Christopher Columbus & the Manatee — The 1493 Mermaid Sighting
Christopher Columbus thought a manatee was a mermaid. On January 9, 1493, off the coast of Hispaniola (modern-day Dominican Republic/Haiti), Columbus recorded in his log that he saw three mermaids — and noted with disappointment that they were not nearly as beautiful as they were painted, with faces that resembled men. The animals he saw were almost certainly West Indian manatees (Trichechus manatus). This is the first written European description of manatees and the most famous example of mermaid mistaken-identity in the historical record. The entry is preserved in Bartolomé de las Casas’s 16th-century summary of Columbus’s lost original logbook.
The most famous case of mistaken identity in the history of marine biology happened in January 1493, and the witness was Christopher Columbus. Returning from the Caribbean at the end of his first voyage, sailing along the north coast of Hispaniola, Columbus saw three large pale animals surfacing near his ship. He recorded them as mermaids. He also recorded that they were ugly, which is more honest than most of what he wrote on that voyage. The animals were almost certainly West Indian manatees — the first ones a European had ever described in writing.
The original log entry

The entry exists today because of a sixteenth-century historian. Columbus’s original logbook is lost; what we have is Bartolomé de las Casas’s summary of it, written from a copy several decades after the voyage.
Columbus’s log entry for January 9, 1493 — the day before he sailed away from Hispaniola at the end of his first voyage — records that he and his crew saw three large creatures the previous day that lifted themselves well out of the water near the ship. He described them as sirenas — mermaids, sirens — and noted that they were not nearly as beautiful as they had been painted in legend. The version preserved by Las Casas includes the observation that they had faces like men, which was Columbus’s polite way of saying they weren’t attractive.
The location was the north coast of Hispaniola, likely near the mouth of a river that Columbus called the Río del Oro — possibly in modern-day Haiti or the northwest Dominican Republic. The habitat is consistent with what we now know about West Indian manatee distribution: shallow coastal water, near river mouths, in the Caribbean. The size, the surface behaviour, and the fact that three animals were seen together (a manatee mother with calves, or a small loose aggregation) all match manatee behaviour. Columbus had no other realistic candidate for what he was looking at.

Why a manatee looks like a mermaid (kind of)

From a sailing ship at distance, with the light wrong and the sailor tired, a West Indian manatee actually does look surprisingly like a person in the water. Not for long, and not closely. But enough to start a story.
A manatee surfacing to breathe lifts its head and upper body out of the water. The pectoral flippers may be held against the chest. Mother manatees often carry their calves against the chest with the flippers, in a posture that is uncannily human-like at distance. The body tapers below the water line into a long, paddle-shaped tail that, in the right light, suggests a fish’s tail. The skin is pale and patchy. From hundreds of metres away on the deck of a ship, the silhouette is just close enough to a human torso with a fish-like tail to fit the mermaid template that European sailors had carried with them since the Greeks.
The closer you get, the less the resemblance holds. Manatees have whiskered, downturned faces with small eyes and pinpoint nostrils. Their skin is thick and wrinkled, often covered in algae and barnacles. They are 600 kilograms of grey, slow, blunt-faced aquatic herbivore. Columbus’s remark that they were not as beautiful as legend suggests he got close enough to see this clearly — he just didn’t change his identification, because the alternative (a previously unknown large marine animal) wasn’t available to him as a mental category.
Why the mermaid framing made sense to a 1493 sailor
In the medieval and early-modern European tradition, mermaids and sirens were not myth in the modern sense — they were creatures sailors plausibly expected to encounter at sea, alongside whales, sea-serpents, and the kraken. Columbus identifying his manatees as mermaids was working within the conventional natural history of his time.
Medieval bestiaries — the standard reference works on the natural world before scientific taxonomy — treated sirens and mermaids as real animals. They appeared in encyclopaedias, in travel narratives, and in church carvings. Sailors swapped stories about them. Pliny the Elder had written about sea-humans in his Natural History. The mermaid was as natural a category for a 1493 European seafarer as the whale or the shark — an animal you expected to encounter at sea, even if you hadn’t personally seen one yet.
When Columbus saw three pale, human-torso-shaped animals surfacing near his ship in unfamiliar tropical waters, the mermaid was the available identification. He wasn’t inventing the connection or being naive; he was using the best taxonomic framework his culture provided him. The disappointment in the log entry is genuine: he had expected the mythical mermaids to be beautiful, and the actual animals were not. Within his framework, he was correctly reporting that the legends had exaggerated.

Was Columbus the first European to describe manatees?
In writing, in published form, yes — Columbus’s January 1493 log is the earliest surviving European description of any manatee. But Europeans had encountered the closely related West African manatee decades earlier.
Portuguese explorers had been sailing the Atlantic coast of Africa since the 1430s, working their way south toward the Cape. The West African manatee (Trichechus senegalensis) lives in the coastal rivers and lagoons of Senegal, Guinea, and onward, and Portuguese sailors and traders had certainly seen and probably hunted these animals by mid-century. References appear in Portuguese trade accounts before Columbus sailed. But no formal description of the African manatee from this period survives in published form, and the animals were treated as just another large fish or sea cow rather than identified as a distinct species.
Columbus’s 1493 log is therefore the first European written record of manatees, and his identification of them as mermaids is the first linkage in print between the manatee body plan and the mermaid tradition. The connection was rapidly cemented by later Spanish and Portuguese chroniclers in the Americas, and by the end of the sixteenth century the West Indian manatee was a regular feature of natural-history writing about the New World — usually with the mermaid identification still attached.
Indigenous Caribbean people knew the manatee long before
By the time Columbus arrived in the Caribbean, the Taíno, Carib, Arawak and other indigenous peoples of the Caribbean had lived alongside West Indian manatees for thousands of years. The manatee was a known and important animal in pre-Columbian Caribbean cultures.
Archaeological evidence from coastal sites across the Caribbean — Cuba, Hispaniola, Puerto Rico, the Lesser Antilles — includes manatee bones, suggesting the animal was hunted for meat, hide, and bone. Manatee figures appear in Taíno art and ceremonial objects. The Spanish chroniclers who followed Columbus recorded indigenous names for the animal and noted that local people hunted manatees with spears and nets from canoes. The Spanish word manatí, from which the English “manatee” comes, is borrowed from a Carib language — recognising that the indigenous peoples already had the animal classified before Europeans arrived.
The historical irony of Columbus’s 1493 sighting is that he was the last person in the Caribbean to see manatees for the first time. He just happened to be the one whose journal got preserved.
What happened to the manatees Columbus saw?

The West Indian manatees of Columbus’s Hispaniola sighting almost certainly did not survive the next several centuries. Spanish colonisation of the Caribbean turned out badly for manatees, alongside everything else.
After Columbus, Spanish colonists across the Caribbean hunted manatees heavily for meat and hide. The animals were slow, surface-breathing, predictable, and lived in shallow coastal water that was easily accessed from boats — essentially helpless against organised hunting pressure. By the 17th and 18th centuries the manatee populations of the larger Spanish colonies (Cuba, Hispaniola, Puerto Rico) had been heavily depleted, with some areas seeing local extinction. Subsequent centuries of further hunting, habitat loss from coastal development, and modern threats like boat strikes have left the West Indian manatee classified as Vulnerable by the IUCN, with the Florida subspecies the most studied population at around 6,500 animals.
The descendants of the manatees Columbus saw still live in Hispaniola today, but as a much-reduced fragmented population, hunted occasionally, hit by boats, and dependent on a few protected coastal areas. The historical irony is that the first European to write about manatees was also the harbinger of the colonial regime that nearly wiped them out across the Caribbean.
Columbus called the animals sirenas, using the old Greek name for a creature that began as a bird-woman, not a fish-tailed one; see sirens vs mermaids for how the two merged.

Did Columbus really think manatees were mermaids?
Yes. On January 9, 1493, Columbus recorded in his log that he saw three mermaids (sirenas) off the coast of Hispaniola, and noted that they were not as beautiful as legend suggested, with faces like men. The animals were almost certainly West Indian manatees, and Columbus’s identification was working within the conventional natural history of his time — mermaids were a standard category of marine animal in medieval European bestiaries.
What did Columbus actually see?
West Indian manatees (Trichechus manatus). The location, behaviour, habitat, and number of animals all match what manatees do. Three large pale animals surfacing near shore in shallow Caribbean coastal water in January is a classic manatee sighting.
Where was the sighting?
Off the north coast of Hispaniola — the island now divided between Haiti and the Dominican Republic. The exact location is uncertain but probably near a river mouth Columbus called the Río del Oro on the returning leg of his first voyage, just before he sailed back to Spain.
Was Columbus the first European to see manatees?
He produced the first written European description of manatees, dated January 9, 1493. Portuguese sailors had almost certainly encountered the West African manatee in coastal Africa decades earlier, but no formal description survives in published form. Columbus’s log is the earliest European written record of any sirenian.
Did Columbus’s log entry survive?
The original logbook is lost. What survives is Bartolomé de las Casas’s summary of it, written in the early sixteenth century from a copy of the original. The January 9, 1493 mermaid entry is one of the well-known passages preserved in the Las Casas version.
Why are manatees and dugongs called sirenians?
The order Sirenia is named after the Greek sirens — mythological creatures who lured sailors to their deaths. The name was formalised by zoologist Johann Karl Wilhelm Illiger in 1811 in recognition of the long history of mermaid sightings that turned out to be sirenians. Manatee-mermaid legends appear in every culture that lives alongside the animals.
What does “manatee” mean and where does the word come from?
The English “manatee” comes from the Spanish manatí, which the Spanish borrowed from a Carib indigenous language of the Caribbean. The original meaning is thought to relate to “breast” or “udder,” referring to the female manatee’s nursing teat located behind the flipper. The Taíno and Carib peoples had names for manatees long before Columbus arrived.
Are manatees the only origin of mermaid legends?
Mostly, in regions where sirenians live. Manatees and dugongs account for the majority of mermaid sightings across the Atlantic, Indian Ocean, and Caribbean. Some mermaid stories may also trace to seals or sea lions in colder regions, but the classic mermaid-in-tropical-water story is overwhelmingly a sirenian one. The order’s scientific name acknowledges the connection.
Did Columbus’s crew hunt or eat manatees?
There’s no record of Columbus’s crew hunting manatees during the first voyage. Indigenous Caribbean peoples did hunt them, and within decades of Columbus, Spanish colonists across the Caribbean were hunting manatees heavily for meat and hide — eventually contributing to the near-extinction of the species across much of its range.
Do manatees still live where Columbus saw them?
Yes, but in much reduced numbers. The descendants of the Hispaniola manatees survive in a fragmented population along the Dominican and Haitian coasts. Hunting, boat strikes, and habitat loss have severely reduced the population from what Columbus would have encountered. The West Indian manatee remains listed as Vulnerable by the IUCN.
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.
About Blane Perun →