Mimic Octopus Mimicking a Crab — Separating the Proven Acts From the Rumors
Popular accounts say the mimic octopus can imitate a crab, sometimes to approach a mate or to lure crabs as prey, but this behavior is poorly documented: it comes from anecdotes and summaries rather than a published study. The best-documented disguises come from the 2001 field study by Norman, Finn and Tregenza: a banded sole (flatfish), a lionfish and a banded sea snake, with less certain resemblances to a sand anemone and a large jellyfish. Treat crab mimicry as plausible but unconfirmed.
Mimic octopus videos online often claim a dozen or more impersonations. Science has carefully confirmed three, and the crab is not one of them.
This page looks at a single claim: that the mimic octopus, Thaumoctopus mimicus, can disguise itself as a crab. It traces where the story comes from, what the two main field studies actually recorded, how biologists decide whether a resemblance counts as mimicry, and what a real case of crab mimicry would have to look like. The aim is not to debunk a remarkable animal. The documented behaviour of this octopus is extraordinary on its own terms, and it deserves to be described accurately.
Does the mimic octopus really mimic crabs?

Possibly, but it is not established. Several popular summaries of the species list crab mimicry, usually described as a form of aggressive mimicry in which the octopus approaches a crab as if it were a potential mate and then eats it. Some divers also describe crab-like postures. Yet no peer-reviewed study has analysed crab mimicry in Thaumoctopus mimicus the way the 2001 study analysed its fish and snake disguises, and the claim is usually repeated without a citation to any original observation.
That matters because the strongest evidence for this species is unusually good. Researchers have spent long periods underwater with habituated octopuses, filmed hours of natural behaviour and counted hundreds of individual mimicry events. Against that standard, the crab story stands out as an anecdote. It may turn out to be true. For now, it belongs in the “reported but unconfirmed” column, beside a number of other impersonations that circulate online.
| Disguise | Evidence | Context |
|---|---|---|
| Banded sole (Zebrias) | Confirmed, filmed | Swimming over open sand |
| Lionfish (Pterois) | Confirmed, 4 individuals | Hovering above seafloor |
| Banded sea snake (Laticauda) | Confirmed, 4 occasions | When attacked by damselfish |
| Sand anemone, large jellyfish | Possible | Observed, less certain |
| Crab | Reported, anecdotal | Hunting or mating, unconfirmed |

Where does the crab claim come from?
The mimic octopus became famous quickly. It was discovered in 1998 off the coast of Sulawesi in Indonesia, featured in a BBC and Discovery natural-history documentary in 2000, and was formally named only in 2005. During those years it gathered a reputation that ran ahead of the science. By 2008 a research team led by Roger Hanlon noted that the “mimic octopuses” of Indonesia were “reputed to mimic up to 13 species” of other local marine animals, a figure drawn from popular accounts rather than from a study.
Crab mimicry appears in some of these lists. The best-known version, repeated in encyclopedia-style summaries, says the octopus mimics a crab as an apparent mate in order to approach and devour a deceived suitor. None of the primary papers on the species supports this. The original 2001 field study does not mention crab mimicry at all. The 2005 formal description by Mark Norman and Eric Hochberg describes the octopus as impersonating “numerous poisonous or dangerous animals”, and the SeaLifeBase species profile lists only soles, sea snakes and lionfish as its models. In short, the crab story seems to have entered the popular literature without a documented observation behind it.
It is easy to see why the idea is appealing. Crabs are a real part of the octopus’s diet, and the notion of an animal disguising itself as its own prey’s mate makes a vivid story. But an appealing story and a recorded behaviour are not the same thing.
What did the 2001 study actually see?
The founding paper is “Dynamic mimicry in an Indo-Malayan octopus” by Mark Norman, Julian Finn and Tom Tregenza, published in the Proceedings of the Royal Society B in 2001. During daylight dives off the northern coast of Sulawesi and at Gilimanuk in Bali, the team watched nine adult mimic octopuses over a total of 16 days between October 1998 and October 2000. They collected still photographs and more than six hours of video. The animals lived on silt and sand off river mouths in water 2 to 12 metres deep, a habitat riddled with the burrows and mounds of worms, crustaceans, echinoderms and fishes.
The researchers described several distinct displays. When moving fast by jet propulsion, the octopus drew all its arms into a leaf-shaped wedge and undulated over the sand like a swimming flatfish, which the authors interpreted as mimicry of an abundant banded sole (Zebrias). Four individuals swam just above the seafloor with their arms trailing and spread, looking like a lionfish (Pterois) with its venomous spines flared. On four occasions, attacks by small territorial damselfishes triggered a posture in which six arms were threaded down a hole while the other two were raised in opposite directions, banded and undulating, producing the appearance of a banded sea snake (Laticauda).
Two further behaviours were noted with less confidence. Octopuses sometimes sat on sand mounds and raised all eight arms above the body in a zigzag form, which might impersonate large stinging sand anemones. In one incident a large female with an arm span of 60 centimetres swam to the surface from 4 metres down and then sank slowly with her arms spread evenly around her, which might resemble a large jellyfish. Every individual showed more than one of these behaviours, and two used all three of the confirmed forms.
The authors were careful about what they claimed. They wrote that human interpretations of potential mimicries are subjective, and that at that stage they were confident only in the mimicry of soles, lionfish and banded sea snakes. That caution is the reason the table above separates confirmed, possible and reported disguises. A crab does not appear anywhere in the paper.
What did later fieldwork add?
The second key study is Hanlon, Conroy and Forsythe’s 2008 paper in the Biological Journal of the Linnean Society, which set out to test the mimicry claims directly. The team allowed individuals of two long-armed octopus species, the mimic octopus and a second long-armed species, to habituate to divers, and then followed and filmed them continuously as they foraged each day on open, featureless volcanic sand off North Sulawesi.
Flatfish mimicry turned out to be common. Over five days of natural foraging the researchers analysed nearly 500 episodes in which the octopuses copied the shape, swimming action, speed, duration and sometimes the colour of a local swimming flounder. Crucially, they used it only when moving. Immediately before and after each flatfish swim the octopuses were camouflaged and motionless, and when still they took on postures and patterns resembling small sponges, tube-worm tubes or colonial tunicates, some of the few objects on the open sand.
Two other findings bear directly on the crab question. First, the octopuses were filmed in several interactions with fishes and with stomatopods (mantis shrimps), and in those encounters they used ordinary secondary defences, not mimicry. Second, foraging happened twice a day using two tactile tactics, in which the octopuses felt for prey rather than stalking it by sight. Neither result fits naturally with an animal that routinely lures crabs by impersonating them. The study also found that dens and food were not limiting, so there was little obvious pressure to evolve elaborate tricks for catching prey.
How do scientists decide whether something is mimicry?
Mimicry has three parts: a model, a mimic and a receiver. The model is the animal being copied, the mimic is the animal doing the copying, and the receiver is the animal being fooled. A convincing case needs evidence for all three. It is not enough for a photograph to look a bit like something else; the resemblance has to be specific, it has to appear in the right context, and ideally there should be some sign that the receiver responds to the mimic as it would to the model.
The flatfish case meets these tests well. The model, a banded sole or local flounder, lives in the same habitat. The resemblance covers shape, colour, swimming motion, speed and duration, not just a single frame. The context is consistent, because the display appears exactly when movement would otherwise expose the octopus to predators. The sea-snake case adds an especially persuasive detail: in every one of the four observations, the display was a reaction to damselfishes, and the authors noted that sea snakes hunt by entering burrows and prey on damselfishes. The octopus seemed to pick a disguise that fitted the threat.
Researchers also have to rule out other explanations. Norman and colleagues discussed two. One is convergent evolution: an octopus might carry black-and-white bands simply because the same pressures that make banding useful for a sea snake also apply to the octopus. They thought this unlikely given how closely the octopus copies animals with completely different body plans. The other is sexual display: a complex posture might be courtship misread as mimicry. They found no evidence for that either, because both sexes performed the displays, the animals were well separated, typically 50 to 100 metres apart, and every display was seen in the absence of other mimic octopuses.
What would real crab mimicry have to look like?
Applying the same standard to crabs shows how much is still missing. A convincing case would need a specific model, such as a particular crab species found on the same sand flats, and a resemblance that goes beyond a rounded body with tucked arms. Crabs walk sideways on jointed legs, hold their claws in characteristic positions and move in short, jerky bursts. An octopus that genuinely copied one would be expected to reproduce some of that gait and posture, not just a compact shape.
The aggressive-mimicry version of the claim sets an even higher bar. If the octopus approaches crabs disguised as a mate, then the crabs are the receivers, and their behaviour should change: they ought to let the octopus approach more closely than they would otherwise, or respond with courtship or territorial signals of their own. Showing that would mean filming many approaches, comparing them with ordinary hunting approaches and measuring how often each one succeeds. Nothing like that has been published for Thaumoctopus mimicus.
There is also an ecological reason for doubt. The 2001 study found that the octopus’s prey are mainly subterranean crustaceans and fishes, which it reaches by threading its long arms down burrows and holes or by trapping fleeing prey under the flared web between its arms. The authors even watched octopuses enter a tunnel completely and emerge from another hole up to a metre away, a foraging style they had not seen in any other octopus. An animal that hunts mostly by touch, out of sight of its prey, gains little from a visual disguise aimed at that prey. The full picture of how it feeds is on our mimic octopus diet page.

Could some “crab” sightings be something else?
Very likely. Octopuses of many kinds pull their arms under the body and lower the mantle when resting, crawling slowly or settling into a burrow entrance, and from some angles that compact shape can look loosely crab-like, especially in a brief video clip. The mimic octopus also takes on a wide range of postures and patterns as it moves between camouflage and display, and Hanlon’s team found that when motionless it resembled sponges, worm tubes and tunicates rather than any animal. A diver who sees an octopus hunched over a burrow, or reaching out to grab a crab it is about to eat, may reasonably come away with the impression of a crab impersonation.
Misidentification is another possibility. The mimic octopus shares its sand flats with other long-armed octopuses, including the closely related wunderpus, Wunderpus photogenicus, and young or poorly lit animals are not always easy to tell apart. Hanlon’s 2008 study described a whole guild of small, long-armed octopus species sharing the same habitat, dens, food and activity period. A behaviour seen in one species can easily be credited to its more famous neighbour.
Which cephalopods really do impersonate other animals?
Animal impersonation is rare even among cephalopods, which is part of why the mimic octopus drew so much attention. When Hanlon and colleagues described flatfish mimicry in the Atlantic octopus Macrotritopus defilippi in 2010, they called it only the fourth convincing case of mimicry in cephalopods. That octopus, filmed at five Caribbean locations, copied the posture, swimming style, speed, duration and colour of the peacock flounder Bothus lunatus, and, like the mimic octopus, used the disguise only while swimming.
Other examples are narrower. The Caribbean reef squid has been reported to take on the look of parrotfish while moving among foraging schools of them, which the 2001 paper suggested is better described as a form of blending in with a crowd. In giant cuttlefish, small males have been seen impersonating females to slip past larger guarding males and reach mates, a case of deception aimed at their own species. In 2005, Christine Huffard and colleagues reported in Science that two octopuses walk on two arms while holding the rest of the body in disguise: Octopus marginatus resembles a coconut and Abdopus aculeatus a clump of floating algae. Those are impersonations of objects, not animals.
Deceptive hunting does exist in octopuses, but it does not involve dressing up as the prey. The larger Pacific striped octopus, studied in aquaria by Roy Caldwell and colleagues, creeps up on a shrimp, extends an arm over it and touches it on the far side, either catching it or startling it into its other arms. That is a clever ambush, and it is the kind of predatory trick that could be mistaken for something more elaborate if seen only briefly in the wild.
Why did mimicry evolve in this octopus at all?
The open sand and mud where the mimic octopus lives offers almost nowhere to hide, and the octopus forages in daylight in full view of fish predators. Norman and colleagues argued that this exposed, predator-rich setting may explain why complex mimicry evolved here and not in reef octopuses that can simply hide in crevices. Octopuses also lack the fast escape of squids, so a convincing disguise may have been the price of entry to this foraging niche.
A 2010 study by Huffard and colleagues looked at the question across the octopus family tree. Contrary to their expectations, flatfish-style swimming appeared to have evolved at the same time as extremely long arms, within a group of sand-dwelling species. The bold banded colour pattern displayed while swimming may be a later, secondary adaptation, one that could allow mimicry of a toxic sole, better disruptive colouration, or a warning signal of its own.
All three confirmed models share one trait: they are dangerous. Banded sea snakes inject venom through fangs, lionfish carry venom-tipped spines, and soles of the genus Zebrias have poison glands at the bases of their fins. That pattern points to defence as the main purpose. Because the octopus regularly falls back on camouflage, the 2001 authors suspected it is a harmless (Batesian) mimic rather than a toxic one. Its ability to switch models on demand, called dynamic mimicry, means predators meet each disguise less often and are slower to learn that any of them is a bluff.
How does the mimic octopus change shape and color?

Like other octopuses, it controls thousands of pigment cells called chromatophores, each opened or closed by tiny muscles under direct nervous control, so it can switch patterns in a fraction of a second. Its body has no rigid internal or external skeleton, which removes most physical limits on the shapes it can adopt. The 2005 species description also highlights very long, narrow arms and fixed colour landmarks, including a white teardrop ring on the mantle, that help identify it. Researchers describe the result as a “neural polymorphism”: one animal can carry the full set of disguises and choose among them, rather than each individual being locked into a single look by its genes. Our page on mimic octopus transformations covers the mechanics in more detail.
Where can you see a mimic octopus?
The species lives on sand and silt in the tropical Indo-West Pacific. The 2005 description recorded it mainly from the Indo-Malayan Archipelago, from Indonesia, Malaysia and the Philippines east to New Caledonia, at depths of about 0.5 to 37 metres, with photographic records extending the range to the Red Sea, and it has since been documented on the Great Barrier Reef. Most sightings still come from Indonesian muck-diving sites in North Sulawesi and Bali. It is active by day, often sitting at the mouth of a borrowed burrow and sometimes staying in the same hole for several days, so patient divers on the right sites have a fair chance of an encounter. The species is assessed as Least Concern on the IUCN Red List, although collection for the aquarium trade and disturbance at popular dive sites are worth keeping in mind.
How should divers report a possible crab mimic?
Good observations can still move the science forward, and much of what is known about this species began with divers and underwater photographers working the same muck sites. If you see a mimic octopus behaving like a crab, record video rather than stills, because movement is what separates a real impersonation from a lucky still frame. Note the time, depth and site. Keep filming before and after the behaviour, and capture any nearby crabs, fish or other octopuses, since the reaction of other animals is the key evidence that a disguise is working.
It also helps to describe what the octopus did next. Did it catch a crab, retreat into a burrow, or switch to another display? Did a crab approach it or ignore it? Share the footage with a regional reef-life survey, a museum cephalopod specialist or a university research group. A handful of well-documented clips, showing a consistent crab-like posture and a clear response from real crabs, would do more to settle this question than any number of retold anecdotes.

Can mimic octopuses mimic crabs?
It is reported in popular accounts but has not been documented in a scientific study, so treat it as unconfirmed.
What animals does the mimic octopus imitate?
Confirmed: banded sole (flatfish), lionfish and banded sea snake. Possibly a sand anemone and a large jellyfish.
Why does the mimic octopus imitate a sea snake?
In the 2001 study it did so only when attacked by territorial damselfishes, which sea snakes prey on.
How many animals can the mimic octopus mimic?
Three are well documented. Popular accounts claim up to 13, but most of those have not been tested.
What is dynamic mimicry?
The ability to switch between several impersonations and pick the one that suits the threat at that moment.
Does the mimic octopus use mimicry to hunt?
The evidence points to defence. It finds most prey by touch, probing burrows with its long arms.
Who discovered the mimic octopus?
It was found off Sulawesi in 1998 and formally described in 2005 by Mark Norman and Eric Hochberg.
Do other octopuses mimic crabs?
Not convincingly. Proven cephalopod impersonations include flatfish, coconuts, algae and, in cuttlefish, females.
- Norman, M.D., Finn, J. & Tregenza, T. (2001). Dynamic mimicry in an Indo-Malayan octopus. Proceedings of the Royal Society B 268: 1755–1758.
- Hanlon, R.T., Conroy, L.-A. & Forsythe, J.W. (2008). Mimicry and foraging behaviour of two tropical sand-flat octopus species off North Sulawesi, Indonesia. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 93: 23–38.
- Norman, M.D. & Hochberg, F.G. (2005). The “Mimic Octopus” (Thaumoctopus mimicus n. gen. et sp.), a new octopus from the tropical Indo-West Pacific. Molluscan Research 25: 57–70.
- Huffard, C.L., Saarman, N., Hamilton, H. & Simison, W.B. (2010). The evolution of conspicuous facultative mimicry in octopuses: an example of secondary adaptation? Biological Journal of the Linnean Society.
- Hanlon, R.T., Watson, A.C. & Barbosa, A. (2010). A “mimic octopus” in the Atlantic: flatfish mimicry and camouflage by Macrotritopus defilippi. Biological Bulletin.
- Huffard, C.L., Boneka, F. & Full, R.J. (2005). Underwater bipedal locomotion by octopuses in disguise. Science 307: 1927.
- Caldwell, R.L., Ross, R., Rodaniche, A. & Huffard, C.L. (2015). Behavior and body patterns of the larger Pacific striped octopus. PLOS ONE; ScienceDaily summary, August 2015.
- SeaLifeBase: Thaumoctopus mimicus species summary (IUCN status, depth, diet, mimicry models).
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.
About Blane Perun →