Exploring Earth's Oceans Since 1999 · Founded by Blane Perun
3,072 Articles·80+ Countries·25 Years of Ocean Science·Site Map
◆ Trending
25 years exploring Earth's oceans,
coral reefs, and the creatures within.
3,072Articles
80+Countries
1999Founded

Coral Farm Lighting: Metal Halide vs Power Compact Fixtures

Coral Farm Lighting — Metal Halide vs Power Compact Fixtures

My Coral Farm
November 7, 2026
12 min read
Lighting at a glance
Fluorescent trial
December 2002 to February 2003
Power quad PC
96 W; about $200 a fixture, $50 a bulb
PC verdict
Good colour and growth for three months, but costly per tank
MH alternative
One fixture about $200, bulb about $60, 18 in above water
Replacement
Two 250 W metal halide pendants
Old zoanthid system
Two 175 W MH pendants
Plan
MH from 175 to 400 W; SPS tank with two 400 W and a 1,000 W 20K

When sunlight through the skylights proved unable to carry the coral farm through winter, I had to choose artificial lighting, and I decided to try a range of the technologies on the market to learn from each. Within a few months most of those first fixtures were gone. This page covers what I tried, why the fluorescents and the power compact fixture came out, how the costs compared, and why I settled on metal halide for the rest of the farm. It also looks at how reef lighting has changed since, because the trade-offs I faced in 2003 still explain many of the choices growers make today.

How did the fluorescent fixtures do?

Both of the first fixtures, the dual 40-watt standard fluorescent strip and the VHO fixture, went in during December 2002 and were removed by February 2003. To my amazement, I still could not achieve the striking colour I had once had with Zoanthus in my previous system under 175-watt metal halides.

The strip light could have done it, but only from about three inches above the water; the light intensity needed for photosynthesis under those tubes requires that close a distance. In this application I was constantly moving the fixture up and down to work in the tank, which became a nuisance, so I bought a 20,000 kelvin metal halide fixture for that tank instead.

Why did the power compact fixture go?

For the large-polyp stony coral tank, I chose supplemental lighting from one of the new power quad compact fluorescent bulbs then on the market, which the manufacturer claimed equalled the output of a 175-watt bulb. I did see great colouration and growth under that fixture for three months, but I chose to sell it and replace it with metal halide.

The problem was mainly cost. The fixture cost about 200 dollars, and a replacement 96-watt bulb about 50. To light the tank adequately I would certainly have needed a second fixture, which meant about 400 dollars in fixtures and about 100 dollars for each set of replacement bulbs, with both fixtures kept relatively close to the water, about six to eight inches. For a little over 200 dollars I could put one metal halide fixture over the tank, some eighteen inches high, light the whole tank and have a bulb replacement cost of around 60 dollars. I decided to sell the fixtures and take a small loss rather than run them for a year with minimal results and then get far less than I had paid.

How did the outputs compare side by side?

In the photos from this stage you can see a ledge built around the perimeter of the ceiling to backlight the room, made wide enough to hide ballasts. Although the power compact fixture looks very bright, and I had grown under similar fixtures before at about seven inches off the water, it still was not enough to bring the colour out of the Zoanthus I once had. So it was sold and replaced with two 250-watt metal halide pendants. In my old system I had grown Zoanthus under two 175-watt metal halide pendants hung three inches from the water surface.

One photo shows corals under a 250-watt metal halide pendant next to the 96-watt power quad, which is switched on. The difference in output is dramatic. After seeing it, I certainly do not agree with the manufacturer’s claim that the power quad matches the output of a 175-watt fixture.

What was the plan for the rest of the farm?

From there I planned to fit the rest of the farm with metal halide fixtures, in wattages from 175 to 400 watts. For my small-polyp stony coral system I planned to run two 400-watt lights and a 1,000-watt 20,000 kelvin lamp, and I expected to have that system assembled and stocked by late summer. I planned to add PAR and lumen readings for all of the lighting choices once that was done.

Why does distance matter so much for fluorescents?

Fluorescent tubes produce light along their whole length and spread it in all directions. Without very good reflectors, much of the light goes sideways or upward rather than down into the tank, and the intensity reaching the corals falls quickly as the fixture is raised. That is why fluorescent fixtures over reef tanks were traditionally mounted just a few inches above the water, and why my strip light had to sit about three inches off the surface to grow colourful corals.

A fixture that close to the water has drawbacks: it gets splashed, it collects salt creep, it must be lifted every time you work in the tank, and it covers much of the surface. In a farm, where hands are in the water daily, those drawbacks add up quickly. A light that can hang well above the tank and still deliver the needed intensity is a great advantage.

Why did metal halide win?

Metal halide lamps are high-intensity discharge lamps: an electric arc passes through a gas containing metal halide salts inside a small quartz arc tube, producing very intense light from a compact source. Because the source is small, a good reflector can direct the light downward in a concentrated beam, and the lamp can be hung well above the water while still delivering strong light to the bottom of a shallow tank. One fixture can cover an area that would need several fluorescent fixtures.

That combination of intensity, penetration and coverage made metal halide the standard for stony coral tanks in the late 1990s and 2000s. It also produced the shimmering, dappled light that results from a point source passing through a moving water surface, which many reef keepers love. The drawbacks were heat, power use and bulb cost, though, as my figures show, in a farm the cost per area lit could be lower than with multiple fluorescent fixtures.

What do kelvin ratings mean?

Lamps are described by their colour temperature in kelvin. Lower values, around 5,500 to 6,500 K, look white or slightly yellow, similar to daylight; 10,000 K lamps look crisp white with a bluish tint; 14,000 to 20,000 K lamps look distinctly blue. Reef keepers often choose higher kelvin lamps because the blue light resembles the colour of light at depth on a reef and makes coral fluorescence glow.

Higher kelvin lamps generally produce less total light output than lower kelvin lamps of the same wattage, so there is a trade-off between appearance and intensity. Many growers combine lamps, or add blue actinic fluorescents, to balance the two. My choice of 20,000 K lamps for some tanks reflected the deep blue look and colour I wanted to bring out.

What about heat and safety?

Metal halide lamps run very hot, and their arc tubes emit ultraviolet radiation. Fixtures over tanks should have a glass shield, either built into the lamp or the fixture, to filter UV and to protect the lamp from water splashes, which can shatter a hot bulb. Hanging pendants high enough to avoid splashes and allow heat to dissipate also reduces the risk of overheating the water. In summer, a room full of metal halide lamps can add a great deal of heat, which is another reason ventilation was part of my farm design.

Ballasts for metal halide lamps, like those for fluorescents, should be kept dry and well ventilated. The perimeter ledge in my farm was built for that purpose, keeping ballasts away from the tanks and out of the splash zone.

How often should reef lamps be replaced?

Metal halide and fluorescent lamps lose output and shift in spectrum as they age, long before they burn out. Many reef keepers replace metal halide lamps roughly once a year and fluorescent tubes on a similar or shorter cycle, though practice varies with the lamp and how long it runs each day. Measuring with a PAR meter, rather than relying on how bright a lamp looks, is the best way to judge. Replacing lamps in a staggered sequence, rather than all at once, avoids sudden jumps in intensity that can stress corals.

How do you measure reef lighting?

Lux and lumens, the units used for room lighting, describe light as the human eye perceives it, weighted heavily toward green and yellow. Corals and their zooxanthellae use a broader range, including the blue light our eyes find dim. That is why reef keepers measure photosynthetically active radiation, PAR, with a quantum sensor that counts photons between about 400 and 700 nanometres equally. A blue 20,000 K lamp may look dimmer than a 6,500 K lamp yet deliver similar PAR.

Measurements should be taken under water, at the depth of the corals, across the whole tank, because intensity varies from directly under a lamp to the corners. A simple map of PAR readings across a rack shows where to place light-hungry corals and where shade-tolerant ones belong. Repeating the measurements as lamps age shows when replacement is due.

Where should different corals sit under the lights?

In a farm with a single lighting type over a tank, the position of each coral controls how much light it receives. Small-polyp stony corals and the most colourful zoanthids generally go nearest the centre of the light and highest in the water; large-polyp stony corals, mushrooms and many soft corals do well toward the edges or lower down. Corals moved from dimmer to brighter conditions should be acclimated gradually, by starting them low or at the edge and moving them up over a few weeks, to avoid bleaching.

That is one reason racks at adjustable heights, and space to move frags around, are so useful. They let a single tank serve several kinds of coral, and let each frag be placed where it grows and colours best.

What does lighting cost to run?

Electricity is a recurring cost that can outstrip the price of the fixtures. A 250-watt lamp running ten hours a day uses about 2.5 kilowatt-hours a day, or roughly 900 a year, before counting the ballast’s own losses; multiply that across a room of pendants, then add the cost of removing their heat in summer. Comparing fixtures by the light they deliver per watt, as well as by purchase and bulb costs, gives a truer picture of what a lighting choice will cost over several years.

How long should reef lights run each day?

Most reef keepers run their main lights for somewhere around eight to twelve hours a day, often with a shorter period of peak intensity in the middle and dimmer light at the start and end, imitating a natural day. Corals do not need light around the clock; they rely on a dark period, and many feed at night. Running lights longer than needed adds cost and heat without benefit, and can encourage nuisance algae. Timers make the schedule consistent, which matters more to corals than the exact length of the photoperiod. When new lighting is installed, or lamps are replaced with brighter ones, starting with a shorter photoperiod or raising the fixtures and then working back up over a couple of weeks gives corals time to adjust their pigments and zooxanthellae to the new intensity.

How has reef lighting changed since?

Since my farm was built, light-emitting diodes have largely replaced metal halide and fluorescent lighting in reef keeping. LED fixtures are efficient, run cooler, last for years without replacement and allow the spectrum and intensity to be adjusted and programmed, including sunrise and sunset ramps. Their small, intense point sources can be focused with optics to penetrate deep water, much like metal halides. Many coral farms now use LEDs, sometimes combined with fluorescent tubes or with sunlight in greenhouses.

The principles that guided my choices still apply: measure the light the corals actually receive, consider the cost per area lit rather than per fixture, keep fixtures out of the way of the work, and do not take manufacturers’ equivalence claims at face value.

What did this stage teach me?

Lighting is the area where it is easiest to spend money twice. The fluorescent and power compact fixtures were not bad lights; one grew corals well for three months. But for a farm where I wanted strong colour, wide coverage and room to work, they could not match metal halide on cost or performance. Selling them at a small loss early was better than running them for a year and selling them for far less. Seeing the 250-watt pendant beside the power quad settled the question for me.

Frequently asked questions

Why were the fluorescent fixtures removed?

They needed to sit about three inches off the water to colour up zoanthids and had to be moved constantly.

Did the power compact fixture grow corals?

Yes, with good colour and growth for three months, but it cost more per tank than metal halide.

How did the costs compare?

Two PC fixtures were about $400 with $100 in bulbs; one MH fixture about $200 with a $60 bulb.

Does a 96 W power quad equal a 175 W metal halide?

Not in my side-by-side comparison; the difference was dramatic.

What replaced the PC fixture?

Two 250-watt metal halide pendants.

What did I plan for the SPS tank?

Two 400-watt metal halides and a 1,000-watt 20,000 K lamp.

Sources & further reading
  1. Blane Perun, My Coral Farm series, TheSea.Org
  2. Joshi, S. & Riddle, D., articles on reef aquarium lighting and lamp output, Advanced Aquarist
  3. Borneman, E. H. (2001), Aquarium Corals: Selection, Husbandry and Natural History, Microcosm/T.F.H.
BP
Last updated November 7, 2026
Written by
Blane Perun

Blane Perun has been exploring Earth’s oceans and marine life for over 25 years. Founder of TheSea.Org in 1999, underwater photographer, coral aquaculture pioneer, and explorer of 80+ countries.

About Blane Perun →
Coral Aquaculture · The Pioneer Story
Blane Perun, A coral aquaculture pioneer

Built one of the first home reef tanks designed as a multi-zone replica of natural reef conditions. Author of long-form profiles cited by Wikipedia, Quality Marine, and SeaScope. Independent — no advertisers, no sponsored placements, no editorial board outside the dive log.

Widely credited as the pioneer of named-coral culture in the reef-keeping hobby. The original — “Perun's Purple People Eater”, a Protopalythoa morph from his coral farm — became the first hobbyist coral to carry an aquaculturist's name in trade, sparking the now-standard practice of naming individual coral strains across the industry.

Founded1999 Articles3,072 Countries80+ Cited inWikipedia · Quality Marine · SeaScope
Read Blane's full bio →
The Dispatch · Monthly

Field notes from eighty countries worth of ocean.

One monthly email. New long-form reporting, species profiles, and dive reports — no filler, no tracking pixels, no sponsored placements. Ever.

Sign up and get my one-click underwater color-correction actions for Photoshop — the set I run on my own dive shots. Free.

Get the action now + monthly field notes
No spam · Unsubscribe anytime
Underwater reef photo before and after Blane Perun's Photoshop color-correction action — washed-out blue-green on the left, full natural color restored on the right
Same shot · one click