channels between them: one taller island for SPS close to the light, a lower one for LPS, and a small isolated rock for zoanthids or star polyps where they cannot spread. Gaps between structures let water flow around every side of the rock and act as firebreaks against creeping corals. Leave flat shelves and ledges for LPS to spread, crevices for fish to sleep in, and open sand at the front for plate corals, elegance corals and sand-sifting gobies. Secure rock with cable ties, acrylic rods or reef epoxy so nothing can collapse, and keep the structure clear of the glass so you can clean it and so flow can pass behind.
What are the biggest mistakes in a mixed reef?
Three mistakes cause most failures. The first is crowding: buying corals faster than the tank can absorb them and placing them where they look good today rather than where they will fit in two years. The second is chasing numbers: reacting to every test result with a new additive, which creates the very swings stony corals hate. The third is letting one group take over, usually star polyps, xenia or a big leather, until the stony corals are stung, shaded or poisoned. Patience, generous spacing and a steady, boring routine solve all three, and they cost nothing.
How do you maintain a mixed reef?
Testing and dosing are much the same as an SPS tank: alkalinity daily at first, then every few days, calcium and magnesium weekly, nutrients once or twice a week. Feed fish generously, because the LPS and soft corals benefit from the extra nutrients, and target-feed LPS once or twice a week. Prune soft corals and zoanthids before they reach stony corals, and move any coral that shows receding tissue on one side, which usually means a neighbour is stinging it. Keep records; a slow decline in one group often traces back to a change made weeks earlier.
For a single-group approach, see our guides to the LPS reef aquarium and the SPS reef aquarium.
What is a mixed reef tank?
A reef aquarium that keeps soft corals, LPS and SPS corals together, zoned by light and flow.
Can SPS and soft corals live together?
Yes, with distance and activated carbon, but large leather corals can slow SPS growth through chemical warfare.
Where should SPS go in a mixed reef?
At the top of the rock work, in the strongest light and flow.
What nitrate level is best for a mixed reef?
Around 2–10 ppm, a compromise between the low levels SPS prefer and the higher levels soft corals tolerate.
Should a mixed reef run carbon?
Yes. Continuous activated carbon helps absorb the toxins soft corals release.
How far apart should corals be in a mixed reef?
At least 10–15 cm between aggressive species, allowing for growth.
Which corals should be kept out of a mixed reef?
Many keepers avoid green star polyps and xenia on the main rock because they overgrow everything.
Is a mixed reef good for beginners?
It is popular, but a soft-coral or LPS tank is easier to start with. Add SPS once the tank is stable.
- Kraken Corals, “Parameters for your reef”
- Gulf Coast Aquatics, “Coral lighting: PAR targets by coral type”
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.
About Blane Perun →