How Does Carbon Dioxide Affect Sea Urchins? — Acidifying Seas Make Every Spine and Skeleton More Expensive
When carbon dioxide dissolves in seawater it forms carbonic acid, so rising atmospheric CO2 is making the ocean more acidic: pH has fallen from about 8.2 to 8.1 in 200 years, a roughly 30% increase in acidity. Sea urchins build their skeletons, spines and larval rods from calcium carbonate, so acidification hits them in several ways: larvae grow and calcify more slowly, they spend more energy controlling internal pH, and in some studies adults grow more slowly or have weaker spines. Effects vary widely by species and population.
They are calcifiers, their larvae are easy to raise, their genome is sequenced, and they are ecologically important. Oceanographers monitor urchin health and populations as one way of gauging how marine life responds to acidification.
How does CO2 make the ocean more acidic?
CO2 reacts with seawater to form carbonic acid, releasing hydrogen ions and using up carbonate.
The ocean absorbs more than a quarter of the carbon dioxide released into the atmosphere. Dissolved CO2 forms carbonic acid, which releases hydrogen ions (lowering pH) and ties up carbonate ions, the building blocks calcifying animals need. So acidification both raises acidity and reduces the raw material for shells and skeletons.

How does acidification affect sea urchin larvae?
It slows their growth and skeleton building.
Urchin larvae (plutei) are held up by calcium carbonate rods and must build them quickly while drifting. A 2012 study led by Meike Stumpp at GEOMAR, published in PNAS, found that green sea urchin larvae in acidified seawater grew and built their skeletons more slowly and took longer to develop. The cause was energy: larvae had to spend more energy keeping the fluid in their calcifying cells at the right pH, leaving less for growth. Longer larval life in the plankton means more time exposed to predators.
| Life stage | Reported effects of higher CO2 | Strength of evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Larvae | Slower growth and calcification; longer development | Strong, many studies |
| Juveniles | Slower growth in some species | Moderate |
| Adults | Higher energy costs; weaker spines or slower growth in some studies | Mixed, species-dependent |
| Fertilisation | Reduced success at high CO2 in some experiments | Mixed |
Are all sea urchins equally affected?
No. Responses vary between species and even between populations.
Urchins from places with naturally variable pH, such as upwelling coasts where CO2-rich deep water regularly rises to the surface, often cope better than those from stable conditions. Purple urchins on the US West Coast, for example, experience low-pH upwelling events naturally, and researchers have found evidence of local adaptation. This variability is why a single headline number for “urchin decline” would be misleading.
Will acidification help or hurt kelp forests?
It could cut both ways, and warming is the bigger immediate threat.
If acidification slows urchin growth and recruitment, it could ease grazing pressure on kelp. But warming water, marine heatwaves and loss of predators are currently reshaping kelp forests far faster, as the 2014–2017 Northern California collapse showed. Meanwhile coral reefs, where urchins graze algae, are themselves weakened by acidification. See ocean acidification and coral reefs and sea urchins eating kelp.
Why is an urchin skeleton so sensitive to seawater chemistry?
Because it is made of a form of calcium carbonate that dissolves more easily than most.
An urchin’s test, spines and teeth are built from magnesium-rich calcite. The more magnesium a calcite contains, the more soluble it is, so urchin skeletons are among the more chemically vulnerable carbonate structures in the sea. Each skeletal plate is a single, sponge-like crystal riddled with pores and filled with living tissue, which makes it light and strong but also means a large surface area is in contact with body fluids.
To build skeleton, specialised cells concentrate calcium and carbonate and lay down mineral inside a sealed compartment, partly through an unstable precursor called amorphous calcium carbonate. That process works best when the surrounding seawater is well saturated with carbonate. As CO2 rises and carbonate falls, the animal has to pump more ions and acid to keep its internal chemistry on track. This is the extra cost that shows up as slower growth in many experiments.

How does high CO2 affect adult sea urchins?
Adults are tougher than larvae, but they still pay a metabolic price.
When seawater CO2 rises, CO2 also builds up in the urchin’s body fluid (the coelomic fluid), and its pH falls. Some species can partly buffer this, for example by raising bicarbonate levels, but many urchins have limited ability to regulate the chemistry of their body fluid compared with fish or crabs. Studies on different species have reported effects such as slower growth, smaller gonads, reduced feeding, slower spine regrowth after damage and changes in the strength of spines or teeth. Other studies found little measurable effect at the CO2 levels expected this century. The overall picture is that adults usually survive moderate acidification, but less energy may be left for growth and reproduction.
What do natural CO2 vents tell us about the future?
Where volcanic CO2 bubbles from the seafloor, urchins tend to thin out or disappear close to the most acidic water.
Shallow volcanic vents, such as those off the island of Ischia in Italy, release CO2 that lowers local seawater pH. They act as natural laboratories for studying long-term acidification. Researchers working at these sites have reported that sea urchins and many other calcifying animals become scarce or absent near the strongest vents, while seagrasses and some fleshy seaweeds do well. The vents are not a perfect model, since pH fluctuates and animals can drift in from outside, but they suggest that whole communities shift as acidification increases, not just individual species.
How do warming and low oxygen interact with acidification?
They often add up. Urchins rarely face just one stress at a time.
Rising CO2 is arriving together with warming seas, more frequent marine heatwaves and, in some regions, lower oxygen levels. Warmer water raises an urchin’s metabolic rate and oxygen demand at the same time that acidification adds energy costs, so the combination can be more damaging than either factor alone. In some experiments mild warming has partly offset acidification effects on larval growth, but beyond a species’ thermal limit the combined stress tends to reduce survival. Heat stress has also been linked to outbreaks of disease in urchins, adding another layer of risk. See how long do sea urchins live?
What does this mean for urchin fisheries and people?
Possibly slower-growing stocks and more variable harvests, layered on top of existing pressures.
Sea urchins support valuable fisheries for uni in Japan, Chile, the US West Coast, Maine, Atlantic Canada and Europe. If acidification reduces larval survival or slows growth, fewer young urchins may reach harvestable size, and roe quality could be affected where adults have less energy to put into gonads. Because urchins also control seaweed on reefs and kelp beds, changes in their numbers can ripple out to fisheries for fish and lobsters that depend on those habitats. Researchers now monitor seawater carbonate chemistry alongside temperature in many urchin-producing regions. See sea urchins in Maine and red sea urchins.

How does carbon dioxide affect sea urchins?
It acidifies seawater, slowing larval growth and skeleton building and increasing the energy urchins spend on pH control.
Does ocean acidification dissolve sea urchins?
Not at today’s levels in most places, but it makes calcification harder and can weaken spines and skeletons.
Are sea urchin larvae affected by acidification?
Yes. Larvae are the most sensitive stage, growing and calcifying more slowly.
Can sea urchins adapt to ocean acidification?
Some populations from naturally variable upwelling coasts show greater tolerance.
How much has ocean pH changed?
From about 8.2 to 8.1 over 200 years, roughly 30% more acidic.
Why do scientists study urchins for acidification?
They are calcifiers, easy to raise and ecologically important.
Will sea urchins go extinct because of ocean acidification?
There is no evidence that urchins as a group face extinction from acidification. The concern is reduced growth, recruitment and abundance in some species and places, especially combined with warming.
Does warmer water make acidification worse for urchins?
Often yes. Warming raises energy and oxygen demands, so combined with acidification it can reduce survival more than either stress alone, though mild warming sometimes offsets effects on larvae.
- U.S. National Park Service. Ocean acidification basics: CO2 uptake, pH change, 30% acidity increase.
- Stumpp, M. et al. (2012), PNAS 10.1073/pnas.1209174109. Acidified seawater impacts sea urchin larvae pH regulatory systems relevant for calcification (GEOMAR).
- Sea urchin, Wikipedia. Urchins as indicators for acidification monitoring.
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.
About Blane Perun →