Treasure of the Empress of Ireland — Canada’s Titanic and Its Silver Bars
Silver bullion and mail. Weeks after the Canadian Pacific liner Empress of Ireland sank in the St Lawrence River on May 29, 1914, salvors recovered 212 silver bars (valued at about $150,000 in 1914, though older accounts say $1,099,000), 318 bags of mail and the purser’s safe, cutting through the hull to reach them. The disaster killed 1,012 of 1,477 aboard in about 14 minutes, more passengers than died on the Titanic.
Canada’s worst peacetime maritime disaster is often called the forgotten Titanic. The Canadian Pacific liner Empress of Ireland went down in the St Lawrence in about 14 minutes, killing more passengers than the Titanic had two years earlier. Her silver cargo was salvaged within weeks, but the wreck has kept drawing divers, collectors and historians ever since, and it is now one of the most strictly protected underwater sites in Canada. This page tells the story of the ship, the sinking, the 1914 salvage of her bullion, mail and safe, and what has happened to the wreck since.
What kind of ship was the Empress of Ireland?
The Empress of Ireland was a twin-screw ocean liner built for the Canadian Pacific Railway by the Fairfield Shipbuilding and Engineering Company at Govan on the Clyde. She was launched on 27 January 1906 and sailed on her maiden voyage on 29 June 1906, a few weeks after her sister ship, Empress of Britain. At 14,191 gross tons and about 570 ft (174 m) long, with quadruple-expansion steam engines driving two propellers, she could make about 18 knots and carried around 1,580 passengers and crew.
She was built for one route: Liverpool to Canada. From May to October she ran up the St Lawrence to Quebec City; in winter, when the river iced over, she used Halifax and Saint John instead. Over eight years of crossings she carried 119,262 passengers westbound and 67,838 eastbound. Many of the westbound travellers were emigrants in third class, heading for new lives in Canada, which is why the ship mattered so much to the country and why her loss was felt so widely.
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 27 Jan 1906 | Launched at Fairfield, Govan, on the Clyde |
| 29 Jun 1906 | Maiden voyage, Liverpool to Quebec |
| 28 May 1914 | Leaves Quebec City for Liverpool with 1,477 aboard |
| 29 May 1914, 01:56 | Struck by the collier Storstad in fog off Pointe-au-Père |
| 29 May 1914, 02:10 | Sinks about 14 minutes after the collision |
| 16 Jun 1914 | Commission of Inquiry under Lord Mersey opens in Quebec |
| Summer 1914 | Salvors recover mail, the purser’s safe and 212 silver bars; diver Edward Cossaboom dies |
| 1964 | Wreck relocated by divers; a brass bell is raised |
| 1999 | Protected under Quebec’s Cultural Property Act |
| 2009 | Declared a National Historic Site of Canada |
| 2014 | Centenary exhibitions, stamps and coins |

How did the Empress of Ireland sink?
On the afternoon of 28 May 1914 the Empress left Quebec City for Liverpool with 1,477 people aboard: 420 crew and 1,057 passengers. In command was Henry George Kendall, promoted to captain only that month; it was his first trip down the St Lawrence in charge of the ship. At about 1:30 a.m. she dropped her pilot at Father Point (Pointe-au-Père), near Rimouski, and headed out into the widening river.
Coming the other way was the Norwegian collier Storstad, under Captain Thomas Andersen, with Chief Officer Alfred Toftenes on watch. At 1:56 a.m., in thick fog, the Storstad’s bow struck the Empress on her starboard side near midships. The current swung the collier away within seconds, opening the wound, and water poured in at an estimated 270,000 litres a second.
The liner heeled over to starboard almost at once. The list made it impossible to launch the lifeboats on the port side, and of the starboard boats only five got away safely; two more capsized as they were being lowered. The ship had more than enough lifeboats for everyone aboard, a lesson learned from the Titanic, but there was simply no time to use them. Many passengers, especially in the lower decks, never reached the open air. At 2:10 a.m., about 14 minutes after the collision, the Empress of Ireland rolled onto her side and sank.
How many people died on the Empress of Ireland?
The usual figure is 1,012 dead and 465 survivors, although early counts differed slightly; the inquiry opened with 1,014 lost and 463 saved, “subject to correction,” and some secondary sources give totals as high as 1,073. Among passengers the toll was 840 dead, more than died among the Titanic’s passengers. Survival was far higher among crew, who were awake and on deck, than among passengers asleep in their cabins.
| Group | Aboard | Died | Survived |
|---|---|---|---|
| First class | 87 | 51 | 36 |
| Second class | 253 | 205 | 48 |
| Third class | 717 | 584 | 133 |
| All passengers | 1,057 | 840 | 217 |
| Crew | 420 | 172 | 248 |
| Children (included above) | 138 | 134 | 4 |
| Total | 1,477 | 1,012 | 465 |
The numbers tell a story that differs from the Titanic’s. On the Titanic, women and children were loaded into the boats first and survived at far higher rates than men. On the Empress, there was no time for any such order. Only 41 of the 310 women aboard survived, against 172 of the 609 men, and the survival rate in first class, about 41 per cent, was more than double that in second (19 per cent) and third class (18.5 per cent). Crew members, 59 per cent of whom survived, did best, largely because many were on duty and awake when the ship was struck. Location on the ship, and whether a person was asleep, decided who lived far more than any rule of the sea.
Children fared worst of all. Of 138 children aboard, only four survived: three girls and one boy. One of them, Grace Hanagan, was seven years old; she lived until 1995 and was the last known survivor of the disaster. Another large group lost that night belonged to the Salvation Army, whose Canadian delegation of about 170 people (sources give 167 or 170) was travelling to an international congress in London. All but eight members of its Canadian Staff Band died.
Rescue came from small vessels based nearby. The Eureka reached the scene at 3:10 a.m. and picked up about 150 people. The Lady Evelyn arrived at 3:45 a.m., took about 200 survivors off the damaged Storstad, whose crew had pulled people from the water, and recovered 133 bodies. Kendall himself was thrown into the river, pulled into a lifeboat and spent the rest of the night directing rescue work. More bodies than survivors were eventually brought ashore at Rimouski.
Who was blamed for the collision?
A Canadian Commission of Inquiry opened in Quebec on 16 June 1914, presided over by Lord Mersey, who had chaired the British inquiry into the Titanic two years earlier, with Sir Adolphe-Basile Routhier and Ezekiel McLeod as fellow commissioners. Over eleven days it heard 61 witnesses, and the central question was which ship had changed course in the fog.
The commissioners found that the Storstad had altered course to starboard in the fog and caused the collision, and they singled out Chief Officer Toftenes for changing course negligently and failing to call his captain. A separate Norwegian inquiry reached the opposite conclusion, clearing the Storstad’s crew and blaming Kendall for not passing port to port. Andersen called Mersey a fool. In the courts, Canadian Pacific won a claim of C$2 million against the collier’s owners, A. F. Klaveness & Co., whose counterclaim of $50,000 failed. The Storstad was seized and sold for $175,000. She did not survive the First World War: a German submarine sank her in March 1917.
What was the Captain Kendall and Dr Crippen connection?
Kendall was already famous before the Empress sank. In 1910, as master of the Canadian Pacific steamer Montrose, he recognised two passengers as the fugitive Dr Hawley Harvey Crippen, wanted in London for the murder of his wife, and his mistress travelling in disguise. Kendall alerted the authorities by wireless, and Crippen was arrested and later hanged. The use of shipboard radio to catch a fugitive made the case, and Kendall, famous. Four years later the same captain stood on a sinking ship in the same river, and the press could not resist the connection.

What treasure was found on the Empress of Ireland?
The ship was not a treasure galleon, but she was carrying valuable cargo. Within weeks of the sinking, Canadian Pacific sent salvage divers to the wreck, which lay on its side in roughly 40 m of cold, dark water. Hard-hat divers cut into the hull to reach the purser’s safe, the mail and the silver. They recovered 318 bags of mail and 212 bars of silver bullion, together with the safe.
Accounts disagree on what the silver was worth. Many older histories, and earlier versions of this page, give a 1914 value of $1,099,000. More recent sources, including Wikipedia and reporting by the CBC, give a figure of about $150,000 in 1914 money, and the Maritime Executive describes the haul as worth roughly $1.1 million in today’s terms, which may be the source of the larger number. The weight of evidence favours a 1914 value in the region of $150,000, but the record is not clean, and readers should treat any single figure with caution.
The salvage had a human cost. A diver named Edward Cossaboom died during the work when he apparently slipped from the hull and fell about 20 m to the riverbed; his air hose had been closed or ruptured, and he could not be revived. He was the first of many divers to die on the wreck. The salvage also took a toll on the ship itself, since large openings were cut in her side to reach the cargo.
A remarkable record of the operation surfaced only recently. In 2021 the Montreal historian David Saint-Pierre bought an album of photographs taken by the salvor Ralph Stratton Blydenburgh after a friend spotted two mislabelled prints on an auction site. The images, published in Saint-Pierre’s book In the Wake of the Empress of Ireland, show international dive teams, primitive lifting gear, recovered silver bars and mail that the salvors were careful to keep legible.
What happened to the wreck after 1914?
Once the salvage was over, the exact position of the wreck was lost, and it was not found again until 1964, when Canadian divers relocated it and raised a brass bell. Through the 1970s divers removed many more objects, including a stern telemeter, parts of the Marconi radio room, a brass porthole and a compass. China, silverware, jewellery, pocket watches, navigational instruments and a fog bell weighing about 200 kg ended up in private hands. Robert Ballard, who found the Titanic, later complained that treasure hunters were still stripping fixtures and artefacts from the Empress.
That era ended with legal protection. In 1999 the wreck was declared a site of historical and archaeological importance under Quebec’s Cultural Property Act, the first underwater site in the province to receive that status, which made it illegal to remove anything without a permit. In 2009 it was designated a National Historic Site of Canada. Parks Canada underwater archaeologists, led by Charles Dagneau, have since carried out what was described as the first scientific study of the wreck, focusing on the rudder, which some believed had malfunctioned and for which no plans or drawings survive.
Can you dive the Empress of Ireland?
Yes, but it is a serious technical dive. Unlike the Titanic, which can only be reached by submersible, the Empress lies within reach of scuba divers, at roughly 40 to 45 m depending on the part of the wreck and the source. That accessibility is also the danger. The St Lawrence is cold even in summer, visibility is often poor, tidal currents are strong, and the hull is slowly collapsing. By 2009 six recreational divers had died on the wreck, most of them on dives that went inside the ship.
Today the site is protected, and divers must follow the rules of the provincial and federal designations: look, photograph and leave everything in place. Anyone planning a dive should go with local operators who know the tides and the site. For most visitors the better way to see the Empress is ashore, in the museums that now hold her artefacts.
Where can you see Empress of Ireland artefacts?
The main collection on the St Lawrence is at the Empress of Ireland Pavilion of the Site historique maritime de la Pointe-au-Père in Rimouski, close to where the ship went down. The Canadian Museum of History acquired a major private collection of artefacts and documents, which its curator called the single most important 20th-century acquisition the museum had made, and staged the exhibition Empress of Ireland: Canada’s Titanic for the centenary in 2014. The exhibition moved to the Canadian Museum of Immigration at Pier 21 in Halifax in 2015, a fitting home for a ship that carried so many immigrants to Canada.
The centenary in May 2014 also brought two commemorative stamps from Canada Post and coins from the Royal Canadian Mint, along with commemorations in Quebec and elsewhere in Canada. For a disaster that was quickly overshadowed by the outbreak of the First World War only weeks later, the attention was overdue.
Why is the Empress of Ireland called the forgotten Titanic?
Timing is the main reason. The Empress sank on 29 May 1914; a month later Archduke Franz Ferdinand was assassinated in Sarajevo, and by August Europe was at war. The story of a liner lost in a Canadian river could not compete with the war news. There was also no celebrity passenger list to match the Titanic’s, and the ship sank so quickly that there were few of the drawn-out scenes of heroism that made the Titanic legendary.
Yet in some ways the Empress is the more instructive disaster. She had enough lifeboats, a wireless set (call sign MPL) and an experienced crew, and none of it was enough against a collision that let water in faster than any ship of the time could survive. The disaster is often credited with influencing later thinking on bow design, and it showed that safety at sea depended as much on collision avoidance in fog and on watertight subdivision as on the number of boats. For other wrecks whose cargo drew salvors, see our shipwreck treasure section and the story of the RMS Titanic.

What treasure was on the Empress of Ireland?
212 silver bars, salvaged in 1914 with the purser’s safe and 318 bags of mail. Sources value the silver at about $150,000 in 1914; older accounts give $1,099,000.
How many people died on the Empress of Ireland?
About 1,012 of the 1,477 aboard; 840 of them were passengers and 134 of the 138 children aboard died.
How fast did the Empress of Ireland sink?
In about 14 minutes, from the collision at 1:56 a.m. to the sinking at 2:10 a.m. on 29 May 1914.
What ship hit the Empress of Ireland?
The Norwegian collier Storstad, in thick fog.
Who was blamed for the sinking?
Lord Mersey’s Canadian inquiry blamed the Storstad’s chief officer; a Norwegian inquiry blamed Captain Kendall of the Empress.
Where is the Empress of Ireland wreck?
In the St Lawrence off Pointe-au-Père, near Rimouski, Quebec, at roughly 40–45 m.
Can you dive the Empress of Ireland?
Experienced technical divers can, but it is cold, dark and current-swept, and divers have died there. The site is protected and nothing may be removed.
Is the Empress of Ireland a protected site?
Yes. It was protected under Quebec’s Cultural Property Act in 1999 and named a National Historic Site of Canada in 2009.
- Commission of Inquiry into the loss of the Empress of Ireland, Quebec, 1914 (proceedings, via titanicinquiry.org).
- Wikipedia: Sinking of the RMS Empress of Ireland and RMS Empress of Ireland (casualty tables, inquiry, salvage, protection; accessed November 2026).
- MaritimeQuest: Empress of Ireland (1906) ship data, casualties and Captain Kendall.
- CBC News: Parks Canada’s first scientific study of the Empress of Ireland wreck.
- Canadian Museum of History: Treasures from the Empress of Ireland.
- Nautilus International: review of David Saint-Pierre, In the Wake of the Empress of Ireland (History Press, 2025).
- The Maritime Executive: This day in maritime history, Empress of Ireland sinks.
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.
About Blane Perun → More on Shipwreck Treasure →