Is Cuttlefish Squid? — Classification, Calamari and the Fish Counter
No. Cuttlefish is not squid, but it is a close relative. Both belong to the ten-armed cephalopods, the Decapodiformes, alongside bobtail squid and the ram’s horn squid. Cuttlefish form their own order, Sepiida, with about 116 species, separate from the true squids. At the market a whole cuttlefish is easy to spot: a broad, flattened body with a fin all the way round and a hard, chalky cuttlebone inside, where a squid is a slim tube with a clear, flexible pen. In the kitchen cuttlefish meat is thicker and sweeter, and much commercial “squid ink” is actually cuttlefish ink.
The confusion is understandable. Cuttlefish and squid look alike, both have eight arms and two tentacles, they are often sold side by side and are sometimes cut into the same rings and strips. In several languages and cuisines the names overlap, and labels do not always help.
Is cuttlefish a type of squid?
No. In everyday language people sometimes call any ten-armed cephalopod a squid, but scientists treat cuttlefish and squid as separate groups. Cuttlefish make up the order Sepiida, which contains a single living family, the Sepiidae, with about 116 recognised species. The animals most people mean by squid belong to two other orders: the Myopsida, coastal squid with a transparent membrane covering the eye, such as the familiar market squid of the genus Loligo; and the Oegopsida, open-ocean and deep-sea squid such as the flying squids, the Humboldt squid and the giant squid.
What cuttlefish and squid share is membership of the Decapodiformes, the ten-limbed cephalopods, which have eight arms and two longer feeding tentacles. That group also includes the bobtail squids (Sepiolida), small rounded animals that are not true squid either, and the tiny, deep-living ram’s horn squid, Spirula. The other main branch of living cephalopods, the Octopodiformes, contains the octopuses and the vampire squid.

How closely related are cuttlefish and squid?
Close, but not as close as their shared name in some languages suggests. Cuttlefish and the true squids are cousins within the Decapodiformes, roughly comparable to the relationship between cats and dogs within the carnivores: obviously similar animals with a shared ancestor, but long-separated lineages with their own features. The exact branching order among cuttlefish, bobtail squids, Spirula and the two squid orders has been debated for decades, and molecular studies have produced different answers.
The cuttlefish family itself has also been reorganised recently. For decades, taxonomists placed almost all cuttlefish in the genus Sepia, with only two small additional genera, Metasepia and Sepiella. A 2023 study led by Nikolaus Lupše used DNA and anatomy to split Sepia into several genera, so some familiar species now carry new names; the giant Australian cuttlefish, for example, is now often listed as Ascarosepion apama. The common cuttlefish of Europe remains Sepia officinalis.
What makes a cuttlefish a cuttlefish?
The defining feature is the cuttlebone, a chalky internal shell of aragonite made of many thin chambers. The cuttlefish adjusts the gas and liquid in those chambers to control buoyancy. Apart from the small coiled shell of Spirula, it is the only chambered internal shell among living squid-like cephalopods. Squid have instead a gladius or pen, a thin, flexible, transparent strip of chitin-like material that stiffens the body but provides no lift.
Other traits follow. Cuttlefish have a broad, somewhat flattened body with a narrow fin running around the whole edge of the mantle, W-shaped pupils, and a habit of hovering near the sea floor. Most squid have a slimmer, torpedo-shaped body with fins concentrated at the rear end and spend their lives in open water. Cuttlefish are also absent from the Americas, while squid occur in all oceans, which explains why cuttlefish are much less familiar in North American cooking than in Mediterranean or Asian cuisine.
Why do menus and labels mix up cuttlefish and squid?
Partly because of language. In Italian, cuttlefish is seppia and squid is calamaro; in Spanish, cuttlefish is sepia or choco and squid is calamar, with small squid often sold as chipirones. In Japanese, the word ika covers squid and cuttlefish alike, with species names such as sumi-ika or mongo-ika used for cuttlefish. When dishes travel between cuisines, these distinctions are often lost in translation.
The other reason is processing. Once the head, arms and skin are removed and the body is cut into rings or strips, cuttlefish, squid and even octopus can be hard to tell apart by eye. Frozen cephalopod products in particular are traded internationally in large volumes, and DNA testing studies of seafood in several countries have found cephalopod products labelled with the wrong species name. Within the European Union, retail labels must give both a commercial name and the scientific name, which makes it easier for buyers to check what they are getting.
How do you tell a whole cuttlefish from a squid at the fish counter?
Start with the shape. A whole cuttlefish has a broad, oval, slightly flattened body, often with a striped or mottled skin even after death, and a narrow fin running all the way round the body like a skirt. A squid is a long, narrow tube, often pinkish or purple-spotted, with two triangular or diamond-shaped fins at the far end. Cuttlefish arms are short compared with the body; in many squid, the two tentacles are conspicuously long.
Then feel the back. A cuttlefish has a hard, rigid plate along its back, the cuttlebone, which you can feel through the mantle and which gives the body a stiff, shield-like feel. Pressing the back of a squid finds only a thin, flexible strip, the pen, which bends easily. If the fishmonger has already cleaned the animal, look for the shape of the body sac: cuttlefish sacs are broad and thick-walled, squid tubes long and thin-walled.
What does a cleaned cuttlefish look like?
Cleaning a cuttlefish is a little more involved than cleaning a squid, and messier. The cuttlebone is removed by cutting along the back and pushing it out; it slides free in one piece. The head and arms are then pulled away with the innards, and the large, dark ink sac must be removed carefully, or kept if the cook wants the ink. Finally the thin outer skin is peeled away from the white body.
The result is a thick, white, flattened piece of meat, quite different from the slim tube of a cleaned squid. Cuttlefish flesh is typically thicker, denser and slightly sweeter in flavour than squid of a similar size. In many cuisines it is cut into strips or diamonds rather than rings, scored in a criss-cross pattern so that it curls when cooked, or stuffed whole. Small whole cuttlefish, sometimes sold as baby cuttlefish or seppioline, are often cooked without cleaning out the body.
Is “squid ink” really from squid?
Often not. Black pasta, risotto and paella are commonly described in English as being made with squid ink, but in the Mediterranean the traditional ink comes from cuttlefish: the Italian nero di seppia and Spanish tinta de sepia. Cuttlefish carry a much larger ink sac relative to their size than most squid, and their ink is easier to collect in quantity. Much of the commercial “squid ink” sold in jars or sachets is, according to the label, cuttlefish ink.
Squid ink and cuttlefish ink are similar. Both are mainly melanin, the same pigment that colours human skin and hair, mixed with mucus and other compounds. In cooking they give a black colour and a mild, briny flavour. The historical pigment sepia, used by artists and writers for centuries, was made from cuttlefish ink, which is how the cuttlefish’s scientific name came to describe a shade of brown.
How do cuttlefish and squid cook differently?
Both are cooked by the same rule: very quickly or very slowly. Fast cooking over high heat, for a minute or two, keeps the flesh tender; moderate cooking makes it tough and rubbery as the proteins contract; long, gentle cooking, typically 45 minutes or more in a sauce, softens the connective tissue again. Thin squid rings are best fried or grilled briefly. Cuttlefish, with its thicker flesh, is more often stewed, braised with peas or tomatoes, or slow-cooked in its own ink.
Cuttlefish is also popular grilled, especially in Spain and Portugal, where choco a la plancha or grilled chocos are common, and in East Asia, where dried, shredded cuttlefish is a popular snack. In Japan, cuttlefish is eaten raw as sashimi, prized for its thick, slightly crunchy texture. Squid is the more versatile and widely available of the two, and much of what is sold as calamari worldwide is squid, but calamari dishes made with cuttlefish are not unusual.
Where do the cuttlefish and squid we eat come from?
Squid make up most of the world’s cephalopod catch. In FAO statistics from the early 2000s, squid accounted for about three-quarters of more than 3 million tonnes of cephalopods landed worldwide each year, dominated by a few species such as the Argentine shortfin squid, the Japanese flying squid and the Humboldt squid. These are caught by jigging with lights at night, by trawling, and by other methods.
Cuttlefish fisheries are smaller but important regionally. In Europe, the common cuttlefish is caught in the English Channel, the Bay of Biscay and the Mediterranean by trawlers, traps and small-scale fishers. Other large fisheries exist off West Africa, in the Arabian Sea and around East and Southeast Asia. Because cuttlefish do not live in the Americas, any cuttlefish sold in North or South America is imported, usually frozen.
Does it matter for allergies whether it is cuttlefish or squid?
Cuttlefish, squid and octopus are all molluscs, and people with a mollusc allergy can react to any of them. The major allergen in cephalopods is tropomyosin, a muscle protein that is similar across many shellfish, so cross-reactions between cephalopods, and sometimes with crustaceans such as shrimp, are possible. Anyone with a known shellfish allergy should treat cuttlefish and squid with the same caution and seek medical advice before eating either.
Food safety is similar too. Like squid, cuttlefish can carry parasites, which is one reason why food authorities recommend that cephalopods intended to be eaten raw or lightly cooked are frozen first. As with all seafood, freshness matters: fresh cuttlefish should smell clean and of the sea, with firm, glossy flesh.
Is cuttlefish more sustainable than squid?
It depends on the species and the fishery, and there is no single answer. Both groups grow fast and live only one to two years, which helps populations recover from fishing, but it also makes stocks volatile: a poor spawning year can quickly reduce the next year’s catch. Many cephalopod fisheries are only lightly managed compared with fish fisheries, and catch data can be incomplete.
Cuttlefish carry some particular risks. They gather in shallow water to spawn and attach their eggs to seagrass, ropes and other structures, so fishing on spawning grounds, or removing traps with eggs attached, can affect the next generation. In the English Channel, researchers have trialled egg-laying supports and studied how trap fishing affects cuttlefish eggs. Seafood guides in different countries rate specific cuttlefish and squid fisheries, and checking a local guide is the best way to choose.
Are bobtail squid and pygmy squid cuttlefish or squid?
Neither, strictly. Bobtail squid, sometimes called dumpling squid, are small, round-bodied cephalopods of the order Sepiolida, with two rounded fins that look like ears. They were once grouped with cuttlefish as “sepioids”, and in fish markets they are sometimes sold alongside baby cuttlefish, but they have no cuttlebone and only a tiny remnant of a pen, or none at all. The best known is the Hawaiian bobtail squid, famous in biology for the glowing bacteria it houses in a light organ.
Pygmy squid of the genus Idiosepius, some no longer than a fingernail, are another small group with their own order. These animals show why common names are unreliable: “squid” is attached to several lineages that are not true squid at all, and “cuttlefish” has sometimes been used loosely for bobtails. If precision matters, the scientific name is the only safe guide.
So what should you call it?
If the animal has a cuttlebone, call it a cuttlefish. Despite the name, it is not a fish either: the “fish” in cuttlefish, like the “fish” in starfish and jellyfish, is an old habit of naming sea creatures. The word cuttle comes from Old English, and sepia comes from the Greek name for the animal.
Squid, cuttlefish, bobtail squid and octopus are all cephalopods, and in the kitchen they are often interchangeable. In biology, though, the differences matter: they reflect separate evolutionary paths, different ways of living and different vulnerabilities. Knowing which animal is on your plate is also the first step to knowing whether it was caught sustainably.
Is cuttlefish a squid?
No. Cuttlefish (order Sepiida) and squid are separate groups of ten-armed cephalopods.
Is calamari squid or cuttlefish?
Usually squid, but cuttlefish is sometimes used and sold as calamari.
How can I tell cuttlefish from squid at the market?
Cuttlefish are broad, with a fin all around and a hard cuttlebone; squid are slim tubes with a flexible pen.
Is squid ink actually cuttlefish ink?
Often. Traditional Mediterranean black ink dishes use cuttlefish ink.
Which tastes better, cuttlefish or squid?
Taste varies; cuttlefish is thicker and slightly sweeter, squid more tender in thin cuts.
Is cuttlefish a fish?
No. It is a mollusc, a cephalopod related to squid and octopus.
Can people allergic to squid eat cuttlefish?
Not safely without medical advice; cross-reactions are common among molluscs.
Why is cuttlefish rarely sold in the USA?
Cuttlefish do not live in the Americas, so it must be imported.
- Jereb, P. and Roper, C. F. E. (eds) (2005), Cephalopods of the World, Vol. 1: Chambered nautiluses and sepioids, FAO
- Lupše, N. et al. (2023), molecular and morphological revision of the genera of the cuttlefish family Sepiidae
- FAO, Fishery and Aquaculture Statistics: cephalopod capture production
- Regulation (EU) No 1379/2013 on the common organisation of the markets in fishery and aquaculture products (labelling)
- WoRMS, World Register of Marine Species: Sepiidae
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.
About Blane Perun →