Slate Pencil Urchin — Spines as Thick as Chalk
The slate pencil urchin, Heterocentrotus mamillatus, is an Indo-Pacific urchin with a body that can exceed 8 cm across and thick, blunt spines up to about 10 cm long. It lives on reefs from the Red Sea and East Africa to Hawaii, usually at about 8–25 m, wedged in crevices by day. Its thick spines resemble the old slate pencils schoolchildren wrote with, which gave it its name.
The first time I saw a slate pencil urchin under a Hawaiian ledge, I thought someone had stuck a bundle of red crayons into the rock.
What is a slate pencil urchin?
Heterocentrotus mamillatus is a tropical sea urchin in the family Echinometridae, the same family as the burrowing rock-boring urchins. Its primary spines are unusually thick, blunt and roughly triangular in cross-section, and can reach about 10 cm. The body itself, often hidden, can exceed 8 cm in diameter. The spines may be a different color from the body: usually reddish-brown to deep red, sometimes with pale bands, and some observers note the red spines look chalky pink at night.A close relative, Heterocentrotus trigonarius, has more slender, sharply three-sided spines and is also called a slate pencil urchin. In the Atlantic, the much smaller pencil urchin (Eucidaris tribuloides) is a different family altogether.

Why is it called a slate pencil urchin?
Before paper was cheap, students wrote on small slate boards with sticks of soft slate. The thick, smooth, blunt primary spines of this urchin look like those old slate pencils, and that resemblance is the whole story behind the name. The name is used loosely: in eastern Australia the Australian Museum applies “slate pencil urchin” to the cidarid Phyllacanthus parvispinus, and in the Atlantic it is used for Eucidaris. Today the spines are best known as material for wind chimes and jewelry sold in shell shops.
Where does Heterocentrotus mamillatus live?
It is widespread in the tropical Indo-Pacific, from the Red Sea, including the shores of the Sinai Peninsula, and East Africa east to Hawaii and other central Pacific islands. It is common in Hawaii and has been recorded at remote sites such as French Frigate Shoals. Reports place it on reefs at about 8–25 m, with juveniles hiding under rocks and adults wedging into holes and crevices with their spines.
How does the slate pencil urchin behave?
It is more active than many reef urchins. A field study cited in species accounts found individuals moving an average of 96 cm a day and up to 600 cm from their starting point. It shelters by day and moves to graze at night. The thick spines are built to resist breakage: research on the spines has shown that their layered structure lets damage dissipate gradually instead of snapping at once, which makes them a model for impact-resistant materials.
What does it eat?
Mainly algae, especially turf and coralline algae scraped from rock with its Aristotle’s lantern, the five-toothed jaw of sea urchins. Like other grazers it helps keep algae in check on the reef. Read more in sea urchins diet.
How does it reproduce?
Sexes are separate. Gametogenesis begins around January, and by May the gonads are almost completely filled with gametes, after which the urchins spawn eggs and sperm into the water. Larvae drift as plankton before settling. A small shrimp, Levicaris mammillata, has been found living on its spines in Hawaii, the Ogasawara Islands and the Ryukyu Islands.
Is the slate pencil urchin dangerous?
No. Its spines are blunt and not venomous, and it is one of the safest urchins to handle gently. That said, wild urchins should be left where they are.
Can you keep a slate pencil urchin in an aquarium?
It is sold in the aquarium trade and is hardy in large fish-only or rock-heavy systems. In a reef tank it is less safe: its size and strong spines let it bulldoze rockwork and loose corals, and it may eat coralline algae. It needs stable salinity (species accounts give about 32–35 ppt), plenty of algae or supplemental seaweed, and a tank with secure rockwork.
- Not venomous and easy to handle.
- Big and strong: it moves unglued frags and rocks.
- Eats coralline algae.
- Needs stable, full-strength salinity.
How to identify a slate pencil urchin
Look at the spines first. Few reef urchins carry spines this thick, this blunt and this few in number.
A slate pencil urchin has two kinds of spines. The long primary spines are the famous ones: thick, heavy, round to roughly three-sided in cross-section and blunt at the tip, often reddish-brown to deep red with paler bands. Between and below them sits a dense layer of very short, flattened secondary spines that pack together around the test like paving stones. That combination, a few big “pencils” sticking out of a tight mosaic of tiny flat spines, is the quickest way to recognise the genus Heterocentrotus.
The two Heterocentrotus species are the ones most often confused. H. mamillatus has the thicker, more rounded spines and is the one usually sold as the red slate pencil urchin. H. trigonarius has more slender spines with sharper, clearly triangular edges, and tends to be paler or browner. Other urchins that share the name are easy to separate once you know them: cidarids such as Eucidaris and Phyllacanthus have spines that are often crusted with growth and lack the flat mosaic of secondary spines, and their test is usually more visible between the spines.
- Primary spines: thick, blunt, up to about 10 cm, usually red to red-brown.
- Secondary spines: short, flat-topped and tightly packed around the body.
- Habit: wedged into reef holes by day, spines pointing outward.
- Not to confuse with: H. trigonarius (slimmer, sharper-edged spines) or the Atlantic pencil urchin.
Anatomy: test, tube feet and Aristotle’s lantern
Under the spines, the slate pencil urchin is built like every other sea urchin. Its body is a rigid shell, the test, made of fused calcite plates arranged in the five-part pattern shared by all echinoderms. Each spine sits on a small knob on the test and moves on a ball-and-socket joint controlled by muscles, which is how the urchin can lock its spines against the walls of a crevice and become almost impossible to pull out.
Rows of tube feet emerge through tiny pores in the test. They are powered by the water vascular system, a network of fluid-filled canals unique to echinoderms, and they let the urchin grip rock, climb walls and pass food toward the mouth. On the underside sits the Aristotle’s lantern, a jaw apparatus with five self-sharpening teeth that scrapes algae from hard surfaces. Small pincer-like organs called pedicellariae, scattered over the test, help keep the surface clean of settling larvae and debris.
What role does it play on the reef?
Grazing urchins are part of the reef’s cleaning crew. By scraping turf algae from dead coral and rock, slate pencil urchins help keep bare surfaces open for coral larvae to settle, and they compete with fish such as surgeonfish and parrotfish for the same food. Because members of its family scrape and wear down limestone as they feed, urchins like this one also contribute to bioerosion, the slow breakdown of reef rock that recycles calcium carbonate into sand.
Their spines provide shelter, too. Besides the small commensal shrimp mentioned above, juvenile fish and other tiny invertebrates are sometimes seen sheltering among urchin spines on Indo-Pacific reefs. A healthy population of grazers is generally a sign of a balanced reef; problems tend to arise only when urchins become extremely abundant or disappear entirely.
Predators, threats and conservation
Thick spines are a strong defence, but not a perfect one. Triggerfish, some large wrasses and pufferfish are well-known urchin predators on Indo-Pacific reefs, and some triggerfish are known to flip urchins or attack them from the less-protected underside. Hiding in crevices by day and feeding at night reduces that exposure.
People are the other pressure. The spines and cleaned tests are collected for the curio and craft trade, and live animals are exported for aquariums. Like other reef animals, slate pencil urchins also depend on the health of the reef itself, so coral loss, pollution and habitat damage affect them indirectly. The species remains widespread and is regularly seen in places such as Hawaii, and there is no clear evidence that it is globally threatened, but local collection is best kept light and sustainable.
Where to see one in the wild
Hawaii is one of the easiest places to find slate pencil urchins, and snorkelers sometimes spot them in clear, shallow water over rocky reef, although most live a little deeper. Elsewhere in the Indo-Pacific they turn up on reef slopes from the Red Sea to Micronesia. The best approach is slow and patient: check holes, ledges and the undersides of boulders, especially late in the day when they begin to emerge.
Look, photograph and leave it in place. Pulling an urchin from its crevice can damage its spines, tube feet and the surrounding coral. If you want spines as a keepsake, buy them from a reputable source rather than collecting from the reef.
Is the slate pencil urchin poisonous?
No. Its spines are blunt and not venomous.
Where do slate pencil urchins live?
On Indo-Pacific reefs from the Red Sea and East Africa to Hawaii, usually at about 8 to 25 m.
How big do slate pencil urchins get?
The body can exceed 8 cm across, with spines up to about 10 cm.
What do slate pencil urchins eat?
Mainly algae scraped from rock, including coralline algae.
Are slate pencil urchins reef safe?
Not fully. They knock over rocks and corals and may eat coralline algae.
What is the difference between a pencil urchin and a slate pencil urchin?
The Atlantic pencil urchin is the small cidarid Eucidaris tribuloides. The slate pencil urchin is the larger Indo-Pacific Heterocentrotus.
What are slate pencil urchin spines used for?
They are sold for wind chimes, jewelry and decor.
Can a slate pencil urchin regrow its spines?
Yes. Like other sea urchins it can regenerate broken spines over time, although a regrown spine may look slightly different from the original.
- Wikipedia contributors. Heterocentrotus mamillatus (size, depth, movement, reproduction).
- Ogden et al. (1989), movement data as cited in species accounts.
- Australian Museum. Slate pencil urchin (Phyllacanthus parvispinus).
- WoRMS. Heterocentrotus mamillatus (Linnaeus, 1758).
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.
About Blane Perun →