Sand Sifting Starfish — The Burrowing Comb Star
The sand sifting starfish, or comb sea star (Astropecten polyacanthus), is a flat, five-armed sea star that spends the day buried in sand and hunts at night. It is the most widespread Astropecten, found throughout the Indo-Pacific from the Red Sea to Hawaii, at depths to about 185–222 m. Its arm spread is roughly 12–20 cm. It swallows small clams and snails whole and digs with pointed tube feet that lack suckers. It carries tetrodotoxin, the pufferfish toxin. In aquariums it clears detritus but often strips the sand bed of life and then starves.
On a night dive over a sandy lagoon you sometimes see a neat star-shaped outline in the sand. Wait, and a comb star may rise out of it and start gliding across the bottom.
What does a sand sifting starfish look like?
The upper surface is dark purplish to gray, while the underside is orange. The top is covered in paxillae, tiny pillars with flattened, fuzzy tops, colored cream, gray or brown and sometimes forming a chevron pattern. Along the edges of the five broad arms runs a fringe of long, sharp marginal spines with brown bases and pale tips, the “comb” behind its other common name. The species name polyacanthus means “many thorned.”

How big does it get?
Sources differ: SeaLifeBase gives a maximum of about 12 cm across, while other references give an arm spread of up to 20 cm, with individual arms up to about 9 cm long. Most aquarium specimens are 8–15 cm.
Where does the sand sifting starfish live?
In shallow tropical and subtropical seas throughout the Indo-Pacific: from the Red Sea and Zanzibar to Hawaii, and from Japan to Australia and New Zealand. In Australia it ranges from Cape Naturaliste in the west around the north coast to Sydney. It favors silty sand bottoms in harbors, lagoons and estuaries, and has been recorded down to about 185–222 m.
How does a sand sifting starfish move and dig?
Its tube feet are pointed rather than tipped with suckers, an adaptation shared with other Astropecten and Luidia species that lets it dig quickly and glide over sand faster than most starfish. It sinks into the sediment by working sand away with its tube feet and stays buried during the day, often with only a faint star outline visible.
Built for sand: what makes a comb star different
Comb stars belong to the order Paxillosida, and their whole body is shaped around life in soft sediment. The upper surface is covered in paxillae, from a Latin word meaning “little stakes”: tiny pillars with flattened, spiny tops that sit close together like a mat. Between them sit the papulae, soft, retractable outgrowths of the skin used in breathing. The arm edges carry two rows of large marginal plates, the upper (superomarginal) and lower (inferomarginal) series, and in Astropecten the lower plates bear the long, pointed spines that form the “comb.”
The tube feet are the other key difference. Most familiar sea stars, including the chocolate chip star and the blue sea star, walk on tube feet tipped with suckers. Astropecten has pointed tube feet without suckers, which are better for digging and for pushing across loose sand than for clinging to rock. That is why a comb star can glide quickly over a sandy bottom and sink out of sight so readily.
What does it eat?
It is a predator and detritus feeder. At night it crawls across the sand hunting small bivalves and snails buried in the sediment, which it swallows whole, digesting them inside the body and later expelling the shells. As a primitive starfish it cannot push its stomach out of its body the way chocolate chip stars do. It also swallows pebbles and digests the biofilm and tiny animals coating them.
Is the sand sifting starfish poisonous?
Yes, if eaten. Astropecten polyacanthus contains tetrodotoxin (TTX), the potent nerve toxin best known from pufferfish, for which there is no antidote. After a case of paralytic poisoning in Japan, investigators traced the toxin through a trumpet shell (Charonia) that had eaten these sea stars. In the follow-up study, most of the 54 comb stars tested contained TTX, with one scoring 520 mouse units per gram. Handling one is not dangerous, but never eat it, and wash your hands after handling any sea star.
The tetrodotoxin story in more detail
The discovery that a common comb star carries one of the most potent natural toxins began with a poisoning. In the early 1980s Japanese researchers investigated a case of paralytic poisoning caused by eating a trumpet shell, known locally as boshubora. They published their findings in 1982: the trumpet shell, reported as Charonia sauliae and now often treated under the name Charonia lampas, had acquired tetrodotoxin through its diet of Astropecten polyacanthus, which they found contained the toxin. Most of the 54 comb stars tested in the follow-up work contained TTX, and one scored 520 mouse units per gram, the unit used for TTX potency.
Later work refined the picture. In 1987, a team including H. Narita and T. Noguchi reported isolating a bacterium, Vibrio alginolyticus, that produces TTX from the starfish itself, supporting the idea that the toxin originates with microbes rather than being made by the sea star’s own cells. A Japanese research report from 1988 found that toxicity varied greatly between body parts: the ovary was by far the most toxic organ, at up to 12,700 mouse units per gram, followed by the digestive organs, and females were much more toxic overall than males. The researchers suggested that the sea star, like a TTX-bearing flatworm they studied alongside it, may use the toxin as a defense or alarm substance against predators. Related work has looked at the source of TTX in another species of the genus, Astropecten scoparius.
None of this makes a comb star dangerous to touch. The risk is to anyone who eats the animal, or eats a predator such as a trumpet shell that has fed on it. Tetrodotoxin blocks the sodium channels nerves use to fire, and there is no specific antidote.
Is it the same as the sand sifting star sold in stores?
Not always. The aquarium trade sells both Astropecten polyacanthus and the sand star Archaster typicus as “sand sifting starfish.” The two look similar because both evolved for burrowing, but Archaster has flat, blunt marginal spines and parallel radial rows of plates on top, while Astropecten has long, sharp spines.
Two different animals sold under one name
The aquarium trade uses “sand sifting star” for at least two unrelated sea stars, and they differ in more than looks. The second is Archaster typicus, often simply called the sand star. Its resemblance to Astropecten polyacanthus is a case of convergent evolution: both evolved similar shapes and colors for burrowing. But Archaster belongs to a different order, the Valvatida, and its tube feet have suckers rather than points. Its marginal spines are short, flat and blunt, and the small plates on top of its arms are lined up in neat parallel rows, which is the easiest way to tell the two apart in a photograph.
The two also feed differently. Archaster is a detritivore that pushes its stomach out through its mouth to engulf food, then draws it back in, the method used by most sea stars. Astropecten cannot do that; it swallows prey whole and later spits out the empty shells. For an aquarist the practical difference is significant, because a true Astropecten is a predator of the live animals in a sand bed, while Archaster mostly cleans up detritus.
The sand star’s unusual mating embrace
Archaster typicus is one of the few sea stars that pairs up before spawning. Adults grow to about 12–15 cm across, with males often smaller than females. It lives in the western Indian Ocean and the Indo-Pacific down to about 60 m, on sand, silt and seagrass. Its larvae settle among mangroves, and the animals move into seagrass and then onto open sand as they grow. It tends to bury itself during high tide and move over the surface at low tide.
The species reaches sexual maturity at a radius of about 29 mm. Around two months before spawning, the sea stars begin to gather. A male that recognizes a female, probably by chemical cues, climbs on top of her and may stay there for up to two months, a behavior called pseudocopulation. The female can still move and feed, while the male is more restricted. During that time the pair’s reproductive cycles become synchronized, so that when the female releases her eggs, the male releases sperm almost at the same moment. In the Philippines mating happens in September and October, and pair densities can reach seven pairs per square metre around the full moon, while at new moon none are seen.
Telling the sand star apart in the field
Beyond its parallel rows of arm plates and blunt marginal spines, Archaster typicus is grey or brownish, marked with darker and lighter patches that sometimes form a chevron pattern, with a pale underside. The body looks slightly inflated, and a whitish madreporite, the sieve plate of the water vascular system, sits near the centre of the disc. Most individuals have five long, slightly tapering arms with pointed tips, though three-, four- and six-armed animals turn up. Its recorded range takes in the Maldives, the Bay of Bengal, Singapore, northern Australia, New Caledonia, the Philippines, China, southern Japan and Hawaii.
One species, many names
The comb star’s variability shows in its long list of synonyms. Since Müller and Troschel described Astropecten polyacanthus in 1842, specimens from different places have been named as separate species, including Astropecten armatus and Astropecten hystrix (both by the same authors in the same year), Astropecten samoensis (Perrier, 1869), Astropecten edwardsi (Verrill, 1870), Astropecten chinensis (Grube, 1866) and Astropecten burbonica (Döderlein, 1917). All are now treated as the same animal. For a species ranging from the Red Sea to Hawaii, that is a reminder that color and spine length vary from place to place, and that the name on an aquarium label is only as good as the identification behind it.
Should you keep a sand sifting starfish in a reef tank?
Many hobbyists buy one to keep the sand clean, and it does turn over sand and eat leftover food. The problem is appetite: it also eats the worms, copepods, snails and other small animals that make a sand bed work, and in most tanks it eventually runs out of food and slowly starves. If you keep one:
- Use a large, mature tank with a deep, well-populated sand bed.
- Drip-acclimate slowly; like all sea stars it cannot tolerate sudden salinity changes.
- Target-feed meaty foods such as clam, mysis or sinking pellets near it at night.
- Watch for a shrinking, limp or curling body, a sign of starvation.
- Do not keep it with snails, clams or a sand bed you want full of life.
Relatives around the world
Astropecten is a large genus found in many seas, and its members share the same buried-by-day, hunt-by-night lifestyle. The species can look very similar, and positive identification sometimes needs a specimen in the laboratory or a genetic test; from photographs, specialists rely on the marginal plates and spines, the overall size and the shape of the disc and arms.
In the Mediterranean and the eastern Atlantic from Portugal to Angola lives the red comb star, Astropecten aranciacus, the largest Astropecten in the Mediterranean. It usually measures about 30 cm across and can reach 55 cm. It lives on sand, mud and gravel at depths of about 2 to 100 m. At low tide it buries itself, often leaving only the swollen centre of its upper side showing as a small cone that works as a sense organ; touch it and the cone contracts and the animal digs deeper. It is most active in the late afternoon and at night, and it hunts molluscs, catching them with its arms and passing them to the mouth.
Astropecten irregularis, a common species of the northeast Atlantic and Mediterranean, lives on mobile seabeds from about 1 m to roughly 1,000 m deep. It usually measures 10–12 cm, with a maximum of 19 cm, and its pinkish upper side often turns violet toward the arm tips. It too stays buried by day and hunts mainly bivalves at night. Its raised central bulge, which pokes out of the sediment while the rest of the animal is hidden, helps with respiration.
Finding comb stars on a night dive
For divers, sand sifting stars are a classic night-dive find on sandy lagoon floors, harbour bottoms and silty areas between reef patches. By day the best you will see is a faint star-shaped outline in the sand. After dark, sweep your light slowly over open sand and look for a flat star gliding along with its marginal spines fanned out, or for the small mounds and trails left where one has been digging.
Keep your fins high and avoid stirring up silt, which ruins visibility and buries the very animals you are looking for. Do not pick comb stars up: the pointed tube feet are delicate, and handling stresses the animal. Watching one sink back into the sand at the end of a night dive is reward enough.
A note on buying one
Before buying a “sand sifting star,” check which species is on offer. An Astropecten will hunt the worms, snails and small crustaceans in a sand bed, while Archaster is a detritus feeder with a different diet and a different set of needs. Either way, both live on soft sediment in the wild, so a small aquarium with a shallow, sparsely populated sand bed is a poor substitute.
How is it related to other sea stars?
It belongs to the order Paxillosida, considered one of the more primitive starfish groups because its members swallow prey whole and lack suckered tube feet. Compare it with the reef-dwelling blue sea star, the seagrass-loving chocolate chip sea star and the fast-moving brittle stars that share its sand.
What does a sand sifting starfish eat?
Small clams, snails and other sand-dwelling invertebrates, plus detritus.
Is the sand sifting starfish reef safe?
It leaves corals alone but eats beneficial sand-bed fauna and often starves.
Is the sand sifting starfish poisonous?
It contains tetrodotoxin; it is dangerous to eat, not to touch.
How big does a sand sifting starfish get?
About 12–20 cm across.
Why does my sand sifting star stay buried?
It is nocturnal and buries itself during the day.
How long can a sand sifting star live in a tank?
In small tanks it often starves within months; in large mature systems it can live much longer.
Where does it live in the wild?
Silty sand in harbors, lagoons and estuaries across the Indo-Pacific.
- SeaLifeBase: Astropecten polyacanthus summary (size, depth 0–222 m, diet).
- WoRMS: Astropecten polyacanthus Müller & Troschel, 1842.
- Encyclopaedic overview of A. polyacanthus (range, TTX study of 54 specimens; Wikipedia, 2023).
- Noguchi, T., Narita, H., Maruyama et al. (1982). Tetrodotoxin in the starfish Astropecten polyacanthus, in association with toxification of a trumpet shell, “boshubora” Charonia sauliae. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi 48. doi:10.2331/suisan.48.1173
- Narita, H., Matsubara, S., Miwa, N. et al. (1987). Vibrio alginolyticus, a TTX-producing bacterium isolated from the starfish Astropecten polyacanthus. Bulletin of the Japanese Society of Scientific Fisheries 53(4): 617–621.
- Miyazawa et al. (1987). Distribution of tetrodotoxin in various organs of the starfish Astropecten polyacanthus. Marine Biology. doi:10.1007/BF00412522
- KAKENHI project 62560211, final research report summary (1988): TTX in flatworm and starfish; ovary up to 12,700 MU/g (accessed 8 Nov 2026).
- Lin & Hwang (2001). Possible source of tetrodotoxin in the starfish Astropecten scoparius. Toxicon. doi:10.1016/S0041-0101(00)00171-9
- Wikipedia: Archaster typicus; Astropecten; Astropecten aranciacus; Astropecten irregularis.
Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.
About Blane Perun →