Zoanthus pacificus — Hawaii’s Zoanthid With a Question Mark Over Its Name
Zoanthus pacificus is a zoanthid described from Hawaii in 1971 by Gordon Walsh and Richard Bowers, in the same review of Hawaiian zoanthids that named the notorious Palythoa toxica. Today the World Register of Marine Species lists it as a taxon inquirendum: a name whose real identity needs further study. It may be a local form of a widespread Indo-Pacific species rather than a species of its own.
That makes this a page about a name as much as an animal. If you are trying to identify a green or brown zoa on a Hawaiian reef flat, here is what the name means and what you are probably looking at.
What does taxon inquirendum mean?
It is a formal flag that a species name is doubtful. Usually the original description is too short, the type specimens are lost or unclear, or the features used to define the species overlap with other species. For zoanthids the problem is common, because colour, polyp size and tentacle count change with light, depth and water movement. Modern descriptions rely on DNA as well as anatomy; Walsh and Bowers worked before that was possible.

Why are there two Zoanthus pacificus?
Confusingly, the zoologists Pax and Müller also used the name Zoanthus pacificus in 1957, for different material. That earlier name is now treated as a synonym of Zoanthus sansibaricus, the common Indo-Pacific zoa. Walsh and Bowers’ Hawaiian Z. pacificus is a separate name. Two scientists choosing the same name for different animals creates a homonym, one more reason the name is under review.
| Name | Author | Current status |
|---|---|---|
| Z. pacificus | Walsh & Bowers, 1971 (Hawaii) | Taxon inquirendum |
| Z. pacificus | Pax & Müller, 1957 | Synonym of Z. sansibaricus |
| Z. sansibaricus | Carlgren, 1900 | Accepted, Indo-Pacific |
What does it look like?
Hawaiian Zoanthus colonies are mats of smooth, sand-free polyps on short stalks joined by stolons, with green, brown or blue-green oral discs and short marginal tentacles. They are smaller and smoother than Hawaiian palys such as Palythoa tuberculosa, whose polyps are sunk in a gritty, rubbery mat.
Where does it live?
On intertidal rock, tide pools and shallow reef flats in the Hawaiian Islands, in the same kind of habitat where Walsh and Bowers found P. toxica. Hawaii has a small zoanthid fauna compared with the western Pacific, but zoas and palys are conspicuous on wave-washed benches and reef flats. See coral reefs of Hawaii.
What are you probably looking at in Hawaii?
On current evidence, a green or brown zoa on a Hawaiian reef flat is best called Zoanthus sp. Molecular studies across the Pacific have repeatedly found that many locally named Zoanthus belong to a few widespread species such as Z. sansibaricus and Z. kuroshio, and that some may hybridise. Until the Hawaiian material is studied with DNA, “Z. pacificus” is a label, not a settled species.
Who were Walsh and Bowers?
Gordon Walsh and Richard Bowers reviewed the zoanthids of the Hawaiian Islands in 1971, at the same time as University of Hawaii chemists were isolating palytoxin. Their paper described three new species, including Palythoa toxica, identified at last as the animal behind the legend of limu-make-o-Hana. That context matters: their work was driven partly by the hunt for the source of the toxin, and Hawaiian zoanthids have been studied by chemists far more than by taxonomists ever since.
Could Hawaii have its own Zoanthus?
It is not an unreasonable idea. The Hawaiian Islands are among the most isolated island groups on Earth, and their marine life shows it. Surveys of shallow reefs in the Northwestern Hawaiian Islands have found that around a fifth of the reef fish species are endemic, found nowhere else. On deeper, mesophotic reefs, between about 30 and 90 metres, a 2014 study in the Bulletin of Marine Science by Kane, Kosaki and Wagner found that about 46% of the reef fishes encountered were Hawaiian endemics, nearly twice the rate known from any other tropical region, rising to as high as 92% at the northern end of the chain.
With so many unique fishes, it would not be surprising if Hawaii also had a few unique invertebrates, and Walsh and Bowers clearly thought that their Hawaiian Zoanthus deserved a name of its own. The difficulty is that zoanthids are not fishes. Their larvae can drift for weeks, colonies can raft on floating debris, and the main zoanthid species of the Pacific turn out to be remarkably widespread. A shallow-water zoanthid in Hawaii is just as likely to belong to a species that also lives in Japan or the South Pacific as to be a Hawaiian original.
That is why the question can only be settled by comparing Hawaiian colonies directly with those from elsewhere. Until that is done, both possibilities remain open, and the cautious label Zoanthus sp. is the honest one. Field guides and online identification sites that give a confident species name for every green zoa on a Hawaiian bench are, in effect, guessing. A good record says what was seen, where and when, and leaves the final name to specialists working with DNA.
How was Japan’s Zoanthus sorted out?
The best model for what needs to happen in Hawaii comes from southern Japan. In 2006, James Davis Reimer and colleagues published a combined morphological and molecular revision of Zoanthus from south-western Japan in Zoological Science. They compared the shape and internal anatomy of many colonies with their DNA sequences, and they found that the variety of colours and forms on Japanese shores belonged to a small number of species. In the same paper they described two species new to science, one of them Zoanthus kuroshio, whose name refers to the Kuroshio, the warm current that sweeps north past the Ryukyu Islands and the Japanese mainland.
The revision showed that many traits long used to tell zoas apart, especially colour, are unreliable. Colonies of the same species could look quite different from one rock pool to the next, while colonies of different species could look almost the same. Features such as the number of tentacles, the arrangement of internal muscles and the structure of the polyp wall, combined with DNA markers, gave a much clearer picture.
A year later, a further study by Reimer and colleagues reported molecular evidence suggesting that some Zoanthus species can hybridise. If species can exchange genes, then the boundaries between them are softer than a neat list of names suggests, and some colonies will be genuinely intermediate. For anyone trying to decide whether Hawaii’s zoas are a separate species, this is an important caution: a few small genetic differences might reflect local variation or past hybridisation rather than a distinct species.
What anchors a species name?
Every animal species name is tied to a physical specimen, or a small set of them, called the type material. Usually one specimen is designated the holotype, the reference point for the name. If later researchers are unsure what a name means, they go back to the type and compare it with their own material. This system, governed by the International Code of Zoological Nomenclature, is what allows a name coined in 1818 or 1971 to be applied consistently today.
For soft-bodied animals like zoanthids, type material is often a problem. Preserved polyps shrink and lose their colour, internal features can be damaged, and older specimens are rarely suitable for DNA. Some types have been lost entirely. When a name cannot be pinned to a recognisable animal, it ends up in limbo, flagged as a taxon inquirendum, just as Zoanthus pacificus has been.
There are ways out. If a type is lost, specialists can designate a new reference specimen, called a neotype, from the original area, provided they can show it matches the original description. Alternatively, if the Hawaiian animals prove to belong to an older, widespread species, Z. pacificus Walsh & Bowers would become a synonym of that older name. Either way, the decision requires fresh specimens, careful comparison and publication in the scientific literature.
Can you collect zoas in Hawaii?
Hawaii has been at the centre of a long legal and political argument over aquarium collecting. In 2017 the Hawai‘i Supreme Court ruled that commercial aquarium collection must undergo environmental review under the state’s Environmental Policy Act, and commercial collecting stopped while that process ran. An environmental impact statement for West Hawai‘i was later upheld by the same court in 2024, but permits still had to be issued under new rules, and as of late 2025 commercial aquarium collection remained illegal across the state while that rulemaking continued.
The debate has centred on fishes such as the yellow tang rather than on zoanthids, but it matters for anyone tempted to take a colony home from a Hawaiian tide pool. Collection rules, protected areas and permit requirements change, so check the current regulations of the Hawai‘i Department of Land and Natural Resources before taking anything from the shore. In practice, the safest approach for visitors is to take photographs only.
There is also a biosecurity side. Moving living rock and invertebrates between islands, or from aquariums back into the sea, can spread pests and diseases. Hawaii has already had to deal with a non-native zoanthid that was traced to an aquarium release, a reminder that the rule “never release aquarium animals or rock into the sea” applies everywhere.
How to look at zoas on a Hawaiian shore
Hawaii’s wave-washed benches and shallow reef flats are good places to see zoanthids in the wild. Visit at low tide on a calm day, and watch the waves: Hawaiian shorebreak and sudden sets are a real danger on exposed rocks. Wear sturdy footwear, but step on bare rock or sand rather than on living animals. Zoas usually sit in the lower parts of tide pools and on the edges of benches that stay wet.
Look for mats of smooth green, brown or blue-green polyps joined by runners. Next to them you may find gritty, rubbery Palythoa mats, which are far more toxic and should never be touched. A photograph of an open colony from above, with something for scale, plus the location and date, is the most useful record if you want help with identification or wish to contribute to biodiversity platforms.
How would scientists settle the question?
By collecting fresh Zoanthus from the original Hawaiian localities, sequencing standard genetic markers such as mitochondrial COI and 16S and nuclear ITS, and comparing them with specimens of Z. sansibaricus, Z. kuroshio and other Pacific species. If the Hawaiian animals fall inside one of those species, Z. pacificus becomes a synonym. If they form their own branch, the name could be revived with a modern description.
How do zoanthids reach remote islands?
For a sessile animal, crossing thousands of kilometres of open ocean seems impossible, yet zoanthids, corals and many other bottom-dwellers have reached every remote island group in the tropics. There are two main routes. The first is as larvae, which drift in the plankton for days to weeks and can be carried long distances by currents before they settle. The second is rafting: adult colonies attached to floating objects such as logs, pumice or seaweed can survive long voyages and colonise a new shore when the raft runs aground.
A striking modern demonstration of rafting came after the tsunami that followed the great earthquake off Japan on 11 March 2011. Over the following years, debris from the Japanese coast, including docks, boats and buoys, washed up in Hawaii and along the west coast of North America. A team led by James Carlton of Williams College examined more than 600 pieces of this debris and, in a paper in Science in 2017, reported 289 living species of invertebrates and fishes that had survived the crossing, most of them coastal Japanese animals.
Plastic and other modern debris last far longer than natural rafts, so they may now be carrying more hitchhikers across oceans than ever before. For a remote archipelago like Hawaii, every new arrival is a possible invader. This is one more reason why the relationships of Hawaiian zoanthids to those of Japan and the wider Pacific are worth working out: knowing what is native helps conservation managers recognise what is new.
Is it toxic?
Zoanthus usually tests much lower in palytoxin than Palythoa, but zoanthids vary. On a Hawaiian reef, especially one where P. toxica or P. tuberculosa grows, look but do not touch.
Can you keep it in an aquarium?
Hawaiian zoanthids are not normally collected for the trade, and Hawaii regulates aquarium collecting. Care for any Zoanthus is the same: moderate light and flow, stable water and space. See our zoanthid care guide.
What is Zoanthus pacificus?
A Hawaiian zoanthid described by Walsh and Bowers in 1971 whose identity is now considered doubtful.
What does taxon inquirendum mean?
A species name of uncertain identity that needs further study.
Is Zoanthus pacificus the same as Zoanthus sansibaricus?
The 1957 Pax and Müller Z. pacificus is a synonym of Z. sansibaricus; the 1971 Hawaiian name is still under review.
Where is Zoanthus pacificus found?
It was described from the Hawaiian Islands, on shallow rock and reef flats.
Who described Zoanthus pacificus?
Gordon Walsh and Richard Bowers, in 1971.
Is Zoanthus pacificus toxic?
Zoanthus is usually far less toxic than Palythoa, but do not touch zoanthids with bare skin.
Can I buy Zoanthus pacificus?
Not under that name in normal trade; Hawaiian zoas are rarely exported.
- WoRMS: Zoanthus pacificus Walsh & Bowers, 1971 (taxon inquirendum).
- Walsh, G.E. & Bowers, R.L. (1971). A review of Hawaiian zoanthids with descriptions of three new species. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 50: 161–180.
- Wikipedia: Zoanthus sansibaricus (synonyms).
- Reimer, J.D. et al. (2007). Molecular evidence suggesting interspecific hybridization in Zoanthus spp. Zoological Science 24(4).
- Kane, C., Kosaki, R.K. & Wagner, D. (2014). High levels of mesophotic reef fish endemism in the Northwestern Hawaiian Islands. Bulletin of Marine Science.
- Reimer, J.D. et al. (2006). Morphological and molecular revision of Zoanthus from southwestern Japan, with descriptions of two new species. Zoological Science 23(3): 261–275.
- Carlton, J.T. et al. (2017). Tsunami-driven rafting: transoceanic species dispersal and implications for marine biogeography. Science.
- Earthjustice: The latest on commercial aquarium collection in Hawai‘i (updated November 2025).
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.
About Blane Perun →