Types of Sea Urchins — From Pencil Urchins to Sand Dollars: The Echinoid Family Tree
There are about 950 living sea urchin species (class Echinoidea). They fall into two broad body types: regular urchins, round with long spines and a five-toothed jaw, and irregular urchins, flattened or heart-shaped burrowers such as sand dollars and heart urchins. Among regular urchins, the main groups are the pencil urchins (cidaroids), the long-spined urchins (diadematids), the soft-bodied fire and leather urchins, and the large camarodont group that includes most familiar and edible species.
Yes. Sand dollars are irregular sea urchins, flattened for life in sand. Their short, velvety spines and tube feet move food particles to a central mouth. The white “dollar” on the beach is the bleached test. Heart urchins (sea potatoes) are another irregular group.
What are the main types of sea urchins?
Six groups cover almost every urchin a diver, beachcomber or aquarist will meet.
| Group | Examples | Key features |
|---|---|---|
| Pencil urchins (Cidaroida) | Eucidaris tribuloides, Phyllacanthus imperialis, Cidaris | Few, thick, widely spaced spines often encrusted with growth; oldest living lineage |
| Long-spined urchins (Diadematidae) | Diadema, Echinothrix, Astropyga | Very long, thin, hollow, brittle spines; often venomous; react to shadows |
| Fire and leather urchins (Echinothuriidae) | Asthenosoma, Araeosoma | Soft, flexible test; venomous spines in fire urchins; most species deep-sea |
| Camarodonts | Purple, red, green, collector, flower, tuxedo, shingle and burrowing urchins; the red slate pencil urchin | Most familiar and edible urchins; strong lanterns |
| Sand dollars and sea biscuits (Clypeasteroida) | Dendraster, Clypeaster, Encope | Flat, short velvety spines; live in sand |
| Heart urchins (Spatangoida) and other burrowers | Sea potato, Meoma, deep-sea pourtalesiids | Heart- or bottle-shaped; burrow; no lantern |
Scientists put the number of living sea urchin species at roughly 950, and a 2018 phylogenomic study by Nicolás Mongiardino Koch and colleagues counted “a little over 1000”. The fossil record holds more than 10,000 described species, so the urchins alive today are a small surviving slice of a very old group. All of them belong to the class Echinoidea, from the Greek word for hedgehog, and all share the same basic plan: a hard internal shell called a test, built from interlocking plates of calcium carbonate, covered in movable spines and pierced by rows of holes for tube feet.
Formal classification splits the class into two branches. The cidaroids, or pencil urchins, form one; every other living urchin belongs to the Euechinoidea, the “true” or modern urchins. Within the euechinoids, biologists recognise more than a dozen orders, but most of them sort neatly into the six practical groups in the table above. Those groups match what you can actually see on a reef or a beach: spine shape, body outline and whether the animal grazes on rock or burrows in sand.
The everyday split between regular and irregular urchins cuts across that family tree. “Sea urchin” in the strict sense means the regular, globe-shaped animals. Sand dollars, sea biscuits and heart urchins are irregular echinoids, grouped together as the Irregularia. They are sea urchins in every biological sense, but they look so different that most people do not recognise them as relatives until they see the five-part pattern on a bleached test.

What is the difference between regular and irregular urchins?
Shape, lifestyle and jaws.
Regular urchins are round with the mouth centred below and the anus on top, five-part radial symmetry, long spines and a full Aristotle’s lantern. They live on hard bottoms and graze. Irregular urchins have evolved a front and back for burrowing: the anus has moved off the top, spines are short and dense, and the lantern is reduced (sand dollars) or lost (heart urchins). They feed on organic particles in sediment.
The difference starts with the skeleton. In a regular urchin, the test is divided into ten double columns of plates running from mouth to anus: five narrow ambulacral zones, each perforated with pairs of pores for the tube feet, alternating with five wider interambulacral zones. Every plate carries rounded bumps called tubercles, and each spine sits on one of them in a ball-and-socket joint. Muscles at the base tilt the spine, and a collar of collagen fibres can stiffen and lock it in place. Because all five sectors are the same, a regular urchin has no front end and no preferred direction of travel.
Irregular urchins rebuilt that plan for life in sediment. The body developed a front and a back, so these animals are secondarily bilateral even though the five-part pattern survives. On the upper surface, the tube feet of each ambulacrum are concentrated into a flattened, petal-shaped area called a petaloid, used mainly for breathing. Sand dollars and heart urchins have no gills around the mouth, so those tube feet do most of the gas exchange. Regular urchins usually have five gonads; most irregular forms have four, and heart urchins only three or two.
What are pencil urchins?
The oldest surviving urchin lineage, with thick, blunt spines.
Cidaroids have fewer, heavier primary spines, set much further apart than in other urchins. Once they are fully grown, the main spines lose their outer skin, so algae, sponges and other small organisms settle on them; a cidaroid often looks furry or encrusted rather than glossy. Other primitive features include a relatively simple test and a series of plates that continues across the soft membrane around the mouth. Cidaroids also lack the gill slits of modern urchins, and they are the one group without the small balance organs, called sphaeridia, that most other urchins use to sense gravity.
Shallow-water members include Eucidaris tribuloides of the Caribbean and western Atlantic and Phyllacanthus imperialis of the Indo-Pacific. Eucidaris lives from about Cape Hatteras south to Rio de Janeiro and is described as a sluggish, nocturnal animal that hides in crevices by day. Many other cidaroids live in deep water, including Cidaris abyssicola, found several kilometres down.
The name “slate pencil urchin” causes real confusion. It is used for Eucidaris tribuloides, a true cidaroid, and also for the red slate pencil urchin of Hawaii, Heterocentrotus mamillatus. Despite the shared name, Heterocentrotus is not a cidaroid at all. It belongs to the family Echinometridae within the camarodonts, and its thick, ringed spines evolved separately. See slate pencil urchin and pencil urchin.
What are long-spined urchins?
The family Diadematidae: needle-like spines and a surprising ability to track shadows.
Diadematids carry long, hollow, brittle spines on a rigid or flexible test. The family includes Diadema, the black urchins found on reefs around the tropics; Echinothrix, with banded spines; Centrostephanus, which reaches cooler waters off south-eastern Australia and the Mediterranean; and Astropyga. Unlike most urchins, diadematids have eye spots, so they can swing their spines toward an approaching shadow. Divers who reach toward one usually see the spines converge on the hand before it gets close.
Astropyga radiata shows how varied the family can be. Its test reaches about 20 cm across and is flattened on top, with five bare V-shaped zones lined with rows of iridescent blue dots. It lives on sand and rubble in Indo-Pacific lagoons, usually at 10–30 m, and often gathers in groups. Common names for it include red urchin, false fire urchin and blue-spotted urchin. Small fish, shrimps and crabs shelter among its spines, and one crab carries the urchin on its back as a living shield.
The best-known species, Diadema antillarum of the Caribbean, is covered on the long-spined urchin page.
What are fire and leather urchins?
Soft-bodied urchins whose tests flex under pressure.
The family Echinothuriidae is nearly unique among urchins because its test is flexible. Its plates are thin, weakly calcified and not always joined, so the body is a soft, bulging disc that can flatten when handled. Most members live in the deep sea and are called leather urchins. Spines on the underside end in a small translucent hoof that helps the animal walk on soft mud. The family appears to have arisen near the end of the Cretaceous.
The shallow-water genus Asthenosoma includes the fire urchins. Asthenosoma varium grows to about 25 cm across and lives on sand and rubble from the Red Sea to Australia and southern Japan. In this species the plates overlap like roof tiles. Its upper spines carry small venom-filled swellings below the tip that work like hypodermic syringes, and a sting can stay painful for several hours. Commensal shrimps and the zebra crab live on it, which makes it a favourite subject for macro photographers who know to keep their hands well clear.
What are camarodonts?
The large modern group that contains most familiar, edible and aquarium urchins.
Camarodonts are globular urchins with compound ambulacral plates and a powerful lantern whose teeth carry a keel. They have existed since the Early Cretaceous. The order includes the families Echinidae, Echinometridae, Strongylocentrotidae, Toxopneustidae, Parechinidae, Temnopleuridae and others. If you have eaten uni, watched an urchin on a rocky shore or kept one in a tank, it was very likely a camarodont.
The Strongylocentrotidae include the temperate kelp-forest urchins of the North Pacific and North Atlantic, such as the red sea urchin, the purple sea urchin and the green urchin. The Toxopneustidae include the collector urchin, Tripneustes gratilla, which grows to 10–15 cm and covers itself with shell and rubble, and the variegated or green urchin Lytechinus variegatus of the western Atlantic, which reaches about 11 cm and can occur at 15 per square metre in seagrass. The same family holds the flower urchin, Toxopneustes pileolus, whose short spines are usually hidden under a carpet of flower-like pincers.
The Echinometridae are the rock specialists. Echinometra mathaei, about 5 cm across, uses its teeth and spines to bore into reef rock across the Indo-Pacific, and it can erode reefs where fishing has removed its predators. The shingle or helmet urchin, Colobocentrotus atratus, has turned its upper spines into a smooth mosaic of flat plates and clings to wave-battered Hawaiian shores; in tests it resisted being washed off about three times better than Echinometra. The red slate pencil urchin also belongs here. In the Temnopleuridae, the small tuxedo urchin, Mespilia globulus, reaches about 5 cm and has bare blue-green bands between rows of short spines.
Two further modern orders are easy to confuse with camarodonts. The Arbacioida include Arbacia punctulata, the Atlantic purple urchin of the US East Coast, which reaches about 8 cm and is a classic laboratory animal. The Pedinoida and Salenioida are small, mostly deep or obscure groups that rarely appear in field guides.
What are sand dollars and sea biscuits?
Flattened urchins built for life on and under loose sand.
Sand dollars and sea biscuits make up the order Clypeasteroida. Their tests are flat or gently domed, and in life they are covered in a velvet of short spines lined with cilia, coloured green, blue, violet or purple depending on the species. Coordinated beating of those spines moves the animal through sand. Many species have slots called lunules cut through the test, which help keep the animal anchored when waves pass. The name comes from the bleached tests that wash up on beaches, which reminded earlier beachcombers of a large silver coin such as the old Spanish dollar. Other names include sea cookie, sand cake and, in South Africa, pansy shell.
Most sand dollars average three to four inches across. The Pacific or eccentric sand dollar, Dendraster excentricus, lives from Alaska to Baja California, averages about 76 mm, and has its flower pattern set off-centre, which gives the species its name. Sea biscuits such as Clypeaster rosaceus of the Caribbean are thicker and puffier. Sand dollars keep a reduced lantern, which is why the small “doves” rattle inside a dried test. The first true sand dollar genus, Togocyamus, appears in the Paleocene, and modern-looking groups follow in the Eocene. Molecular work suggests that some cassiduloids, a small group of rounded burrowers with only a handful of living species, sit inside the sand dollar branch. See sand dollar.
What are heart urchins?
Burrowing, heart-shaped urchins with no jaw at all.
Heart urchins, order Spatangoida, have an elongated oval body with the mouth near the front and the anus at the back, which produces the heart outline. They have no lantern. Instead, cilia around the mouth pull strings of mucus carrying food particles into the mouth, and the animal feeds on organic matter in the sediment it burrows through. Their petaloids are often sunk into grooves on the upper surface.
The common heart urchin or sea potato, Echinocardium cordatum, is typical. It is 6–9 cm long, covered in a dense mat of backward-pointing yellowish spines, and lives buried in sandy sea floors across temperate seas. The spines trap air that helps the buried animal avoid suffocation. Its white, papery test is a common find on European beaches after storms. In the Caribbean, Meoma ventricosa is a much larger heart urchin that lives in sand near reefs.
The related order Holasteroida pushes the burrowing design to an extreme. Its deep-sea pourtalesiids are bottle-shaped, strongly bilateral and also jawless. The genus Pourtalesia was named after Louis-François de Pourtalès, who first dredged the animals from about 600 m. The family now holds around 28 living species.
Which types of sea urchins live in the deep sea?
Leather urchins, many cidaroids and the bottle-shaped pourtalesiids.
Many genera live only in the abyss, including many cidaroids, most echinothuriids and the “cactus urchins” of the genus Dermechinus. Pourtalesiids hold the depth record for the class, collected about 6,850 m down in the Sunda Trench. Even so, urchins are the shallowest-living class of echinoderms. Brittle stars, starfish and crinoids remain abundant below 8,000 m, and sea cucumbers have been recorded below 10,600 m. Most urchin species live on temperate and tropical coasts within a few tens of metres of the surface, close to the algae and other food that sunlight supports.
How can you tell the types apart?
Look at the spines first, then the outline, then where the animal lives.
Long, thin, hollow spines that move toward your shadow point to a diadematid. Thick, blunt, widely spaced spines coated with growth suggest a cidaroid, while thick spines with clean colour bands and a camarodont body suggest Heterocentrotus. A soft, flexible body that dents when pressed means an echinothuriid, and any such animal in shallow tropical water should be treated as a fire urchin. A dense coat of pincers that look like small flowers is the mark of the flower urchin. A rounded urchin with short to medium spines that grazes on rock or carries debris is almost certainly a camarodont. Anything flat, oval or heart-shaped that lives in sand is an irregular urchin.
Dead tests are easier still. A regular urchin test is round with a large hole underneath for the mouth and a smaller one on top. A sand dollar test is flat with a five-petal pattern on top and often slots through it. A heart urchin test is thin and fragile, with a groove at the front and the mouth set toward one end of the underside.
Which types of sea urchins are dangerous?
Long-spined urchins, fire and leather urchins, and the flower urchin.
Diadematids have brittle, venom-coated spines; echinothuriids have venomous spine tips; and the flower urchin, a camarodont, has venomous pincers and is widely regarded as the most dangerous urchin. The generic name Toxopneustes literally means “poison breath”. Most urchin injuries, however, are simple punctures from spines that snap off in the skin. They hurt, and spines left in place can cause infection, granulomas or a purple-black stain from the urchin’s pigment. Breathing difficulty after a sting may mean a serious reaction and needs medical help. See flower urchins and can you touch sea urchins?
Which types are popular in aquariums?
Tuxedo, pincushion and pencil urchins.
These are reef-safe algae grazers. Tuxedo urchins have distinctive blue-black bands; pincushion urchins have short, colourful spines. Avoid long-spined species unless you know how to handle them. Aquarists like the tuxedo urchin for its small size and its habit of decorating itself with bits of shell and rubble. Pencil urchins are hardy and slow, but some will nibble coral or other invertebrates, so keepers often choose them for fish-only or mixed tanks. Sand dollars and heart urchins rarely do well in captivity because they need deep, food-rich sand. See tuxedo urchins and pincushion urchin.
How old are the main groups?
Echinoids go back about 465 million years; most modern groups are far younger.
Echinoids go back about 465 million years to the Middle Ordovician. Their tough tests fossilise well, which makes them useful to geologists for dating and correlating rocks. Early urchins had thin tests and probably lived in quiet water. The group nearly vanished at the end of the Paleozoic, with only six species known from the Permian. Two lineages crossed into the Triassic: the line through Miocidaris that led to modern pencil urchins, and the ancestor of all euechinoids. Cidaroids have changed little since the Late Triassic.
The euechinoids then radiated in the Jurassic and Cretaceous. The first irregular urchins appeared in the Early Jurassic, camarodonts and holasteroids in the Early Cretaceous, echinothuriids near its end, and sand dollars in the Paleogene. Some extinct heart urchins, such as Micraster in the chalk of southern England and northern Europe, evolved so steadily that geologists use them as zone fossils.
How big do sea urchins get?
Most are 3–10 cm across; the largest reach about 36 cm.
The biggest urchins are deep-sea species. Among shallow-water species, red sea urchins are giants. The smallest urchins are only a few millimetres across. Spine length varies as much as body size: most species have spines of 3–10 cm, but the black long-spined urchins can carry spines up to 30 cm. Among shallow tropical species, the fire urchin Asthenosoma varium reaches about 25 cm, Astropyga radiata about 20 cm and the flower urchin 15–20 cm, while the tuxedo urchin and the rock-boring Echinometra stay near 5 cm.
How many types of sea urchins are there?
About 950 living species by older counts, and a little over 1,000 by a 2018 estimate, sorted into roughly a dozen orders.
Is a sand dollar a sea urchin?
Yes. It is an irregular sea urchin in the order Clypeasteroida, flattened for life in sand.
What is the biggest type of sea urchin?
Some deep-sea species reach about 36 cm across. In shallow water, the red urchin and the fire urchin (to about 25 cm) are among the largest.
What is a heart urchin?
A burrowing, heart-shaped irregular urchin with no jaw, also called a sea potato.
Which sea urchins are venomous?
Long-spined diadematids, fire and leather urchins, and the flower urchin.
What is the oldest group of sea urchins?
The cidaroids, or pencil urchins, which descend from one of only two lineages to survive the end-Permian extinction.
Is the slate pencil urchin a pencil urchin?
Only sometimes. The name covers the Atlantic cidaroid Eucidaris tribuloides and the Indo-Pacific Heterocentrotus mamillatus, which is a camarodont.
Which sea urchins have soft bodies?
Leather and fire urchins in the family Echinothuriidae, whose tests flex because the plates are not rigidly joined.
- Mongiardino Koch, N. et al. (2018). A phylogenomic resolution of the sea urchin tree of life. BMC Evolutionary Biology 18: 189. Living species count (a little over 1,000), more than 10,000 fossil species, relationships among cidaroids, echinothurioids, Irregularia, sand dollars and cassiduloids.
- Sea urchin, Wikipedia (summary of primary literature). Species count, anatomy, size range, depth record, fossil history, venomous families, regular vs irregular anatomy.
- World Register of Marine Species (via Wikipedia family and order pages). Cidaroida, Diadematidae, Echinothuriidae, Camarodonta, Clypeasteroida, Spatangoida, Holasteroida and Pourtalesiidae composition and characters.
- Species accounts: Eucidaris tribuloides, Heterocentrotus mamillatus, Astropyga radiata, Asthenosoma varium, Tripneustes gratilla, Lytechinus variegatus, Echinometra mathaei, Colobocentrotus atratus, Mespilia globulus, Arbacia punctulata, Dendraster excentricus, Echinocardium cordatum, Toxopneustes pileolus.
- Guinness World Records. Flower urchin as the most dangerous sea urchin.
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.
About Blane Perun →