Manta Ray Intelligence — The Biggest Brain in the Fish World
Manta rays are probably the most intelligent fish we know of. The giant oceanic manta (Mobula birostris) has a brain of up to about 200 g, the largest of any fish and the largest relative to body mass. In a 2016 study, two captive mantas reacted to a mirror with behavior the authors read as self-checking, a possible sign of self-awareness, though other researchers argue it may be social. Mantas also return to the same cleaning stations and feeding sites for years, which suggests long-term spatial memory. The mirror result is debated and has only been tested on two animals.
When people ask how smart manta rays are, the honest answer is: smarter-looking than almost any other fish, but nobody has measured manta intelligence the way researchers measure it in apes, dolphins or crows. What exists is a set of strong clues, from brain size and anatomy to memory in the wild and one famous, much-debated mirror experiment. This page weighs that evidence; for the anatomy of the organ itself, see manta ray brain.
How big is a manta ray’s brain?
The giant oceanic manta (Mobula birostris) has a brain that weighs up to about 200 g. That is five to ten times heavier than the brain of a whale shark, a fish that can weigh many times more. Mantas are generally credited with the largest brain of any fish and the largest brain-to-body mass ratio of any fish. The best-known comparative study, by the neuroscientist Csilla Ari in 2011, examined brain size and organisation across the mobulid rays, the family of mantas and devil rays, and linked their large brains to their ecology.
There are two manta species. The giant oceanic manta reaches about 7 m across the wings and roams open oceans, often far offshore; the smaller reef manta reaches about 5.5 m and tends to stay resident around coasts and reefs. Most of the brain measurements come from the giant manta, while most of the long-term behavioural studies come from reef mantas, which are easier to find and resight. Conclusions about “manta intelligence” therefore mix evidence from two related but different animals.
Brain size on its own is a weak measure of intelligence. Big animals tend to have big brains simply to run big bodies, which is why scientists prefer relative measures such as brain-to-body ratios or comparisons with related species. On those measures mantas still stand out among fish. But a large brain shows capacity, not how it is used. The evidence that mantas use that capacity comes from behaviour.

Why do manta rays keep their brains warm?
Mantas have retia mirabilia, “wonderful nets” of fine blood vessels in which warm and cold blood run side by side and exchange heat. In mantas these networks supply the brain and are thought to keep it warmer than the surrounding water. That matters because mantas are not just surface plankton feeders. Giant mantas fitted with transmitters have travelled as far as 1,000 km from where they were tagged and dived to at least 1,000 m; reef mantas (Mobula alfredi) have been recorded below 400 m; and the related Chilean devil ray, which has similar vascular anatomy, dives to nearly 2,000 m. Research on manta diets suggests that around 73% of what a giant manta eats comes from the mesopelagic, the dim twilight zone, rather than the surface.
Cold slows nerve signalling. A brain kept warm on a deep, cold dive can presumably keep processing sensory information, controlling movement and making decisions at something close to its normal speed. That fits the picture of mantas as alert, mobile foragers rather than passive drifters.
Can manta rays recognise themselves in a mirror?
Possibly, but the evidence is thin. In 2016 Csilla Ari and Dominic D’Agostino of the University of South Florida published a study in the Journal of Ethology titled “Contingency checking and self-directed behaviors in giant manta rays: do elasmobranchs have self-awareness?”. They worked with two giant oceanic mantas held at the Atlantis aquarium in the Bahamas, with support from the Save Our Seas Foundation, and compared how the rays behaved with a mirror in their tank, with a non-reflective control such as a whiteboard, and with nothing.
With the mirror present, the mantas became more active near it and performed unusual movements in front of it, including blowing bubbles and moving their fins in ways not typical of their normal swimming, then watching the reflection. When the mirror was removed, the behaviour reportedly decreased. The authors interpreted this as contingency checking: moving your own body and watching whether the image follows, a step that apes, dolphins and some birds go through before they recognise themselves. Press coverage summarised the finding as the rays reacting to their reflections rather than treating them as another animal.
The criticisms are substantial. Stewart and colleagues from the Manta Trust published a reply the same year, “Are mantas self aware or simply social?”, arguing that the behaviours described are also common during ordinary social interactions among wild mantas, so they may be the rays responding to what they perceive as another manta rather than to themselves. They called for more conclusive evidence and for work that combines captive and wild animals. Gordon Gallup Jr., the psychologist who devised the mirror test, cautioned that such studies usually rely on very small samples that are hard to reproduce. Without a mark test, and with two animals, the manta mirror result is best described as intriguing.
What is the mirror test, and why is it controversial?
The classic mirror self-recognition test, developed by Gallup, puts a mark on part of an animal’s body that it can only see in a mirror. If the animal looks in the mirror and then tries to touch or remove the mark on its own body, it is taken to understand that the reflection is itself. Conservative reviewers conclude that convincing evidence is still restricted to great apes, while others accept results from dolphins and a few other species.
Fish complicate the picture. In 2019 a Japanese team led by Kohda reported that the bluestreak cleaner wrasse (Labroides dimidiatus), a small reef fish, scraped at a brown mark on its throat after seeing it in a mirror. Critics argued that a fish that spends its life picking parasites off other fish might react to a parasite-like mark for reasons other than self-recognition. A 2022 follow-up in PLOS Biology found that all 14 newly tested wrasse scraped their throat when given a brown mark, but only when a mirror was present; blue and green marks did not trigger scraping, and seeing another fish with the same mark did not either. The debate continues, but it shows that small fish can produce mark-test results, which makes the absence of a mark test for mantas a real gap rather than a technicality.
A deeper problem is that the mirror test favours animals that rely heavily on vision and have hands, beaks or flexible bodies to touch a mark. A manta has no limbs to reach its own body and may perceive the world differently. Many researchers now treat mirror tests as one piece of evidence among several rather than a pass-fail exam for self-awareness.
| Animal | Mirror test result |
|---|---|
| Bottlenose dolphin | Passed (mark test) |
| Bluestreak cleaner wrasse | Passed mark test (2019, 2022; debated) |
| Giant manta ray | Contingency checking in 2 animals, no mark test |
| Octopus | Problem solving; mirror results mixed |
Do manta rays have good memories?
Field evidence points that way. Mantas visit cleaning stations on coral reefs, where small fish such as wrasse pick parasites and dead skin off them. A manta hangs almost motionless over the coral for several minutes while it is cleaned, and visits are most frequent at high tide. Individual mantas return to the same cleaning stations and feeding areas again and again, and researchers think they hold cognitive maps of their environment, mental representations of where useful places are and how to get between them.
Long-term photo-identification studies, which recognise individual mantas from their natural markings, support this. Off Maui, Hawaii, Mark Deakos and colleagues carried out 229 surveys at a manta aggregation site from 2005 to 2009 and identified 290 individual reef mantas. High resighting rates within and across years gave strong evidence of site fidelity, although animals moved in and out of the area and males tended to stay for shorter periods than females. The discovery curve never levelled off, so many more mantas use the area than the 290 identified. The same study found shark bite scars on 33% of the rays and an amputated or non-functional cephalic fin on 10%, a reminder that the reef is not a safe place to forget.
Returning to precise places over years, across a home range of many kilometres, is the kind of spatial memory that in mammals depends on large, well-organised forebrains. It does not prove anything about mantas’ inner lives, but it is consistent with a brain that is doing real work.
Are manta rays social?
More than they look. Mantas may travel alone or in groups of up to about 50, and they coordinate when feeding. One manta may “piggy-back” over another’s back; in chain feeding they line up head to tail; and chains can curl into a “cyclone” of up to 150 mantas spiralling upwards in a column about 15 m across for as long as an hour. Such manoeuvres need each animal to track the positions and movements of its neighbours.
Recent studies suggest that relationships are not random. A 2019 study by Perryman and colleagues, published in Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology, analysed social preferences and network structure in a population of reef mantas, and reef mantas have been shown to form associations with particular individuals and act together. Social intelligence, keeping track of who is who and who to associate with, is widely thought to be one of the main drivers of large brains in animals, and mantas may be a fish example. They also breach, sometimes in sequence within a group, and somersault, for reasons nobody has established; communication and shaking off parasites or remoras are among the suggestions.
| Behaviour | What it suggests |
|---|---|
| Returning to the same cleaning station for years | Long-term spatial memory |
| Mirror-directed movements and bubbles | Possible self-recognition (disputed) |
| Approaching divers and boats | Curiosity, learned associations |
| Cooperative chain and cyclone feeding | Social coordination |
Are manta rays curious about divers?
Many divers report that mantas circle back over a group again and again rather than simply swimming on, and photographers describe individual rays that seem to investigate bubbles and lights. That is anecdote rather than data, but it is consistent across many sites and fits the picture of an animal that investigates its surroundings. Mantas find food using both sight and smell, so a large, novel object in the water is worth checking. The change in human attitudes is itself recent: sailors once believed mantas were dangerous and could drag ships out to sea by the anchor, and only from around 1976, when divers in the Gulf of California found them placid and approachable, did manta encounters become a popular dive experience.
Night snorkels and dives off Kona, Hawaii, use lights to attract plankton, which in turn brings mantas in to feed; see the Kona manta night snorkel. Whether individual mantas learn to associate the lights with food, as many guides believe, has not been formally tested, but the regular return of known individuals fits the site fidelity seen elsewhere.
Why would a filter feeder need a big brain?
It seems odd that a fish that eats plankton would need more brain than a hunting shark. Ari’s comparative work framed brain size in mobulids in terms of their ecology, and several features of manta life plausibly demand it. Plankton is patchy and shifts with tides, currents, seasons and moon phases, so finding it efficiently across a large home range rewards memory and navigation. Mantas switch between surface feeding and deep foraging in the twilight zone, which demands rapid processing in very different light and temperature conditions. And their social and cleaning-station behaviour requires keeping track of places and other animals.
Mantas also have a slow life history, which is often linked with larger brains. Gestation is thought to last about 12–13 months, females usually have a single pup, and in the wild an interval of about two years between births may be normal. An animal that lives a long time, reproduces slowly and invests heavily in each offspring benefits from learning, because experience accumulates over many years.
How do mantas compare with other smart sea animals?
On problem solving and tool use, dolphins and octopuses still have the stronger record, backed by many controlled experiments. Dolphins pass the mark test, use signature whistles that work like names and cooperate in complex hunts; octopuses solve puzzles, open jars and escape enclosures. Mantas have nothing comparable yet, largely because they are very difficult to study: they are huge, live in open water, and only a few are kept in aquariums.
Among fish, though, mantas sit at the top for brain size, warm their brains and show behaviour consistent with long-term memory, sociality and curiosity. That makes them strong candidates for the most intelligent fish, with the caveat that “intelligence” in fish is still poorly measured. Their apparent curiosity also has economic value. Manta tourism has been estimated to generate more than 73 million US dollars a year in direct revenue and about 140 million a year for local economies, with most of it earned in ten countries including Japan, Indonesia, the Maldives, Mozambique and Mexico. One analysis put the value of a dead manta at 40 to 500 dollars, against about 1 million dollars in tourism over the lifetime of a manta at a popular dive site. Protections such as Indonesia’s 2014 ban on manta fishing and export, covering 5.8 million km² of ocean, reflect a growing view that a living manta is worth far more than a dead one.
Are manta rays smart?
Probably the smartest fish known. They have the largest brain of any fish and behaviour consistent with long-term memory, social coordination and curiosity, though their intelligence has not been formally measured.
Do manta rays pass the mirror test?
Not formally. Two captive mantas showed contingency checking in a 2016 study, but no mark test was done and other researchers argue the behaviour may be social.
How big is a manta ray brain?
Up to about 200 g in the giant oceanic manta, five to ten times heavier than a whale shark’s brain.
Are manta rays smarter than sharks?
Their brain-to-body ratio is higher than that of any shark, but intelligence has not been compared directly in experiments.
Do manta rays remember people?
There is no study showing they recognise individual people, but they return to the same cleaning stations and feeding sites for years.
Why do manta rays approach divers?
Curiosity, and at some sites the plankton concentrated by lights, are the likely reasons.
Are manta rays self-aware?
Possibly. The evidence is suggestive, based on two captive animals, and disputed.
Why do manta rays warm their brains?
Networks of blood vessels called retia mirabilia are thought to keep the brain warm during deep dives into cold water, below 1,000 m in giant mantas.
- Ari, C. & D’Agostino, D.P. (2016). Contingency checking and self-directed behaviors in giant manta rays: do elasmobranchs have self-awareness? Journal of Ethology. doi:10.1007/s10164-016-0462-z
- Stewart, J.D., Stevens, G.M.W., Marshall, G.J. & Abernathy, K. (2016). Are mantas self aware or simply social? A response to Ari and D’Agostino 2016. doi:10.1007/s10164-016-0491-7
- Ari, C. (2011). Encephalization and brain organization of mobulid rays (Myliobatiformes, Elasmobranchii) with ecological perspectives. The Open Anatomy Journal 3. doi:10.2174/1877609401103010001
- Deakos, M.H., Baker, J.D. & Bejder, L. (2011). Characteristics of a manta ray Manta alfredi population off Maui, Hawaii, and implications for management. Marine Ecology Progress Series 429: 245–260.
- Perryman et al. (2019). Social preferences and network structure in a population of reef manta rays. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology. doi:10.1007/s00265-019-2720-x
- Kohda, M. et al. (2022). Further evidence for the capacity of mirror self-recognition in cleaner fish. PLOS Biology. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.3001529
- Wikipedia: Manta ray; Giant oceanic manta ray (accessed via offline mirror).
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.
About Blane Perun →