Difference Between Squid and Octopus — A Practical Identification Guide
The fastest way to tell them apart: count the limbs and look at the body shape. A squid has 10 limbs (8 arms + 2 longer tentacles with clubbed tips) and a torpedo-shaped body with fins. An octopus has 8 arms only (all the same type, no tentacles) and a soft rounded body with no fins. If you see fins — it’s a squid. If you see a saggy round head with 8 matching arms dangling below — it’s an octopus. Other giveaways: squid are almost always in open water or schooling; octopuses are usually on or near the seafloor, often in a den. Squid eyes tend to be wedge-shaped; octopus eyes are horizontal rectangles. This guide walks through every practical identification feature.
Whether you’re diving, snorkelling, watching a nature documentary, browsing a seafood market, or trying to ID what you’re about to eat at a restaurant, being able to distinguish squid from octopus is a useful skill. The two groups look different enough that with a few cues, identification is straightforward — even for casual observers. This guide runs through the identification features in order of usefulness, starting with the most obvious and working down to subtler details for trickier cases.
Tell 1 — count the limbs
The single most reliable identifier is limb count, but only if you can see all the limbs clearly. A squid has 10, an octopus has 8.
A squid has 8 arms plus 2 longer tentacles, for 10 total. The 8 arms are all roughly the same length and form a cluster around the beak. The 2 tentacles are distinctly longer, usually extending well beyond the arms, with specialised clubs at their tips carrying larger suckers or hooks. When the squid isn’t actively hunting, these tentacles often retract partially between the arms, making it easier to see the distinction between short arms and long tentacles.
An octopus has 8 arms, all the same type. No tentacles. All eight limbs are the same kind — uniform in structure, lined with suckers from base to tip. When you count them, you’ll find exactly eight with no longer ones protruding. If an octopus seems to have more than eight limbs, you’re likely seeing arms twisted or tangled, not actual extra limbs.
Counting isn’t always easy — limbs get tangled, obscured, or hidden behind the body. But when you can count them, the number is diagnostic. 10 means squid. 8 means octopus.

Tell 2 — body shape and fins
If you can’t count limbs clearly, look at the body. Squid and octopus have distinctive body shapes that give them away immediately.
A squid has a torpedo-shaped or arrow-shaped body, pointed at one end, wider near the head. Running along the sides or at the rear are fins — visible flaps that undulate for slow swimming or are held steady during fast jetting. Some squid species have fins that wrap around most of the body (like the bigfin squid); some have small rear fins that form a sharp arrowhead; some have side fins that run most of the length of the mantle. In every case, fins are present and visible.
An octopus has a soft, rounded, bulbous body with no fins. The body looks somewhat like a bag or balloon with arms attached. No streamlining, no rigid shape, no fin flaps. When an octopus is resting, the body can look almost spherical or slightly elongated; when it’s moving, the body deforms freely because there’s no internal shell or rigid structure. Imagine a sock puppet with eight dangling strings — that’s an octopus body plan.
If you see fins, you’re looking at a squid. If you see a fin-less rounded body, you’re looking at an octopus. This alone is diagnostic in most casual identification situations.
Tell 3 — where they are and how they move
If you’re watching the animal in its natural environment (diving, snorkelling, or watching footage), where it is and how it moves is a reliable identifier.
Squid are almost always in the water column — swimming freely in open water, at various depths depending on species, often in schools or small groups. They move primarily by jet propulsion, which looks like smooth, fast, directional swimming with the body pointing in the direction of travel (often tail-first when jetting away from a threat). Fins may undulate gently for low-speed cruising. You’ll rarely see a squid just sitting still on the seafloor — they’re open-water creatures.
Octopuses are usually on or near the seafloor. You’ll often see them crawling across rocks or sand, squeezing through gaps, or hiding in a den. When they swim, it’s typically in short bursts — a brief jet followed by settling back to the bottom. Most dive encounters with octopus happen because the octopus was found in its den, not because it was swimming past. Octopus movement looks deliberate, exploratory, crawling — very different from squid’s smooth open-water cruising.
Behaviour is a useful tell: if it’s swimming freely in the water column and you can’t see what’s below, assume squid. If it’s crawling on the seafloor or peeking out of a den, assume octopus.
Tell 4 — at the market or on your plate
For seafood shoppers and diners, telling squid from octopus at a market or on a plate is usually straightforward if you know what to look for.
Whole squid at a market have a pointed, torpedo-shaped body with fins still attached near the pointed end. The 10 limbs are visible at the head — 8 shorter arms and 2 longer tentacles (the longer ones may be folded against the head). Whole squid look streamlined and organised, with distinctive shape.
Whole octopus at a market have a rounded, saggy body with no fins, and 8 uniform arms dangling from the head. Octopuses often look larger and lumpier than squid of similar weight because the body isn’t streamlined. The 8 arms typically extend much longer than the body length — the arms are the main visible feature.
On a plate, the distinction is also visible: calamari rings (the classic fried or grilled preparation) are thin cross-sections of squid mantle — firm, uniform rings. Octopus is almost always served as whole arm pieces, chunks of tentacle meat, or occasionally as whole small octopus — chewier texture, more complex shapes. If you’re ordering calamari and it arrives as uniform rings, you’re eating squid; if it arrives as suckered arm pieces, you’re eating octopus.
Tell 5 — eyes and skin for the close observer
For the curious observer looking at a live or freshly-dead specimen up close, eyes and skin texture offer additional identification cues.
Pupil shape differs. Squid typically have wedge-shaped pupils — sometimes described as triangular or D-shaped, varying by species. Octopus pupils are horizontal rectangles or bar-shaped — long, narrow, and oriented horizontally across the eye. These shapes are visible in close-up images and in careful live observation. The difference has to do with how light is gathered and how each species judges depth and direction.
Skin texture also differs. Squid skin tends to be smooth and relatively uniform, with chromatophore colour changes happening mostly as simple patterns. Octopus skin can be highly textured, with the ability to raise papillae (bumps) to mimic rocks, coral, or sand — true 3D texture change, not just colour change. If you see an animal with extensive bumpy, rock-like textured skin, it’s almost certainly an octopus.
These subtler identifications are useful when the limb count and body shape cues aren’t clear — for example, in close-up photos where the whole body isn’t visible.
What’s the difference between a squid and an octopus?
Squid have 10 limbs (8 arms + 2 longer tentacles), a torpedo-shaped body with fins, and live in open water. Octopuses have 8 arms only (all the same type, no tentacles), a soft rounded body with no fins, and live on or near the seafloor. Squid jet-swim fast; octopuses crawl and briefly jet. Squid pupils are wedge-shaped; octopus pupils are horizontal rectangles. Both share cephalopod features (beak, ink, three hearts, blue blood, camera eyes), but they’re different orders that diverged 270+ million years ago.
How can I quickly tell a squid from an octopus?
Two quick checks: (1) count the limbs — 10 means squid, 8 means octopus; (2) look for fins — if the body has visible fins, it’s a squid; if the body is rounded and fin-less, it’s an octopus. These two checks together will correctly identify squid vs octopus in almost every situation. Where and how the animal is moving (open water vs seafloor) is a reliable third check.
Is calamari squid or octopus?
Calamari is technically squid. The word “calamari” is the Italian plural for “calamaro” (squid), and in most culinary contexts refers specifically to squid. Fried calamari rings are made from squid mantle cross-sections. However, in some regions and some cheaper preparations, the name is used more loosely and may sometimes include octopus. Traditionally and correctly, calamari means squid.
Which is bigger, squid or octopus?
Squid holds the records for largest cephalopods. The colossal squid (up to 10 m, up to 500 kg) is the largest invertebrate ever documented. The giant squid is also massive (up to 13 m total length including tentacles). The largest octopus is the giant Pacific octopus, typically 3–4 m armspan, 50 kg — large but clearly smaller than giant or colossal squid. So at the largest sizes, squid beats octopus significantly.
Can you eat both squid and octopus?
Yes, both are consumed globally as seafood. Squid is more commonly eaten worldwide (calamari is one of the most popular seafood dishes), typically prepared by frying, grilling, or quickly cooking to preserve tender texture. Octopus is eaten extensively in Mediterranean, East Asian, and Latin American cuisines, typically prepared by slow braising or simmering to tenderise the denser meat. Both are healthy protein sources; both have distinctive textures.
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.
About Blane Perun → More Squid Q&A →