Nautilus moretoni — Willey’s 1896 New Guinea Variety
Nautilus moretoni is not a species you will find in a modern field guide. It is a name, coined in 1896 by the British zoologist Arthur Willey for a single nautilus shell he obtained at Samarai, a small island off the eastern tip of New Guinea. Willey did not even regard it as a full species: he called it Nautilus pompilius var. moretoni, a variety of the chambered nautilus, and named it after the Hon. M. H. Moreton, the colonial official who gave him the shell. In 1987 the nautilus specialist W. Bruce Saunders classed the name as a species dubium, a doubtful name that cannot be reliably applied to any distinct population, and that remains its status.
Earlier versions of this page, like many on the web, described N. moretoni as a distinct species with its own range around the Great Barrier Reef, mating rituals and seasonal breeding. None of that is supported by the scientific literature. This rewrite explains where the name actually came from, what it tells us about nineteenth-century nautilus science, and what is now known about the nautiluses of Papua New Guinea.
Who was Arthur Willey?
Arthur Willey (1867–1942) was a Yorkshire-born zoologist trained in the comparative anatomy tradition that dominated British biology in the late nineteenth century. After a period as a tutor at Columbia University in New York, he won the Balfour Studentship at Cambridge in 1894, a fellowship that allowed him to spend the following years in the western Pacific. His goal was ambitious: to find and study the embryos of the pearly nautilus, which no scientist had ever seen develop.
Nautilus embryology mattered because the nautilus was regarded as the most primitive living cephalopod, the surviving representative of the shelled ancestors of squid, cuttlefish and octopus. Biologists of the time believed that the development of an embryo could reveal its evolutionary history, so nautilus eggs were a prize. Willey later became director of the Colombo Museum in Ceylon, now Sri Lanka, and in 1910 professor of zoology at McGill University in Montreal, but his Pacific expedition remained the work for which nautilus researchers remember him.

How did Willey hunt for nautilus eggs?
Willey’s account, published in his Zoological Results between 1898 and 1902, reads like an adventure story. He worked first in New Britain, in what is now Papua New Guinea, then travelled through British New Guinea and on to the Loyalty Islands, east of New Caledonia. His plan was to find a place where nautiluses could be caught alive and kept in cages in shallow water, at four or five fathoms rather than the forty or fifty at which they were normally trapped.
He found such a place at Sandal Bay on Lifu, in the Loyalty Islands, where he lodged with a trader for about eight months. Working with local fishermen who used large woven fish traps from rafts, he kept captive nautiluses, the bellybutton species Nautilus macromphalus, in cages at about three fathoms and fed them three times a week. On 5 December 1896, nearly four months after his arrival, he found the first nautilus egg ever recorded, fixed to sacking in one of the cages. His excitement was short-lived. Over the following weeks every egg he tried to rear proved infertile; many were empty capsules.
In June 1897 he returned to New Britain with a set of large cages made to his design in Sydney, and set them in Blanche Bay. There the chambered nautiluses also laid eggs, almost identical to those of the Lifu species, but again none developed. He gave up in September 1897. It would be nearly a century before aquariums succeeded in hatching nautilus eggs. The Waikiki Aquarium in Honolulu, one of the pioneers, became the first in the United States to hatch a nautilus embryo.
Where does the name moretoni come from?
In 1896, while still in the field, Willey published a paper in the Quarterly Journal of Microscopical Science titled “On some variations in the shell of Nautilus, with description of a new variety”. In it he discussed how the shell of the chambered nautilus varies, particularly around the umbilicus, the centre of the coil, and introduced several varietal names.
In his later summary, Willey explained that shells assigned to Nautilus stenomphalus, the form with a narrow open umbilicus, varied in the diameter of that opening, and that he had named one form, of which he obtained only a single shell through the kindness of the Hon. M. H. Moreton at Samarai, N. pompilius var. moretoni. He added that he had since been shown an identical specimen in the Manchester Museum by the museum’s keeper, the cephalopod specialist William Evans Hoyle.
Samarai is a tiny island at the eastern end of mainland New Guinea, at the entrance to Milne Bay, and in the 1890s it was an administrative and trading centre of the colony of British New Guinea. Moreton was a government officer there. A shell handed over at a trading port could have come from anywhere in the surrounding seas, which already made the variety difficult to tie to a population.
What was Willey arguing?
Willey’s varieties are best understood as part of an argument rather than as attempts to name new species. He had handled more nautiluses than almost any scientist of his time, and he was struck by how much their shells varied. He concluded that N. stenomphalus, which Sowerby had described in 1849, was simply an extreme variety of N. pompilius, and that the umbilical region was precisely the part of the shell where variation was most marked.
He also offered an explanation for why the chambered nautilus closes its umbilicus. Shells with an open, deeply hollowed umbilicus, such as those of N. macromphalus and the species now called Allonautilus scrobiculatus, are a favoured attachment site for tubeworms, barnacles, oysters, bryozoans and other fouling organisms, which he thought could irritate the mantle and hamper swimming. A plug of shell over the umbilicus, he suggested, keeps such “unbidden guests” away. Whatever the merits of that idea, his central point, that shell features once used to define species vary within populations, has been borne out by later research.
In the same 1896 paper Willey also introduced the varietal names marginalis and perforatus for other shell forms. All three were later placed by Saunders in the doubtful category. Note that Willey’s perforatus is not the same as Allonautilus perforatus, a separate name based on Conrad’s 1849 description, which is itself still debated.
Why is the name considered doubtful?
A species dubium is a name whose application is uncertain, usually because the original description is too vague, the type material is lost or inadequate, or the locality is unknown. N. moretoni scores on all three counts. It was based on one shell, described in terms of a feature, umbilical width, that its own author regarded as variable. The shell’s exact origin is unknown beyond its purchase at Samarai. And no population of nautiluses with consistently distinctive umbilical features has been found in eastern Papua New Guinea that would give the name a natural home.
Saunders’s 1987 review of the species of Nautilus, published in the standard reference volume Nautilus: The Biology and Paleobiology of a Living Fossil, listed the name as a species dubium with an unresolved type repository. Modern checklists follow him, and the name is treated as falling within the variation of Nautilus pompilius.
How are nautilus species told apart now?
Since Willey’s time the toolkit has grown considerably. From the late 1970s, researchers led by Saunders and Peter Ward began trapping living nautiluses throughout the Indo-Pacific, measuring large samples of shells from known localities, tagging and releasing animals, and observing them with cameras. This revealed how much shells vary within a population and between males and females, and showed that features like umbilical width and stripe pattern must be judged across many animals.
Genetics followed. Studies using mitochondrial genes in the 1990s and 2010s found that nautiluses form groups that track geography, and a 2017 study using genome-wide RAD-seq data from thousands of markers resolved distinct lineages on individual island groups in the South Pacific. In 2023 three of those lineages, from Fiji, American Samoa and Vanuatu, were formally named as new species, each based on live-caught animals with measurements, photographs and DNA. The same paper used new, measurable shell characters, such as the percentage of the shell covered by colour stripes and whether stripes reach the umbilicus.
By modern standards, a single shell of uncertain origin, distinguished by one variable feature, cannot support a species name. That is why the name moretoni has not been revived, even as several genuinely distinct nautiluses have been recognised.
Which nautiluses live around Papua New Guinea?
Papua New Guinea lies at the heart of the nautilus range and has two genera. The chambered nautilus, Nautilus pompilius in the broad sense, occurs around the mainland and the islands of the Bismarck Archipelago, including New Britain and New Ireland, where Willey worked. The crusty nautilus, Allonautilus scrobiculatus, with its wide open umbilicus and fuzzy, hair-like outer shell layer, is also found in Papua New Guinea and the nearby Solomon Islands.
The crusty nautilus has a special place in this story. Its shells had been known since the eighteenth century, but the first living specimens were not collected until the 1980s, in Papua New Guinea, by Saunders and colleagues. Study of those animals revealed differences in the shell structure, hood, gills and reproductive organs that led Peter Ward and Saunders to place it in a new genus, Allonautilus, in 1997. It is a good example of how live animals, rather than shells alone, have settled questions that collectors argued over for two centuries.
Shell variation among Papua New Guinea nautiluses was examined in the 1980s, including a chapter on the subject in the 1987 reference volume edited by Saunders and Neil Landman. That work did not establish any population matching Willey’s variety, and the umbilical differences he described fall within the range now known for the chambered nautilus.
How does a nautilus live?
The biology of the nautiluses Willey caged has since been documented in detail. They live on steep reef slopes, usually between about 100 and 700 metres, rising toward shallower water at night. Their depth is limited by shell implosion at around 700 to 800 metres and by warm surface water, generally above about 28 degrees Celsius, which they cannot tolerate for long. These limits keep them close to reefs and islands and make it hard for them to cross deep ocean.
They are scavengers and opportunistic predators, locating food by smell and gripping it with numerous sucker-less tentacles. They swim by jet propulsion through a funnel and control their buoyancy with the gas-filled chambers of the shell. A ten-year field study at Osprey Reef in Australia’s Coral Sea, which captured 2,460 nautiluses between 1998 and 2008, estimated that they take about 15 years to mature and can live more than 20 years. Females lay a few large eggs a year, each in a tough capsule, and the eggs take around a year to hatch, which may help to explain Willey’s frustrations: even fertile eggs would have needed many months of stable conditions to develop.
Are nautiluses in Papua New Guinea threatened?
Nautiluses are caught in baited traps for their shells in parts of the Indo-Pacific, most heavily in the Philippines and Indonesia, where studies have documented falling catches consistent with overfishing. The slow growth and low reproductive rate of nautiluses make local populations vulnerable, and because populations around different islands are isolated by deep water, a depleted population may not be replenished from elsewhere.
All nautiluses were added to Appendix II of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES) in 2016, which requires export permits for international trade in nautiluses and their shells. In 2018 the United States listed the chambered nautilus as threatened under its Endangered Species Act. Detailed population surveys across Papua New Guinea’s many islands remain limited, so the state of its nautilus populations is poorly known.
Why do old nautilus names still matter?
It is tempting to dismiss names like moretoni as historical curiosities, but they still matter for three reasons. First, they remain in the literature and in museum catalogues, so anyone researching nautiluses will encounter them and needs to know what they mean. Second, the rules of zoological nomenclature give priority to the oldest available name, so if a distinct population were ever found to match an old variety, its name could in principle take precedence over a new one. Third, these names record how ideas about variation, species and evolution developed. Willey’s conclusion that shell form varies within the chambered nautilus anticipated the genetic findings of the twenty-first century by more than a hundred years.
What should you take away?
Nautilus moretoni is a nineteenth-century varietal name, based on one shell from Samarai in British New Guinea, honouring the official who supplied it. Its author thought it was a form of N. pompilius, later specialists classed it as doubtful, and no modern study supports it as a distinct species. The real story behind the name is Arthur Willey’s long campaign to understand the nautilus, from his caged animals in Lifu to the first recorded nautilus egg, and his insight that the shells he studied varied far more than the species names of his day allowed.
Is Nautilus moretoni a real species?
No. It is a doubtful name (species dubium) and is treated as falling within N. pompilius.
Who named it?
Arthur Willey, in 1896, as N. pompilius var. moretoni.
Who was it named after?
The Hon. M. H. Moreton, who gave Willey the shell at Samarai, British New Guinea.
What was it based on?
A single shell, distinguished by the form of its umbilical region.
Did Willey find nautilus eggs?
Yes. He recorded the first nautilus egg on Lifu on 5 December 1896, but all his eggs were infertile.
Which nautiluses live in Papua New Guinea?
The chambered nautilus and the crusty nautilus, Allonautilus scrobiculatus.
- Willey, A. (1896), Zoological observations in the South Pacific: on some variations in the shell of Nautilus, with description of a new variety, Quarterly Journal of Microscopical Science 39
- Willey, A. (1902), Contribution to the natural history of the pearly nautilus, Zoological Results Part VI, Cambridge University Press
- Saunders, W. B. (1987), The species of Nautilus, in Saunders & Landman (eds), Nautilus: The Biology and Paleobiology of a Living Fossil, Plenum
- Ward, P. D. & Saunders, W. B. (1997), Allonautilus: a new genus of living nautiloid cephalopod, Journal of Paleontology 71
- Barord, G. J. et al. (2023), Three new species of Nautilus from the Coral Sea and South Pacific, ZooKeys 1143: 51–69
- Dunstan, A. J., Ward, P. D. & Marshall, N. J. (2011), Nautilus pompilius life history and demographics at the Osprey Reef Seamount, PLoS ONE 6: e16312
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.
About Blane Perun →